If it Ain't Broke...!
You did something similar a few years ago and the reaction was similar - a huge outcry and you had to largely backtrack. The Reg v1 was the original and still the best.
You've now gone even worse than the changes you made then!
Please, please don't listen to the agency guys or go all web3. Just stick to what's made you successful in the first place - good info written up in a fun way in an easily readable format.
If it ain't broke, don't fix it!