Charisma envy? ;)
Hi Adam I think you are comparing Apples and Non-Apples
Everyone I know has great respect for Redhat.
But Redhat has a Market Cap(Mil) of 4837.11 and is making good profits.
Canonical is a private company of 200 employees not making any profit atm.
Now Mark Shuttleworth, I believe, is covering all the bills out of his own pocket so its a bit rich to be comparing the two in such a way.
> Canonical uses a lot of work from other projects and companies (Debian, Red Hat, Novell and others)
Well I don't see that as wrong, after all the software is FOSS, you are allowed and encouraged to do this!
>but tends to market itself as if it were the be-all and end-all and all the work was coming out of its own offices.
Maybe this bit gets to your fundamental concern?
I have never seen Ubuntu marketing say anything of the sort myself maybe you have some links to back this claim up?
> iain34: "blasphemy"?! exaggerate much, or are you just _that_ passionate about Ubuntu forums? :)
Not sure about this I will have a look at iain34's post but the Ubuntu Forums are brilliant :)
>It is an icky area to deal with, when I worked for Mandriva we had lots of issues with it too, it took a lot of releases before we managed three or four in a row where there weren't any problems with upgrading when using the proprietary drivers.
Hmm interesting I actually paid for the boxed retail set of a Mandriva distro thinking I could move over to Linux - It was a while ago :)
Mandriva at that time was nasty and unfinished.
I actually binned it.
I don't really see what you have got against Mark & Ubuntu except envy tbh.
I know it must be annoying when people new to GNU/Linux refer to the whole thing as "Ubuntu" but I don't think thats anything to get the hump about - they are new to the whole FOSS thing and will get it eventually.
I also think you miss the large contribution that Ubuntu does make.
1. http://ubuntuforums.org/ is probably the best advertisement for Linux and the values behind Linux that you could get.
It not only provides the best support on the web but it is polite and encourages community building and outreach.
2. It has poured money in to desktop Linux and produced a fine polished product that users love.
3. Its great at marketing and generating excitement for each new release.
4. Mark has the vision thing :)