NASA's robotic moon-dirt grubbing contest is go

in other news, seti...

is digging deep into amanfrommars...

i wonder

If rather than building materials for moon towns complete with moon town halls and charity shops etc.. and for oxygen production what NASA are really thinking is this could used alongside robotic return vehicles to harvest large amounts of dust/rock from the moon to bring back to earth. As we all know Moon dust is supposed to be rich in ‘helium 3’ a possible component in future fusion based power generation.

@Zmodem

> A hydralic drill with a hoover through the core, and a senor

Even if you used one of the old Hoover Seniors, there isn't enough atmosphere to suspend the moondust or cool the motor. Even if there was, the finest particles would escape through the bag, the next particle size up would bung it up, and because the dust is actually pulled through the fan in those old Hoovers, it would end up being choked or damaged by the larger pebbles.

Plus using an upright Hoover would raise the centre of gravity, making the device less stable.

You'd be better off using a Dyson (I'm referring to his wheelbarrow with a ball).

@Zmodem

There will be this big hole at the business end where the soil is intended to enter. This will somewhat defeat any attempts at 'air tight'. Let alone the issue of using tanked air - which rapidly escapes to everywhere and only very slightly will increase the pressure returning up the nozzle.

And if it is useless until you dig down a bit, you'll need two devices, so Occam would tend to indicate that this is a way too complicated and unnecessary solution which probably will have extreme minimum success anyway.

Also, why would things be better after you have dug a bit? Do you think you are going to reach air-tight mud?

The horse is definitely dead, I'd stop flogging it if I were you.

Simplicity is crucial...arm...scoop...conveyor...hopper

Coal mining machinery

All one needs to do is reduce the size of a continous miner plant somtimes called a road header I think huge beast that rips the coal out and has at least two arms to rake in the shattered coal on to a convayor belt,or rock as the case may be.