back to article El Paso city bungs $3.2m to email crooks pretending to be bosses

After keeping quiet for days, the city of El Paso, Texas, has finally admitted that it has fallen prey to "CEO fraud" emails that saw scammers funnel $3.2m from the authorities using bogus invoices. The city is building a $97m streetcar project in its downtown district, but red flags were raised in October when a key …

  1. J. R. Hartley

    Shitting crikey!!

  2. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    hmm, preferred suppliers not a thing in Texas then?

    The last time I dealt with government purchasing it was based upon with a list of known agencies and accounts, to become "known" required a lengthy process of form filling and validation before any money could change hands.

    Clearly they were ripped off because they were at best slack and stupid and/or because they were complicit in the theft, either way they should be held accountable rather than just blaiming the "tinternet" for being unsafe and confusing. If they did not know what they were doing then why were they holding the purse strings

  3. Crazy Operations Guy

    Specify financials in the contract

    Any money paid by a government entity should always be part of a well-written and verified contract. Any proper contract would include the exact destination of funds along with the payment schedule. At the outset of the contract it should be known "On this day, provided the contracted tasks have been completed in a satisfactory manner, the sum of $300,000 USD is to be transferred from <routing/account number of city's coffers> to <routing/account number of contractor's coffers>". Any changes to the amounts, schedule, or the source/destination should go through the lawyers and the bean counters of both organizations.

    Hell, this should apply just as well to all organizations. The CxO / Mayor / Council / Governor / Head of State should never have the authority to just authorize payment or any money transfer without explicit authorization for each transaction by the responsible legal and financial authority. These 'CEO Scams' would be dead in the water if organizations would just follow procedure. The problem, and sole reason the scam exist, is the massive ego of those in power and they want control over everything, especially the check book.

    1. kain preacher

      Re: Specify financials in the contract

      AND deny the PHB the power they cray? You must be nuts

  4. David 132 Silver badge
    Happy

    .

    Dear Reg editors,

    This is Iain Thomson really riting this mail. Due to totally legitimat resans including pregnancy and climate change I have changed my bank account, Please to dep0sit my payment for this article to my new bank account with the Bank of Nigeria, sort code FF-UU-KK, account number 5318008, thanking you very much

    Singed,

    Iain Thomsan

    ---- scaned by Nortonn Anti-Virus, 100% secure trustiness ----

    1. Danny 14

      Re: .

      Your account number is similiar to mine! 58008618

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: .

        Account number: 55378008

    2. David 132 Silver badge
      Happy

      Re: .

      Thank you all for the kind upvotes.

      At least the editors didn't chime in along the lines of "that mail wouldn't fool us, it can't possibly be from Iain, it's too well-written in its first draft" :)

  5. frank ly

    Subtle form of words

    "City Attorney Sylvia Firth later acknowledged that the city hadn't been instructed by the police to keep quiet about the fraud, but had simply been advised that it might be better to do so."

    Was it the police who 'advised' them to do that or was it their PR department?

  6. Magani
    Facepalm

    Me too!!

    Sounds like the same MO as was perpetrated on both the Brisbane ($450K) and Townsville ($300K) City Councils in August.

    http://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/queensland/townsville-also-targeted-by-scam-as-state-put-on-alert-20160819-gqw9x2.html

    Interesting the little old Oz was ahead of its bigger TransPacific cousin.

  7. David Pollard

    I've got this plan for a bridge in London ...

    Even though it will only carry pedestrians and isn't really needed to ease congestion, it will have gardens and so forth and will be a real treasure for residents. The £30 million that the government has already provided ran out some while ago so another payment of a few million is needed for more research to be done on this project.

    1. Danny 14

      Re: I've got this plan for a bridge in London ...

      I thought the millennium bridge had been built?

      1. BebopWeBop

        Re: I've got this plan for a bridge in London ...

        Having an office for a year overlooking the Millennium bridge I can assure you it was extremely well used by pedestrians during that time. Including myself. Lovely view actually, when the need for procrastination becomes overwhelming, a few minutes gaze across the river to St Pauli is lovely.

  8. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    "this kind of fraud is skyrocketing"

    I've seen one or two invoice scams in my spam folder. Obviously random. These successful scammers must be studying the companies they're impersonating - or hacking into their email accounts etc. Accounts Payable clerk gets invoice, verifies payee and amount, cuts a check, mails it to scammer's PO Box shown on invoice.

    That form of fraud isn't new. What's new is the ease of hacking in and gathering information, and the ease of impersonating people who never talk to each other on the phone or in person.

  9. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    My company nearly got done...

    The MD was on a scheduled visit to the USA and a very plausible email in their name made it through to the finance manager. They were about to pay it when something in the back of their mind led to call the MD and check.

    We think that they had been researching the MD and used social media to work out when they were travelling.

  10. Amos1

    Don't worry. All of your income tax returns are totally safe with your city or school district.

    Yeah, I live in one of the states that allow cities to leverage an income tax against their citizens. :-(

    1. ecofeco Silver badge

      Re: Don't worry. All of your income tax returns are totally safe with your city or school district.

      If it will make you feel any better, the IRS regularly outsources processing to India.

      Sleep tight.

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: Don't worry. All of your income tax returns are totally safe with your city or school district.

        I have it on good authority that the IRS outsources ALL actual work; the employees union slugs just collect paychecks.

  11. Filippo Silver badge

    One of my clients recently outsourced their accounting to India. So at one point I received an email in somewhat uncertain English asking me for my bank details because they needed to make a payment. Obviously, I trashed it without reading it. I realized what happened only months later when I noticed I wasn't getting paid any more.

  12. Cuddles

    Paper-only invoicing

    Because everyone knows any invoice written on paper must be 100% trustworthy.

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon

Other stories you might like