* Posts by Mage

9273 publicly visible posts • joined 23 Nov 2007

Firefox-on-Windows users, rejoice: Game of Thrones now in HTML5

Mage Silver badge
Coat

Netflix is that it is so cheap and convenient

Not cheap. It's a huge amount a year. Also pointless unless you are top end speed DSL with no cap, Cable or Fibre.

It's a service for the affluent and privileged.

Mage Silver badge
Facepalm

not having support on many platforms ...

Smart TVs are a bad idea, likely provider X uses codec Z, management Q and DRM R next week/year/month and the TV "maker" (or real OEM) never releases new firmware, or if they do it's only OTA on one platform in another country, or impossible for joe soap to install.

At least a laptop as a final resort can be dual booted into unwanted OS U to get X, Z, Q and R.

Mage Silver badge

Re: ...of the dumbest ideas from dumbville

Yes, Adobe DRM added to ePub open standard: Books that tell someone what page you are on, and in the clear too!

Adobe DRM on PDFs, often scans of Public domain documents.

Purchased downloads and media should NEVER have DRM. It's immoral.

DRM on Streaming? Well, a decent HD camera and 42" HD monitor defeats it.

DRM is pointless and immoral. It only makes life more awkward for ordinary users, never stops commercial pirates and only for a short while stops casual home "pirates". Yet removes consumer rights, adds restrictions not in Berne Convention on copyright, allows corporations to "landgrab" public domain works and retain restrictions when copyright should have expired.

Some contracts and so called licences on Digital Downloads (not streaming) may not even be enforceable.

Did I mention DRM is pointless and immoral?

Well. I boycott pay TV and Subscription Streaming.

Assembly of tech giants convene to define future of computing

Mage Silver badge

Future?

We've seen it. Nothing new here at all. Even the marketing buzz words are getting stale.

From alchemy to brain-hacking: How to be better, forever

Mage Silver badge
Paris Hilton

Fantasy

Its not even proper SF, but Science Fantasy with wishful thinking!

MoJ digital software glitch sends thousands of divorcees back to negotiating table

Mage Silver badge

digital software?

So did they previously use an analogue hydrological computer programmed by dials?

How long until we can build R2-D2 and C-3PO?

Mage Silver badge

AI versus simulated Intelligence

We have made no progress at all on AI since 1946, all progress has been narrow areas of simulation and so called "Expert Systems". Much language in the AI field has been redefined. Computer Neural Networks are nothing of the sort. "Learning" and "Adaptive" is nearly a misuse of English. Successful language translation has almost abandoned grammar / parsing / semantics / context to use a brute force "Rosetta Stone" approach.

Speech recognition is nowhere near as good as Audio Typist, never mind a personal assistant. It just needs less "training" that it used to.

We don't yet have an adequate definition of natural Intelligence, so how can we define the program requirements much less write one? True natural language interaction rather than the Artificial Stupidity of phone response "robots", Siri and Cortana is very far away and probably needs true AI. It's not a question of computer power, or it could be done slowly.

Neal Stephenson in "The Diamond Age" asks is in fact real AI even possible with a "turing machine" (i.e. ANY computer). The "book" in the story certainly isn't possible today [ignoring issues of communication and charging] without even a real time team of humans, rather than the one person. The hardware and software of the "Book" is certainly feasible, though it's more like something implemented with eInk plastic paper than OLED or LCD.

In a way Project Xanadu is the first attempt at the "book" and while earlier than Apple's Hypercard (before HTTP/WEB) and HTTP/Web tries to solve some basic limitations of web pages.

The hardware of C3PO or R2D2 was possible even in 1977. Though power supply and balance for C3PO a problem then, now solved by e.g. Honda's robot (though I suspect power / running time is an issue).

Philips backs down over firmware that adds DRM to light

Mage Silver badge

Apple

Magsafe connector

Various generations of iPod / iPhone docks

The Apple Watch so called "wireless charger" plate*

Inability to use USB storage mode, you have to use iTunes or "cloud" to move data from iDevice with USB port even if you have a Mac.

[* So called wireless chargers are connector-less, the pad still needs a cable. Even madder is a Cordless kettle. It's a corded kettle with a really big plug!]

Mage Silver badge
Unhappy

Re: WTF happened to this once mighty company?

Before 1926 they only did light bulbs. Now they only do light bulbs and health products. They licensed the TV and HiFi badges to two different Asian companies, a step beyond outsourcing. Philips Electronics that did wonderful valves (Mullard from 1928) and later Transistors and ICs (inc Valvo and Mullard) was spun off ages ago as NXP.

They were the last serious European competitor to Asian Consumer Electronics.

Mage Silver badge

MS? No, more like Adobe and Apple

MS (after losing an EU case) is pretty open. Even before that very much was interoperable. Nor generally do MS create SW that only works with their H, or HW that only works with their accessories.

There is a good reason why retail OS X is a lot cheaper than retail boxed Windows.

Canadian live route map highlights vulnerabilities to NSA spying efforts

Mage Silver badge

Another good reason.

Another good reason to avoid outsourcing or using the so called "Cloud".

EE recalls all 'Power Bar' USB batteries due to 'fire safety risk'

Mage Silver badge

The Elephant in the room

Phones are too skinny, batteries too small for the consumption. My phone used to last all week.

I'd happily have a phone twice as thick as my Sony Xperia Z1 if the extra space was all battery.

Let's shut down the internet: Republicans vacate their mind bowels

Mage Silver badge

but unfortunately tweets do not write laws.

You joke I hope.

99.99% of tweets are irrelevant (a guess).

If Facebook and Twitter was closed the Internet would be improved.

Media takes far too much notice of Tweets. The BBC has plumbed new depths by not only having a feature article on their website of something trending on Twitter, but having BBC R4 program promoting what ever trendy thing on Twitter they picked.

We certainly don't want undemocratic, self selecting, minority activists using twitter to create laws.

However the US Politician ignorance of Internet, or indeed life outside USA, or the "West" and the sense of entitlement to >70%+ resources for < 16% of population is astounding.

Hapless Virgin Media customers face ongoing email block woes

Mage Silver badge
Coffee/keyboard

ISP and Google

No ISP should EVER be using any Google supplied service, especially eMail.

If they can't run their own email system why be an ISP?

Be afraid, Apple and Samsung: Huawei's IoT home looks cheaper and better

Mage Silver badge
Facepalm

IoT

There is no evidence yet that

a) We need this even if done properly

b) That anyone can do it properly

c) That just on the security aspect, there is no evidence that can be got right without both an expert supplier and a resident security expert (I've seen otherwise secure PCs or Routers with STUPID PAWN ME settings enabled by user trying to get a game working).

Mage Silver badge

Re: Huawei

Huawei are not actually the Chinese State. They even have complained about the state owned Chinese companies getting preferential treatment.

Besides if you are NOT Chinese / Tibetan / Taiwanese / North Korean etc which is worst:

1) NSA

2) GCHQ

3) Chinese Government

4) Israelis (10% of security products shipped!)

5) Russia

Bigger than Higgs? Boffins see hints of bulbous new Boson

Mage Silver badge

Boffins

Aren't they wonderful?

When is Boffin Day so I can toast them?

Samsung appeals to Supreme Court to bring patent law into 21st century

Mage Silver badge

Re: The law is a Ass

The iPhone used commodity parts, was basically samsung chips glued to an iPod and the fingerworks GUI added to a cut down port of OS X (As MS did to get WinCE for PDAs and later phones from NT).

The original iPhone used a Samsung stock 6400 family ARM SoC.

Other people used resistive screens because "handwriting" and Annotation was a holy grail (From early Palm and Apple Newton devices). Capacitive screens existed from 1980s but ignored due to poor resolution.

Using a finger orientated GUI rather than miniaturised standard WIMP GUI with stylus was the ONLY "innovation" and not IMO patentable as it wasn't new, just not the fashion. Nothing else at all in the original iPhone was innovative, all stock parts. Apple bought their own ARM SoC designers later.

Mage Silver badge
Mushroom

Design Patent approximately UK Registered Design

It's crazy that such a pre-existing design style that is so generic and not at all distinctive was allowed to be registered by Apple.

The Fluted Coca-Cola bottle is a good example that deserves it. A rounded rectangle with touch screen and icons does not.

It shows how broken and partisan the US system is that Apple should be awarded this so called patent,, that it should be enforced and that the penalty is set at 100% by Congress rather than a realistic assessment of damages. If the "design patent" is really valid (which is stupid!) then Apple should only be a awarded a symbolic 1c in damages. It's not an original concept, nor is it likely anyone anywhere intending to buy an Apple phone buys an alternative because it's a similar shape.

Old jet bits, Vader's motorbike gear, sonic oddness: Hats off to Star Wars' creative heroes

Mage Silver badge

Star Wars’ early use of stereo sound,

Stereo is mostly irrelevant to effects, really and was developed in 1930s (Alan Blumlien in EMI). BBC was using stereo on radio earlier than starwars and Stereo radio development (late 1950s, though BBC roll out was much later) was long after Stereo records were 1st produced..

However Lucas did make use of the effects channel, the .1 of 5.1, Surround sound though also predates Starwars.

Many Lucas films have well done 5.1 sound tracks.

Seagate wears dunce's cap in hi-cap disk ship slip

Mage Silver badge

Helium famously leaks.

What is the life of these magical helium drives?

Maybe Seagate is smart.

How do you keep the helium in?

Microsoft extends Internet Explorer 8 desktop lifeline to upgrade laggards

Mage Silver badge

Re: @Mage - Also XP isn't quite dead yet

a) Majority of XP systems not regularly patched anyway, so makes not much difference.

b) Many vulnerabilities are blocked by firewall/router

c) Most bad stuff is now from Internet, not shared disks, people click and install it. Or it can be mitigated by NoScript etc (Which I run on Linux as malware isn't the only issue it solves).

d) People with Win10 and 3rd party AV can be as easily infected if clueless and keep clicking on OK, installing toolbars, fake codecs, opening attachments, etc.

ActiveX in a browser. A stupid idea, in an ideal world who ever signed off that in MS should be in prison. Might as well send all kids past puberty to a brothel for every birthday party.

Mage Silver badge
Trollface

Also XP isn't quite dead yet

Probably more stuff runs XP than Win 10 as nearly all Win10 is on the Internet (it's broken otherwise) and some computer users and applications can't get, or don't want or must not have Internet. Meanwhile some people telling their XP Workstation and Win 2003 server that it's a POS terminal and getting Server 2003 and XP patches for free.

Are second-hand MoD IPv4 addresses being used in invoice scams?

Mage Silver badge

Not about IP range

Relying on the IP address to validate anything is nuts.

Paying bogus invoices is incompetence.

Nokia, ARM, twisting Intel bid to reinvent the TCP/IP stack for a 5G era

Mage Silver badge

3G vs 4G

Main differences:

No native voice on 4G. 3G and 2G voice is native, early data modems simply used the voice modulation, hence 245kbps on 3G and 14.4kbps on GSM. HSPA on 3G adds non-voice modulation modes to the CDMA hopping carrier to increase data rate, depending on link S/N. GSM EDGE is also a trick using different modulation to original GSM to get 200Kbps + There is a version of GSM (not used) for data only called ERMES+ that can do 2.4Mbps and native IP only (no voice). Superior to 3G HSPA as there is no cell breathing and speed is consistent. But bad for marketing as can't compete on peak speed.

3G has no native IP, IP is native on 4G

3G is a wider band version of CDMA-1, typically 5MHz CDMA coded channels. 4G (on downlink at least) uses COFDM or even COFDMA (loads of separate carriers, in 1MHz, 2MMHz, 5MHz, 10MHz or 20MHz channels. GSM uses a 0.2MHz carrier. CDMA 1.25MHz, or 3G 5MHz, is a single carrier frequency hopping in a known pseudo random fashion. Each link is different key. If all keys are used up, then the data is multiplexed, voice and data are different for 3G and HSPA version of 3G.)

Flash-OFDM, Wimax and LTE are 4G systems.

WiFi can be CDMA or COFDM depending on version.

There are real 4G specs, though the important ones for 4G mobile are all LTE, which is certainly NOT at tweaked 3G, it's as different as 3G is from GSM (2G). The 3G is however based on USA 2G (CDMA-1), I guess Qualcomm wanted more money.

Mage Silver badge

Re: IPv6 Mobile

" IPv6 was designed from the ground up to cope with mobile devices."

Err.. citations?

I've never ever seen that claimed before. Other than the addressing size and giving the same IMEI the same v6 IP every time. (Which might be a bad idea for privacy!)

"the need to maintain a static IP address while moving from mast to mast and (potentially) roaming between different subnets."

That's a completely separate issue. It's still not very reliable. Switching between 3G,4G and WiFi without losing a session is really hard. It's possible and IPv6 is nothing to do with it. Switching between mobile 4G sites with IPv4 works fine, was testing it in 2007.

Mage Silver badge

Re: What about IPv6?

3G has "voice HD". It has a choice of codecs. 4G can't use some of the 3G and 2G codecs as they are less than optimal for TCP/IP UDP type networks. VOIP needs codecs optimised for TCP/IP unless you know the latency and packet loss is very low, even then the native "wireless" codecs have wasteful frame sizes for IP traffic

Mage Silver badge

Re: Voice on 4G

You'd care if other people's voice calls was only carried on 4G. The data speeds might be 1/4 for you.

Mage Silver badge

Re: What about 2G, 3G, 4G?

No-one is "going for 5G" already. It's still an ill defined concept, possibly more about integrating infrastructure. There is no 5G standard yet, nor any 5G base stations or software or hardware.

Mage Silver badge

Re: What about IPv6?

No, IPv6 mainly addresses the addressing issues. It does have some other "fixes", but still inherently not good for Wireless. If it was, then Satellite systems would use it natively on the links (nearly 90,000km each way, ground station to user.), they don't.

Mobile / Wireless needs a protocol designed for massively variable speed, packet loss and latency, which can vary from excellent to really bad in minutes for a given link. Also the number of user connections per sector can vary from 1 (20Mbps) to 20+ (0.12Mbps) during a transaction without the addition of weather, movement, interference (even from other cells) or whatever affecting the speed, latency and packet loss. IPv6 doesn't make a huge improvement over IPv4 for that scenario. Also Mobile has the philosophy that individual users get all of the bandwidth available, rather than throttling back power (reducing inter cell interference and increasing battery life) when 1 or 2 users compared to 5 users in a sector. It's pretty garbage anyway for more than 10+ serious users of data (c.f. 3G where about 100 native voice calls are possible).

4G is really really inefficient for voice calls compared to 2G and 3G native voice frames as it's carried as VOIP using TCP/IP to setup and control, then UDP streams. Hence most operators with 4G & 3G make your voice calls use 3G or even 2G!

Mage Silver badge
Boffin

Misleading.

" optimized for the massively varied use cases of the next mobile generation, for cloud services, and for virtualization and software-defined networking (SDN)."

Only wireless is different from point of view of TCP/IP stack and protocol compared to the others.

"Cloud Services" = Remotely connected servers, nothing new here.

"Virtualization" is irrelevant.

" software-defined networking (SDN)" isn't really about TCP/IP at all. It's infrastructure management.

Radio unlike cable*, fibre and in house networking suffers from variable packet loss (other fixed cable/optical links have almost none to zero) which can be high. Wireless has unpredictable variable latency and speed too. The other technologies at the link level are pretty much fixed latency and speed. So TCP/IP is really poor for wireless, especially outdoor wireless like mobile. The ultimate "wireless" is satellite. It doesn't bother with TCP/IP at all. Best to imagine each end of two way link is a pair of proxy servers with a special protocol between them. That's why a VPN is garbage performance on Satellite unless the satellite ISP has your VPN endpoint in your modem and recreating the VPN at their Groundstation.

This is why 4G stuck with TCP/IP, though really a poor solution for mobile, as without being more clever than the Satellite modem folks, lots would be broken.

So this is really ONLY about mobile and how to have not TCP/IP over the wireless transparently to all existing traffic. Look at IP V6. Is the end user or average business going to change to an alternative to TCP/IP?

Anyone today can do their own design of TCP/IP implementation on their OS (virtualised, cloudy or not) as long as to the external network port that it meets the spec!

[* DSL, VDSL etc and other schemes over Cat 3 (phone wires) is more like Radio than cable or fibre. Unlike actual outdoor Mobile, the latency and link speed is constant for a given pair of wires, but the packet loss / interference issues can be like WiFi or Mobile. A powerline Ethernet adaptor or electric fence can disrupt DSL]

Adobe: We locked our customers in the cloud and out poured money

Mage Silver badge

Re: Where are the GIMP fan boys?

Future Alternatives: Paint Shop pro had promise at Ver 7.

Corel bought it and messed it up.

Gimp isn't as bad as it used to be, but I'm going to see can I install PSP7 on WINE!

There does seem to be some alternative to Adobe Ransomeware for some people.

Mozilla backs away from mobile OS as Android looks invincible

Mage Silver badge
Flame

passing era of native apps, downloads and a ‘fat device’

Daft ejits if they think a mobile connection can ever replace local apps and local music and local photo taking and local note writing. Even Chromebook backtracked on that.

I don't want a cloudy phone. I don't want to rent services, experience out of coverage errors and have a data bill. Actually I'd like all the Google "cloudy" services such as Playstore and Location to be able to be disabled, manual or automatic/startup like on Windows or Linux.

I'm quite happy with USB storage mode too, to put stuff on/off from laptop.

Facebook one-ups Google with open hardware release

Mage Silver badge
Alert

If this is so good ...

Why is Facebook such a piece of uselessness?

'Personalised BBC' can algorithmically pander to your prejudices

Mage Silver badge
Paris Hilton

This is stupid.

People tend to only consume more of the same. People will be aided in being narrow in taste and outlook, prejudices reinforced.

The exact opposite of BBC Charter.

Brit-American hacker duo throws pwns on IoT BBQs, grills open admin

Mage Silver badge
Flame

What next?

Internet connected toilets? IoT

Vacuum cleaners, wood burning stoves, coal bunkers, mirrors, beds, floors ...

All madness.

Eurocrats deserve to watch domestic telly EU-wide, say Eurocrats

Mage Silver badge

Ireland

The UK is 20x bigger market. So FTA Irish TV over UK would make TV for IRISH viewer prohibitively expensive for bought in content OR locally made. Any content that UK broadcasters have rights for would them be unavailable at ANY price to Irish broadcasters

Also Ka-Sat has no crippling EPG costs.

Sky ought to be paying RTE etc for the 28.2 Encrypted content. They get it free which makes Sky Ireland competitive.

Sky Encryption, Sky EPG, Freesat EPG, 28.2 Carriage. EACH of those alone is more expensive than Ka-Sat, which RTE uses as a transmitter site backup feed. Sky was charging RTE a fortune for the viewing cards for transmitter sites! So Ka-Sat, which is fill in for people pay TV licence in IRELAND, is essentially free.

The shame is that carriage on Ka-Sat is optional. So TV3 and I think UTV Ireland are not on it as the small cost is more than any additional revenue for 1% to 2% of viewers.

There was originally the Solas Card. The money paid to sky was enormous. Then when BBC, ITV and C4 closed the scheme, Sky had "Freesat from Sky" card for small charge. Puppy dog trojan advertising to get full sub.

Tara went bust on Sky because of the costs of Sky EPG and Encryption. Sky provides this free in Ireland for RTE etc as otherwise Sky PayTv can't compete with Cable (UPC/Virgin and now Eir as well as Crossey). Sky would charge RTE more per channel for UK EPG and Encryption so much that TV licence cost would double!

Mage Silver badge

Only eight per cent of 26,000 Europeans polled had actually tried

Because folk

a) Know they can't get a sub.

b) in UK your dish only gets UK content unless it's multifeed or you have a 2nd one, Sky almost satellite Pay TV monopoly.

c) Newer satellites have narrower spots so pan Western Europe is now needing a very big multifeed or motor dish, or in case of Ka Sat tiny spots and frequency re-use, out of area is impossible even if you have a 4.8m dish.

Bitcoin inventor Satoshi 'outed' as Aussie, then raided by cops – but not over BTC

Mage Silver badge
Facepalm

Re: Tulip Trading

Visa are nuts if they are serious about bitcoin.

IBAN will be the basis of a sensible Universal Electronic Currency, not PayPal or Bitcoin. The only current obstacle is the USA.

Mage Silver badge

Re: Tulip Trading

One does wonder if BitCoin is a clever ponzi scheme and if someone "engineered" the mad Tulip "investment" bubble ... The name surely is a deliberate joke?

At the peak of tulip mania, in March 1637, some single tulip bulbs sold for more than 10 times the annual income of a skilled craftsman. It is generally considered the first recorded speculative bubble (or economic bubble),[3] although some researchers have noted that the Kipper- und Wipperzeit episode in 1619–22, a Europe-wide chain of debasement of the metal content of coins to fund warfare, featured mania-like similarities to a bubble.[4] The term "tulip mania" is now often used metaphorically to refer to any large economic bubble (when asset prices deviate from intrinsic values).[5]

The 1637 event was popularized in 1841 by the book Extraordinary Popular Delusions and the Madness of Crowds, written by British journalist Charles Mackay. According to Mackay, at one point 12 acres (5 ha) of land were offered for a Semper augustus bulb.[6] Mackay claims that many such investors were ruined by the fall in prices, and Dutch commerce suffered a severe shock. Although Mackay's book is a classic, his account is contested. Many modern scholars feel that the mania was not as extraordinary as Mackay described and argue that not enough price data are available to prove that a tulip bulb bubble actually occurred.[7][8]

Wikipedia, may contain nuts.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tulip_mania

Mozilla confirms its Firefox OS phones are dead

Mage Silver badge

Re: We don't need no steenking reading comprehension!

" Google Glass got the same treatment, and you know what? That's still not dead, either."

Unfortunately

Mage Silver badge

Mad.

They lost sight of their mission.

Google says its quantum computer is 100 million times faster than PC

Mage Silver badge

Re: sorry, not a geek but

It's only fast for a very limited class of problem. We still are not sure what is in the box. It's not an actual quantum computer, but obviously different to a conventional CPU, GPU or possibly different to a FPGA implemented specialist processor.

Hence Google calling it "Quantum Annealing"

Battery-free IoT sensor feeds off radio waves

Mage Silver badge
Paris Hilton

Hype

The 5m is optimistic, with RF quiet environment and large direction receiver, unless this is a perpetual motion machine breaking the laws of physics.

A 2.5cm to 20cm range is more realistic. It doesn't matter how little power the chip uses. Even if it has a BIG capacitor and only transmits in 1:100 duty cycle low data rate bursts.

You can't fit any kind of sensible WiFi aerial on a 2mm x 2mm chip either.

This is no different to an RFID chip, simply sending temperature rather than an ID Tiny range unless less specialist kit to power and talk to it and listen to it. "Smart Building" uses are fantasy.

US Navy's newest ship sets sail with Captain James Kirk at the bridge

Mage Silver badge

Bit retro?

Reminds me of some of the old PRE Victorian dreadnaughts and ironclads.

I'd not like to be in it if it's hit broadsides by a wave!

Unsourced, unreliable, and in your face forever: Wikidata, the future of online nonsense

Mage Silver badge

Re: Footnotes

Unless there are cats.

You know cats are NUDE under the fur?

Mage Silver badge

Re: I'm puzzled by the example

"I think you'll find that the reason everyone moved their embassies to Tel Aviv is, officially at least, that they consider Tel Aviv"

That would be IDENTICAL to people outside USA deciding New York is USA Capital not Washington.

You may hate it, but UN has ruled Israel has a right to exist, and the Newer part of Jerusalem has never been part of any State than Israel. Only Britain and Pakistan recognised the illegal Jordanian annexation of East Jerusalem / Old City and the "West Bank" (Occupation 1948 to 1967).

Syria doesn't recognise Jerusalem as anyone's capital as they regard Israel, Lebanon, West Bank, part of Gaza and Jordan as "missing" Syrian territory.

Before 1948 there was the British Palestine Mandate, most of which today is Jordan.

Before that the area was a part of the Syrian provence of Ottoman Empire.

Nations can pick ANYWHERE in their Territory as Capital. Only the Old City is disputed and claimed by the Palestinians. That isn't recognised by UN.

Mage Silver badge
Paris Hilton

I'm puzzled by the example

It would have been interesting if it claimed Jerusalem is capital of Jordan or Palestine. It's never been the actual capital of anywhere other than Israel, though Jordan illegally occupied the "old city" part from 1948 to 1967.

It's true that due to Arab and Moslem threats everyone moved their Embassies to Tel Aviv, but it's not the capital.

However Wikidata sounds bonkers.

EC fires antitrust charges at Qualcomm over its pricing tactics

Mage Silver badge
Flame

Qualcomm are well ... understood.

People do business with Qualcomm because there sometimes is no alternative. Though they make stuff, they annoy everyone in the industry with their lack of commitment to products. They want to make all their income from licensing, IP etc.

Windows Phone won't ever succeed, says IDC

Mage Silver badge

Re: Does anyone think this is a good thing?

SQL wasn't a Microsoft product. They bought in Sybase.

They DID write GUI Word and GUI Excel -- Ironically first of all for Mac

Visio, Powerpoint bought in. Access was and is pointless.

MS DOS bought in

Win NT piggybacked on OS/2 and VMS with the Win 3.x shell (copied like Mac from Xerox).

CE was a cut down NT.

Like Google and Apple, there are very few successful from scratch MS products. Or much real innovation.