back to article Apple news-churn app mysteriously stops churning news in China

Apple's URL-redirect news app has stopped working behind the Great Firewall of China, it has emerged. Even articles saved by those who are too fearful of the world to venture outside the walled garden for their news have been blocked. The New York Times noted that Apple News users in China needed to convince Cupertino that …

  1. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    The warning triangle reads ....

    Danger!

    Walled Garden

  2. PhilipN Silver badge

    No surprise.

    Hats off to Apple for championing uncensored news over the state-filtered version, even at some risk to their penetration of the Chinese market in certain respects.

    China has been doing this for years, starting with Satellite TV transmissions.

    I was sat in a China hotel room some years ago watching the BBC news when a background piece mentioned Tiananmen 1989. Within 2 seconds the screen went blank. It came back after an interval sufficient to see a change of subject.

    Whole bunch of key words and topics will trigger the off switch. Just guessing but presumably Taiwan (once upon a time). Tibet in certain contexts hence Dalai Lama. Falun Gong, etc.

  3. Mike Bell

    Contradictory conclusions

    On the one hand, Larry Salibra says

    "the mechanism Apple uses to disable the News app and Apple Maps uses the location of the user to change the behaviour of their device"

    having already said

    "it was pretty obvious that Apple isn’t using location tracking and geofencing to shut down the News App, but is doing so based on the mobile network the phone connected"

    Who is this nitwit?

    1. Notas Badoff

      Reading comprehension (was Re: Contradictory conclusions)

      "As soon as I connected to the network, the Apple News App would refuse to refresh or open any of the articles already displayed on the screen, showing the message “News isn’t supported in your current region”."

      "At this point, it was pretty obvious that Apple isn’t using location tracking and geofencing to shut down the News App, but is doing so based on the mobile network the phone connected."

      Ah, how nice for you to be using one of those satellite-based cell phones. The rest of us use cell tower-based connections. Which are planted in the ground of very specific locations, connected to specific networks, some of those clearly labeled "do-not-fuck" (with us).

  4. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Ah, the mysterious Apple News App.

    The one that us Brits and amongst others can't get unless we make our phones appear to be owned by someone in the USA.

    The app that has UK News publications all signed up.

    AFAIK, Canada, the Rest of Europe and most parts of Asia are in the same boat.

    Care to comment Apple?

    1. SuccessCase

      Re: Ah, the mysterious Apple News App.

      Holy crap, you mean Apple aren't launching a service in the UK until it is ready and all the deals have been done. What is this madness?

      If you really want it, join the beta program and download 9.1. Earlier in the beta the UK news coverage and updates were patchy but now it's pretty comprehensive.

  5. Your alien overlord - fear me

    It's Apple f*cktards. What do you expect? Apple runs your life and not only do you meekly roll over and accept it but you sing their praises to all non-believers. This is what they do and you have no say except to buy their next new iDevice and love it.

    1. SuccessCase

      Whew, glad we sorted that out. Apple want to bar their customers from using the services they have developed. For a moment I thought it was the Chinese government.

  6. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Wot?

    "uses the location of the user to change the behaviour of their device without their permission, even if the location service is disabled in the privacy settings"

    If you disable location services, I suspect your IP address will be used instead to place you as being behind the GFWoC.

  7. Cincinnataroo

    If you don't take control...

    you get what you , maybe, deserve.

    Good idea to not become dependent on corruptible news sources?

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon

Other stories you might like