* Posts by Steve Todd

2154 posts • joined 19 Sep 2007

Plymouth 'animal rights' teen admits Florida SeaWorld cyber attack

Steve Todd
Silver badge

@ukgnome

So you went in completely open minded and gave an objective opinion then?

5
0

'I urge everyone to fight back' – woman wins $10k from Microsoft over Windows 10 misery

Steve Todd
Silver badge

@dwonk786

I think you'll find that Apple will tell you about new versions of their OS, but won't force you to install the upgrade. THATS the way that MS should be working, a simple offer of the new version and a graceful acceptance if it is declined.

4
0

Special delivery: Activists drop 100,000 net neutrality complaints on FCC

Steve Todd
Silver badge

Re: That's an easy one...

[Harvard] isn't an ISP. They are not breaking net neutrality by providing a free service any more than Google or El Reg are. The local ISP would be breaking net neutrality if they only provided a subset of the net for free, rather than an alowance. What if, for example Oxford or the Sorbon decide to offer free courses also. The locals wouldn't be able to access them under the scheme you describe, even though they may be better for some if not all users.

Also just because something is held up to be good by TPTB doesn't mean that Internet users should be forced to take it. The point of neutrality is to let the users decide what they want rather than forcing particular systems on them.

1
0
Steve Todd
Silver badge

Re: Be careful...

So speaks someone who has completely failed to understand net neutrality. ISPs are allowed to manage traffic for quality of service reasons, but can't prioritise one service above another based on payment by the originator. They can't for example charge Netflix to give priority to their video over other video streaming services, but they can slow down all video steaming if the network is congested.

8
2

Fujitsu picks 64-bit ARM for Japan's monster 1,000-PFLOPS super

Steve Todd
Silver badge

Re: This is why AMD and NVidia are making ARM chips

@bazza - you are joking about Itanium right? It was always going to be a technical disaster. It relied on static compile time organisation of the code rather than dynamic run time out of order execution, so it couldn't adapt to changes. It emulated the x86 (badly), and took a bunch of silicon to do that. It was very late, and never got the critical mass required to make a modern CPU profitable. All in all Intel had holes in their heads when they came up with the idea.

3
0

Apple and Android wearables: What iceberg? It’s full steam ahead!

Steve Todd
Silver badge

Is that the sound of an ax being ground?

One could be mistaken for thinking that Mr Orlowski has something in for smart watches, rather than just hit whoring that he usually does. He personally can't see the point in them, but apparently there are millions of people who can. If you don't want something then don't buy it. Don't think yours is the only opinion though, and don't try to put down those who think otherwise. If the manufacturer makes money out of their product then enough people have voted that they disagree with you.

1
9

Net neutrality victory: DC court backs full rules

Steve Todd
Silver badge

@ac - one sock puppet quoting another

The problem is that cable companies aren't investing in expanding their networks to large areas of the US, and that their service levels are poor for the areas that they do serve. Some tame accademic claiming that the cable companies offer better value triple pay packages doesn't change that, and isn't useful if you only want broadband. Some service for less than the cost of an (expensive) triple pay package is better than no service at all.

1
0
Steve Todd
Silver badge

@donn bly - you seem quick to forget

That municipal broadband schemes are a reaction to the cable companies failures to provide the coverage and service levels that they promised when they were granted their licences. Without incentive to compete and improve their service they have rested on their laurels while most of the first world passed them by.

Put another way, they demonstrably weren't investing beforehand, so any argument that municipal broadband stops them investing is purest bullsh*t.

2
2

Sophos U-turns on lack of .bat file blocking after El Reg intervenes

Steve Todd
Silver badge

Re: Hang on a second

Like all Un*x variants OSX has an Executable bit in the permissions for a file (rwx flags). You can mark anything you want as executable (though it may not run unless it contains a binary).

0
0

ARM Cortex-A73: How a top-end mobe CPU was designed from scratch

Steve Todd
Silver badge

Re: Vulnerabilities

How about never? Branch prediction isn't something code sees. If the prediction is correct then code executes seamlessly. If it misses then there's a pipeline stall while the correct instructions are loaded and executed. Your code has no sight over or access to the predictor, and it is still subject to the memory management unit allowing it access the code in the first place.

8
0

Michael Dell bought his PC biz for a bargain, must get checkbook out for stiffed shareholders

Steve Todd
Silver badge

Re: On a related matter

The price paid was above current market at the time. Value is what the market is prepared to pay, not what you hope you can sell something for.

8
0

Boring SpaceX lobs another sat into orbit without anything blowing up ... zzzzz

Steve Todd
Silver badge

Re: "...angular velocity..."

@dwarf, if an orbiting rocket applies a burst of thrust in the direction of the orbit then the altitude of the orbit will increase and the velocity will decrease until there is once more a balance between gravity trying to pull the rocket down and Newtonian physics trying to keep it going in a straight line. Climbing out of the gravity well takes energy, and that energy is subtracted from the kinetic energy (mass x velocity) of the craft. It seems counter intuitive, but low orbits are fast orbits.

0
0

UK govt admits it pulled 10-year file-sharing jail sentence out of its arse

Steve Todd
Silver badge

Re: So is anyone going to be held to account?

@h4rm0ny - it wasn't just the public who were saying that 10 years is too long, it was parliament and the independent review. I've nothing against harmonising the sentences, but the implication is that the sentence for physical rather than online breach of the law is too high.

The other objection is the sloppiness of the drafting. Make it clear what is considered a serious offence under this law or it WILL get used on folks sharing torrents.

10
0
Steve Todd
Silver badge

Re: So is anyone going to be held to account?

@h4rm0ny - so you missed the stuff about parliament saying no, 10 years is too long, we need an independent review, and the review saying no, it's too long, and more than 2/3rds of all the responses for comment saying that it was too long also? What do we get after all of that? They try to push through 10 years again.

As with most badly framed and thought out laws, what starts out as something targeted at serious crime ends up being used against people committing low level indiscretions. Trying to create laws based on the cries of a special interest group, without taking in to account public opinion and without proper attention to its effects is bound to end in tears.

12
1

Woz says wearables – even Apple Watch – aren't 'compelling'

Steve Todd
Silver badge

Re: Cars

@AC - because semi trucks with failed brakes are something we have to contend with on a daily basis? People made that kind of stupid edge case when it came to seatbelt laws also. You stand a much better chance of survival in an accident with a belt than without. There is a small chance that the belt will hinder rather than help, but this is outweighed considerably by the chance of it helping. The same applies here.

4
1

US anti-encryption law is so 'braindead' it will outlaw file compression

Steve Todd
Silver badge
Stop

The US has the highest per-capita prison population in the world, and you want to make it bigger? I'd suggest that as a policy it's not working, nor are US prisons cosy hotels that no one would want to leave.

Part of the objective of the system should be to rehabilitate offenders, and if you give them no incentive to behave and improve themselves then that isn't going to happen.

8
0

Intel takes aim at Arduino with US$15 breadboard

Steve Todd
Silver badge

STM's nucleo line are $10 each

Are faster, have more storage, use less power and have more software support. Tell me again why I should consider an Intel x86 CPU (that won't actually run normal x86 code, it's not fully compatible)?

2
0

3D printers set for lift off? Yes, yes, yes... at some point in the future

Steve Todd
Silver badge

Re: Consumer device?

You need a good deal more skill, time, effort and space to use a hobbyist grade lathe or mill than you do a 3D printer, and you'll pay a lot more for your feedstock (there's a lot of wastage in the machining process).

What may make a difference is the expiration of the key patents for Selective Laser Sintering type systems. They allow the creation of parts from powdered materials including plastics and metals, and once out of patent the machine costs should fall.

3
0

Mud sticks: Microsoft, Windows 10 and reputational damage

Steve Todd
Silver badge

Re: It's the data harvesting

So you're arguing over the semantics of the word "copy"? Simply put a copy is the same or close to the original. MacOS was radically different from Xerox STAR (not least of which because it wasn't a pre-emptive multi-tasking system), and was the fruit of a lot of research by Apple into human/computer interaction and GUI design. Apple literally wrote the book on how to do much of that.

The best you could argue is that SOME ideas were copied from STAR, and that Xerox were paid for their use. To use the hated car analogy, at most Apple bought a STAR chassis, then created their own engine and bodywork to produce something quite different.

Microsoft likewise copied STAR concepts for Windows 1.0, but for Windows 2.0 they copied ideas from Apple without payment or permission (and if you think Windows = Finder then you're an idiot). As I said previously, it was those parts that Microsoft lifted (like redrawing uncovered sections of a window) that caused Apple to sue them.

0
2
Steve Todd
Silver badge
FAIL

Re: It's the data harvesting

@Pompus git - Firstly "taking an idea and running with it" does not imply theft, it implies that it is built on and improved from the original. Secondly you implied that Xerox's ideas became unavailable to researchers once Apple used them. Untrue. The original ideas were implemented by Microsoft in Windows 1.0 and that wasn't a problem with Apple. Windows 2.0 used Apple's extended ideas, which is where lawsuits started (and were ultimately a failure because copyright wasn't strong enough protection).

0
2
Steve Todd
Silver badge

Re: It's the data harvesting

"So when Apple were running away with PARC's windows, icons, menus and pointing device ideas, they became completely unavailable to the researchers any more because they weren't copies. How does that work? Curious minds and all that."

Firstly Xerox were actually paid for Apple seeing and making use of the ideas from PARC. Secondly Apple didn't claim ownership of the Xerox ideas. What they claimed were the ideas they had come up with themselves in the approximately 5 years between them seeing the PARC system and the Macintosh. Things like repainting uncovered portions of windows automatically.

See http://www.catb.org/esr/writings/taouu/html/ch02s05.html for some of the history.

0
1
Steve Todd
Silver badge

Re: It's the data harvesting

@Pompus Git - Um, no. Take a look at the original PARC/STAR GUI and compare it to that of the Lisa/Mac. The Apple version is obviously not a copy. They took some of the ideas and ran with them. Others they forgot about, yet more were completely new to the Mac. They even back-ported some of the ideas in the Mac to the Lisa. The metaphors of a GUI settled down and standardised in large part due to the manuals that Apple wrote on how to design a good GUI.

0
3

Monster motor breathes fire in Mississippi

Steve Todd
Silver badge

Ah, I was right the first time. The cross-check had the division the wrong way around.

1
1
Steve Todd
Silver badge

Running a cross check, an Olympic pool contains about 660000 US gallons (this is NASA we're talking about) so 660000 / (1500 X 500) = 0.88 Olympic swimming pools.

2
0
Steve Todd
Silver badge

It's only about 1.13

Olympic swimming pools according to the El Reg unit converter (though it seems to lack Gallons as an input unit, so I had to use cubic inches).

2
0

Ad-slinger Opera adds ad-blocking tech to its browser

Steve Todd
Silver badge

Re: Eh?

The early Oric 1 was horribly bug ridden. Printer output was corrupted by the key scanner routine for example. The keyboard was also unpleasant to use. They fixed both of those things with the Oric Atmos (and if you knew what you were doing you could burn a copy of the Atmos ROMs and drop them in to the 1) but it was too little too late. At that point it was the lack of software support that killed it.

0
0

IBM to erase 14,000 people from the payroll – Wall St analyst

Steve Todd
Silver badge

Stop me if I'm wrong

But if you have a company with falling sales, and part of the reason for that fall is crappy customer service, then offshoring jobs is going to (a) do nothing to stem that and (b) demotivate the staff resulting in poor service. How can IBM management not spot the obvious?

19
0

E-borders will be eight years late and cost more than £1bn

Steve Todd
Silver badge

Re: Government IT?

That seems to be the general problem. Getting them to nail down a requirement spec and then stick to it for at least as long as it takes to create a system which matches it. Politicians seem to feel a compulsive need to tinker with requirements while development is in progress.

6
0

Ad-blockers are a Mafia-style 'protection racket' – UK's Minister of Fun

Steve Todd
Silver badge

Like the TV companies

The ratio of adverts to content has to be acceptable to the viewers, and they don't have to be forced to watch them.

Until web sites figure that out (are you listening El Reg) there are many ad blockers on the market, at least some of which block ads completely. If users chose to accept whitelisted adds then they have at least some assurance that the advertiser has agreed to conditions based on that whitelisting.

12
0

More and more Brits are using ad-blockers, says survey

Steve Todd
Silver badge

Take note of this yourself El Reg

I was content to do without ad blocking myself until your huge banner and animated ads made the site unusable on a mobile device. Things have improved vastly since it was enabled. Limit the space and bandwidth of your ads or we'll do it for you.

73
0

Apple fires legal salvo at FBI for using All Writs law in iPhone brouhaha

Steve Todd
Silver badge

Re: safe cracking

If they've done it once then they can be compelled to do it again and again. After a while it becomes impractical to device lock the code, at which point it can then escape. It's a long, slippery slope.

1
0
Steve Todd
Silver badge

Re: safe cracking

Nowhere near that simple.

The safe company has developed a safe that is guaranteed uncrackable, thus making it a valuable item to potential safe owners. The FBI is demanding that the safe company develop a completely new tool to open a safe of this type that was owned by a criminal (which may, but probably doesn't, contain information about his crimes). They've also managed to reset the combination to a random number they don't know. They pinky swear that the tool will be used only this once. Meanwhile they have a queue of other safes that they also want opening, as do the police and foreign governments. Due to the rules of evidence the safe company will also have to document how the tool is created and how it works. Result: no one with that type of safe can rest easy, and the FBI can apply the case law to other manufacturers also so there will be no such thing as a secure safe. The methods will leak out and burglars will soon be able to open them also.

2
1
Steve Todd
Silver badge

Re: What about forcing a phramaceutical company...

If a company has spent a billion dollars bringing a drug to market they wouldn't have done so without there being a large target market. Having discovered a drug and got it through approval they've spent a lot of money. They want to make that back. Just sitting on it gets them no return. Worst case they can license the production to another company for specific uses and get SOMETHING back. At the end of 17 years it becomes generic and anyone can make it (quite how the FDA seems to have screwed up generics is beyond me). After the approvals process that's more like 10 years.

You seem to be confused over the law. The FBI are trying to extend the reach of the All Writs act in order to force Apple to do something they don't want to do. Apple don't want to do it because it's bad precedent (no matter what the FBI would have you believe, having done this once there'd be a queue of government agencies and police forces demanding that they do it again). It would also be next to impossible to refuse the same aid to foreign governments like the Chinese. Apple aren't asking to be exempted from the law, they are asking that there be limits placed on law to prevent this kind of request being made of ANY company.

5
0
Steve Todd
Silver badge
Stop

Re: What about forcing a phramaceutical company...

That "nice guy" bought the rights for a drug that is out of patent. There is nothing stopping another company from making a generic except for the FDA.

There are many diseases around the world that aren't worth researching a cure for (last time I looked it costs about $1bn to bring a new drug to market). If governments think that it has social value to create a cure then they need to put their hands in their pockets, not expect the drug companies to spend that kind of cash out of charity.

People risking their lives to stop criminals have to follow the law in the same way that we do. The problem is that the FBI is trying to redefine the law to let them do whatever they want.

6
1
Steve Todd
Silver badge

Re: One thing I don't understand

@Pseu Donyme, the way that the system is wiped is simply to throw away the AES key, which is stored in the CPU. A copy or emulation of the flash memory wouldn't help here.

4
0
Steve Todd
Silver badge

Re: One thing I don't understand

The data on that chip is encrypted using 256 bit AES. The key is stored inside the CPU and needs to be unlocked using the users PIN before the data can be accessed. Trying to break 256 bit AES directly is massively impractical.

5
0

JavaScript daddy's Brave ad-blocker hits Android, Apple stores

Steve Todd
Silver badge

Re: What I want is an iOS blocker extension, not a browser

Try "Magic", once the HPE ads got too anoying on el reg I installed that and haven't looked back.

0
0

US DoJ files motion to compel Apple to obey FBI iPhone crack order

Steve Todd
Silver badge

Re: Surely...

With enigma the problem was a combination of a mathematical weakness in the algorithm, combined with known text, that allowed the Bletchley Park code breakers to very much reduce the search space. AES on the other hand has been the product of multiple cryptographers and much analysis to look for weaknesses, none practical having been found.

2
0

Sir Clive Sinclair in tech tin-rattle triumph

Steve Todd
Silver badge

Re: Hard to take seriously

People forget that Sinclair worked with ROSPA when they were designing the C5. It was bad publicity that killed it rather than a lack of safety.

8
3

Europe's Earth-watching satellite streaks aloft

Steve Todd
Silver badge

Re: F=ma

So the initial departure is at 0.96G upwards (after you subtract earths gravity dragging it downwards), accelerating as fuel is burned off. Dropped items fall fairly quickly, so imagine something falling upwards.

3
0

Scariest climate change prediction yet: More time to eat plane food

Steve Todd
Silver badge

Re: Surely it wil average out

Actually what happens is that routes eastbound deliberately alter to pick up the jetstream. Westbound they avoid it as much as possible. The result is that the average time is less than the aircraft speed +/- the jetstream speed.

2
1
Steve Todd
Silver badge

Surely it wil average out

Trips west to east will be faster.

Trips east to west will be slower.

3
1

Silent Nork satellite tumbling in orbit

Steve Todd
Silver badge

Re: " Soviet SS-1 "Scud" powerplants"

Either a bad joke or you don't know your history. The V1 was powered by an Argus Tube pulse jet, nothing at all like the V2 rocket engine.

47
4

EU could force countries to allocate 700 MHz band to mobile by mid-2020

Steve Todd
Silver badge

Re: retune or new appliances and hardware?

Depending on the area you are in you may need a new aerial. The cost of this should be met by the government.

Everything else should work as before after a retune. The range of frequencies available for TV is being shrunk, not moved to a different band completely.

0
0
Steve Todd
Silver badge

Re: Nothing to do with IOT or Traffic.

The number of base stations you build has to be cost effective. 700, and to a lesser extent 900MHz, is good for covering rural areas where you can't afford to build one base station to serve only a handful of people. 2100 and 2600MHz is good for city centres where even small cells become saturated.

0
0
Steve Todd
Silver badge

Re: Stupid frequencies

Analog TV needed large lumps of spectrum because of long distance propagation issues (ghosting etc). DTTV solves those issues, and packs many more channels into the same space. It's also designed to allow national networks to run on a single frequency. The result is we don't need the extra space (but some folks will require a new aerial). There is quite a lot of sense in re-allocating 700MHz to mobile data.

BTW, Internet of Things is all very low bandwidth. 2G should be fine for most of it. This is all about 4/5G mobile internet for people.

1
2

Back to the Future's DeLorean is coming back to the future

Steve Todd
Silver badge

If I had a spare $100k

I certainly wouldn't be spending it on a car with as poor acceleration and handling as the DeLorien. A Tesla Model S perhaps. Something that can hit 88MPH effortlessly and in short order certainly.

4
0

Blighty's Parliament prescribed tablets to cope with future votes

Steve Todd
Silver badge

Not that I'm a great respector of MPs

But there are a couple of factors in play here.

Firstly they have other jobs to do other than just hanging about the debating chamber (committees, constituency work, lobbying etc.)

Secondly divisions are often about motions and amendments proposed in the chamber on that day. The result is that it's hard to know what you're voting on all the time, and what your party's line is on it. Now if this division app can inform them about what it is they are voting on, how their party expects them to vote and give them time to think (rather than having to scurry from whatever distant Westminster corner they are in) then it seems like a good idea. How well it is implemented is the important question.

4
2

KeysForge will give you printable key blueprints using a photo of a lock

Steve Todd
Silver badge

In the dim and distant past I was the junior dogsbody for an IT project where it was decided that we needed more keys for the project office. I was sent out to procure them. The local locksmiths told me that they were high security keys, and I needed a letter of authorisation to get them copied. Some months later we managed to lock ourselves out. The building manager turned up with a standard issue catering services knife, inserted it between the door and the jam and gave it a sharp tap. Door opened. So much for high security.

3
0

Huffing and puffing Intel needs new diet of chips if it's to stay in shape

Steve Todd
Silver badge
Stop

Re: Really, selling the same cpu for 5 years makes you wonder why sales are dropping?

I'm not an Intel fan, but even I know that they have been making improvements to the performance and architecture. The i5 from 5 years ago isn't the same as the current i5 (they are fabbed on a different process, use less power at a higher clock speed, have better on board graphics and execute more instructions per clock cycle). Core i is a brand not a design.

2
1

Forums