mildly innovative = seriously dumb
if he hadn't been putting charges through his own company he probably would't have been caught so easily, 342 fraudulent cards all being used to buy services from the same company leaves a pretty clear trail.
A recidivist ID theft fraudster who used a people search website to verify the authenticity of stolen social security credentials has been jailed for more than 16 years. Todd Yurgin, 41, of Newark, Delaware, earned the severe sentence because he had twice previously been convicted of federal fraud offences. In sentencing, …
Say I have the name, address and SSN of John P, aged 16. I go to Bank X that asks for name, address and SSN to confirm identity and input their details, but in the date of birth slot I put a date that matches my apparent age. The bank checks the name, address and SSN and finds they are valid, so it stops there and does not check the DOB. I spend a couple of months paying fixed sums into the account from my company to give the appearance of receiving a regular wage, then I go to the credit card company armed with evidence that I'm John P and I'm old enough to have a card. They run a check, find a clean history, and give me the card. I then withdraw all the money I've put into the John P account, run up a stack of charges on the card and flee.
Of course, if you try following those steps to the letter you'll be caught and jailed because there are loads of things I'm not mentioning - but then the aim is not to turn El Reg into The Fraudsters Handbook. This is just a basic explanation of how it might be done.
The three strike system is usually implemented by politicians wanting to sound tough on crime, however the logical outcome, given enough criminals and crimes, is fairly obvious;
Spend the rest of your life in jail for id theft (usually a non-violent crime), or eliminate the person who could put you in jail for the rest of your life.
Whilst it is good that criminals are brought to justice, the time should fit the crime, and hence should distinguish between violent and non-violent offences.