* Posts by Vic

5860 publicly visible posts • joined 7 Dec 2007

Koala food may power US Defence force

Vic

> Vic's Vap-o-rub, not so much.

It's "Vicks".

Nothing to do with me.

Vic.

UK gov rejects call to posthumously pardon Alan Turing

Vic

> Oh, I see.

No, I don't think you do.

> So if you do a good turn you can commit a crime and expect a pardon.

No.

An *exceptional* person might occasionally be granted a pardon for an offence he has committed.

Any talk of expectation means you haven't grasped what a pardon is about; this isn't trading cards, it's the realisation by a state that, just very occasionally, someone warrants being let off something bad they *have* done because of the good stuff they have also done.

Vic.

Vic

> In bothe cases the reasonable answer is a resounding no. so what's the big deal about Turing?

You miss the point.

A pardon would not be an attempt to re-write history. It would not say that he didn't commit what was, at the time, a criminal act.

A pardon would say that he did commit the act, but that the state has decided to forgive him, on account of the vast numbers of people he helped save and the enormous contribution he made to what has become the modern world.

The pardon would not be because the law has changed, but because he was such an exceptional man.

So your points about speed limits just don't come into it.

Vic.

Vic

> Pardoning is only appropriate when there is doubt someone committed

> a crime by the standards of the time.

No, that's quashing a sentence.

A pardon is when there is no doubt that the person committed the crime but, for other reasons, the state has decided to forgive the act.

Vic.

Vic

> Does Repeal mean to remove and reverse as if it had never existed?

No.

Vic.

Vic

> does any country need a bunch of hereditary lords?

We need some sort of second chamber to counter the excesses of the first.

The hereditary principle is clearly anathema - but is it really any worse than stuffing the chamber with the appointees of the current PM?

Hereditary peers are clearly wrong. They just appear to be a little less wrong than the alternatives :-(

Vic.

Vic

> exonerating Turing

No-one is talking about exonerating him.

The proposal is for a pardon...

Vic.

Vic

> If you pardon him because the law he broke should never have been

> on the books in the first place, then you have to do the same for

> everybody else convicted under that same law.

No you don't.

A pardon doesn't say that someone should never have been found guilty; it says that someone *was* properly found guilty, but the State has since decided to expunge that guilt, not that it has decided to repeal the law.

It's not an appeal, it's a pardon...

Vic.

Job-seeking Marriott hacker gets 30 months' porridge

Vic

> you don't negotiate with terrrists neither, right?

I would.

Frankie Boyle had a good take on that - his plan was simply to outbid the terrorists.

"What's Allah offering you boys, 100 virgins? We'll give you 50 slags."

Vic.

Vic

No it wouldn't.

Giving in to blackmailers is always the expensive option.

Vic.

Mac OS X ARM port by Apple work experience kid revealed

Vic

> Porting an OS to an completely different chip in 12 weeks is no mean feat.

That depends on how portable the OS was to start with.

And SF has a Darwin-on-ARM project dating back to 2006, so this isn't groundbreaking work.

Good work-experience project, though.

Vic.

Vic

Of course Apple are playing with ARM

They'd have to be morons not to test the viability of an ARM port. But that's a very long way from saying they're going to ship one.

Still, it might improve the chances of ARM-based manufacturers telling MS to bog off with their "secure boot" idea...

Vic.

Parliament ponders £400,000 iPads-for-MPs plan

Vic

This should raise Government efficiency

Just look at how many secret documents you can give away by leaving a single iPad on a train...

Vic.

Apple tells authors: All your books iBook files are belong to us

Vic

> you're entitled to rebundle your work in a different format

That is actually the whole point of the article.

A previous version of the EULA laid claim to all versions - including pdf exports.

It is good that this restriction has gone away, but I still wouldn't be happy with what remains...

Vic.

Vic

@Colin

> I don't get it

You certainly don't.

> If you wanna take advantage of Apple's distribution network you pay their fee

If that is all that were happening, that would be perfectly fine.

But it isn't.

What Apple are saying is that, if you develop your own book with your own material, and use this piece of software to create something in the .ibook format, you may not distribute it for a profit unless you sign a deal with Apple first.

> otherwise you take your work which you own and distribute it some

> other way of your choosing.

If you wish to distribute as an ibook, that is explicitly prohibited by the licence agreement.

Now do you see why people are upset about this?

Vic.

Study links dimwits to conservative ideology

Vic

> English is a derivative of a form of German.

No it isn't.

The Teutonic root is just one if the ancestors of English. The Romance root is the other biggie. And we have all sorts of other influences as well.

English has pillaged the best bits from the languages of all our invaders, and come up with something that, until very recently indeed, was quite astoundingly expressive.

It is just a shame that we are throwing away our grammar and vocabulary at such a rate :-(

Vic.

Vic

> I like my conservative paladins

I just don't like paladins.

How can you play a character that can't get the hump and yell "fuck off" at someone?

Vic.

Google and Facebook remove 'offensive' content from Indian sites

Vic
Joke

This should be good for UK IT providers...

The First Commandment :- "Thou shalt have no other gods before me. "

So any non-Christian web page is fundamentally offensive to Christians.

The ensuing take-down wars should ensure that India is effectively isolated, and so all the outsourcing should die down...

Vic.

iOS 5 'crashes more apps' than Android

Vic

> dead happy with an Android app-auto-update to add malware.

You don't have to turn it on, you know.

It's selectable on a per-app basis. IIRC, it's also disabled if the app changes the permissions is requests.

I don't use it myself.

Vic.

PSN renamed Sony Entertainment Network

Vic

This is fairly standard Sony fare

In my time at Sony, I worked for four different Sony companies without changing desk...

Vic.

Doctors sick of anonymous-coward NHS feedback commentards

Vic

> I don't think I've ever had a call/email along the lines of "I just wanted

> to say that your stuff is brilliant and I love it."

I put in a big order to CPC a while back. On delivery, it was short one small item (which I didn't need urgently anyway).

I called them and asked if they would put one in the post sometime. It turned up the next day by courier.

So I called Customer Service & asked to speak to a manager. I got a very resigned tone when she picked up the call. I told her the story, the name of the woman who had helped me, and how happy I was with the service.

And she had no idea what to do with my call. I suspect I might have been the first ever occurrence of praise :-)

Vic.

Can Sony's new supremo make the sacrifices to save his biz?

Vic

> Yes, Sony is a quality product

Actually, this is frequently not the case.

When I joined Sony, it had exactly that reputation; you'd pay more money for a Sony product, but you'd get better quality. But that quality was often illusory - inside the box would be exactly the same reference design that everyone else was using. The name sold the product.

I left Sony when I could no longer stand pumping out shite product with a premium price.

Vic.

Google finally admits it wants to OWN YOU

Vic

> If anyone has a email tunnel-->SMTP converter

Errr - SMTP AUTH for inbound, and smarthost the outbound?

If your IP range is RBLed, either you've done something nefarious, or your upstream has been shown to be non-responsive when it comes to dealing with complaints.

It's a pain if you're caught[1] in this, but the alternative is much, much worse.

Vic.

[1] I got myself onto a blocklist a few weeks ago. I'd tried to mail from the command line on a machine where I'd forgotten to set up the domain name. When I put the machine on my own network, the mail was flushed through, and Google got my IP address put on a blocklist, where it remained for about twenty minutes. Silly mistake, easily fixed.

Euro watchdog asks Google to HALT privacy tweak

Vic

> on this side of the pond, it's 2-year contract or nothing

Are you living in the Land of the Free?

Sometimes it's easier getting by in the anachronism we have over on this side :-)

Vic.

Vic

> Noone with any sense uses it do they?

They do now.

I have an unpleasant suspicion that this is what Google's new "privacy policy"[1] is all about.

Android is very much on the rise. But using many of Google's embedded services means you associate each device with a gmail account. This change looks nastily like a land-grab of a whole bunch of data from Android users.

Vic.

[1] Ha!

BT reveals ultra-fast cable blowing plan for homes, biz

Vic

> Increasing the range surely will bring in more punters?

...But fewer "zomg" headlines.

Which do you think matters more to BT?

Vic.

Five ways Microsoft can rescue Windows Phone

Vic

> In the future the phone will be the portal to work

Not without additional hardware, it won't.

A phone screen does not fill enough of my field of vision to make it appropriate for work. And the keyboard input methods - be they on-screen or slide-out - are insufficient. Additionally, the lack of a solid base means I can't type with all ten fingers[1].

This all ads up to a serious lack of bandwidth[2] between *me* and the machinery. That means it is ineffective as a work tool.

Vic.

[1] I'm including thumbs, for the pedants.

[2] I know typing speed isn't everything[3], But if I'm forever scrolling around looking for stuff and fighting the input method, my productivity would definitely suffer.

[3] An ex-colleague of mine had a brilliant phrase[4]: "A week's keyboard-bashing can sometimes preclude the need for an hour's thought" :-)

[4] Yes, I did mean it like that. Please don't be tempted to "correct" it, as that means you missed the joke.

Vic

> Well can't help you with the difference between a live tile and a widget.

Please do. I can't see any significant differences...

Vic.

Vic

Disclosure: I sell SIP systems

> At my work, we recently shifted from a conventional phone system to VOIP

I do that too.

> using MS Lync

Not that, though.

> It's a strange experience being called on your office number while sitting at home on a laptop

My office numbers - and my home number - come through to my laptop, to my luggable (Snom 300) phone, to my Wifi phone, to my Android tablet, to my mobile phone, ...

I get full integration with my CRM system as well, as long as I'm on a "trusted" network connection[1].

VoIP is a useful way of doing things,. But don't fall into the trap of thinking Microsoft invented it.

Vic.

[1] I've got ways to get a phonebook out for anything I can download a phonebook to - but I've noticed that most phones don't have any security involved. So I just restrict the download to addresses I know are well-controlled - i.e. local LAN or VPN.

Vic

> Wife has a Galaxy and *HATES* it.

Tell her I'll offer her £20 for it...

Vic.

Vic

> This is Doro's problem.

I think Doro has a number of problems.

I've got a Doro IP phone. It (sometimes) connects to a WiFi network, and gives me a SIP line.

Nice idea, right? Unfortunately, it's shit. The biggest problem being that the battery only lasts the one day even if you turn it off

Putting crap products on the market will blight your outlook for a considerable time. Microsoft might like to remember that before releasing "early" versions of WinPho...

Vic.

New forum Wishlist

Vic

> I down-voted this because I hate you and look for all your posts and click the red hate button.

This is real.

On a couple of occasions, I've posted on a contentious topic - and my posts aren't often all that inflammatory. Suddenly, all the posts listed on the first page of my profile get downvoted...

Other fora have limits on how many times you can vote for one individual before voting for others as well. This might be a nice addition, if it doesn't mean too much coding.

Vic.

Vic

> used to be at the top of each reply.

Ah it's still there.

You needed to be in a chronological mode - "newest" or "oldest".

Vic.

Vic

Bah.

I should amend that the 'the "in reply to" link that used to be at the top of each reply.

Smeggin' code changes...

Vic.

Vic

> A "In reply to" link would do.

Like the "in reply to" link at the top of each reply, perhaps?

Vic.

Vic

Page order

Ok, here's my most recent wishlist item.

When selecting a forum from the "Your Forums" link on the right-hand side, the last page in a multi-page forum is always selected.

So if I've set a forum order to "Newest", I get the oldest page of posts (which is never what I want).

Can we have the page selected being dependent on the display mode, please?

Thanks!

Vic.

Vic

> several readers were opposed to threading in any form

That's a slightly strange attitude - but nevertheless...

On various other fora with which I am associated, there's usually some option to define the threading model displayed. So those that want nested comments get them, those that don't, don't.

But that's more code for you to write :-(

Vic.

Vic

> your very own avatars?

If you do this, can we also have the option never to see avatars?

They inevitably end up as an exercise in tastelessness...

Vic.

Demand for safety kitemark on software stepped up

Vic

> It starts very simply

If it were simple, do you think no-one would have done it?

> You have to conform fully to whatever standards you claim to comply with

Really? Do you realise that *most* code is not entirely standards-compliant, and deliberately so.

Years ago, I worked on a V.34 modem implementation. The standard required the call to be dropped in a number of circumstances; we reckoned to have about a 2% chance of getting the connection if we coded strictly to the standard. That's why no-one did; we put in re-tries. Everyone did. But under your rule, every modem would have to be recalled and replaced with something barely functional.

Got a software firewall? Most of them drop unwanted packets, rather than send RST as required by RFC793 (which opens you up to rapid port-scanning, and is a bad idea ). Under your rule, no-one would be permitted to sell such firewalls.

> It is the grown up thing to do

It most certainly is not. It's the plaintive cry from someone who's been bitten by crap software, but hasn't costed out the change from "good" code to "zero defect".

Vic.

Vic

Oh, good grief.

We already *have* safety qualification for software. It's covered in IEC 61508.

There are situations where it is absolutely required.

But anyone calling for this sort of thing just has no idea of the extra cost implications of SIL qualification. It's reasonable to expect 2 to 3 orders of magnitude more expense for any code you buy.

So that £50 game? It's now £50,000. Are you still going to buy it?

Zero-defect coding *is* possible, but makes little sense outside of aerospace and munitions development.

Vic.

Vic

> If you looked at the email, it automatically ran

That depends on how you look at it.

When very paranoid[1], I use "less". If that doesn't let me see what I want, I don't want that email.

Vic.

[1] Yes, yes, I'm usually pissed at that point.

OFFICIAL: Smart meters won't be compulsory

Vic

> unless your PC / router/ radio / whatever is less than a metre from the meter

I use ZigBee kit alongside WiFi at very close proximity.

They don't interfere with each other. That's the neat thing about spread-spectrum[1].

Vic.

[1] Spread-spectrum techniques have been used to minimise/eliminate the propensity for jamming or interception since they were first introduced over a century ago. You can run a transmitter below the noise floor and still get your message across...

Vic

No.

Vic.

Vic

> I have a variable frequency jammer which will jam these things

That's unlikely.

ZigBee is a spread-spectrum technology, so it's fairly resilient to narrowband jamming. And because it's a mesh topology, each unit only really needs to be able to communicate with the next-door neighbour.

Vic.

Google 'chooses' not to censor Mosley content, MP says

Vic

> Where the fk do they get these people?

It's Ben Bradshaw, the former Secretary of State that was so gushing in his praise of the NPfIT...

Vic.

Ye Bug List

Vic

That's broken it...

"Newest" and "oldest" thread ordering now appear to be identical...

Vic.

Trojan smuggles out nicked blueprints as Windows Update data

Vic

> And your alleged exploit will not work for even the version 1.8 of sudo.

Errr - yes, it will. There are a number of versions where this exploit is real.

There shouldn't be any still in the wild, though. Many distros aren't using a 1.8 version at all, and those that are should have patched it by now (Fedora certainly has; I haven't checked the rest) because I'm not that interested.

Vic.

Vic

> did you bother to read the link?

Yes, I did.

> v1.7.6sp2 is not affected.

I know. That's why I posted my output.

I wanted to get that in before someone who had not read the link went around telling the whole universe that G/L was forever hopelessly borked...

Vic.

Vic

> ./%s -D9

./%s: invalid option -- 'D'

> See how much more secure than Windows that was?

Indeed I do. Thanks.

Vic.

Climategate ruling: FOIA requests cover backup servers too

Vic

> that MS finally introduced the MOVE command for handling data.

It doesn't matter who introduced what - if you move data between two physically separate mass storage devices, you necessarily delete it from the first.

Vic.