I'm not : paranoid but they are coming to get me...
> 1.) The merchant gets their money after a period - not instantaneously - holding a gun to their head won't get you any cash from the proposed fraud at a tube station - it'll just be a good-old plain armed robbery of cash on the premises. The period is there for stopping fraud/chargebacks, and for 'clearing' purposes.
It's still worth bopping someone one the head & using the card. The merchant might to get the cash, but the thief has the goods.
>You're suggesting that scum will mug you for your card, so they can get a tenner off of it for White Lightning or something?
Yes. I've known people mugged for a fiver - and 3 trips to different offies & it adds up to a lot of White Lightning
The problem with things like the Oyster card is that to obtain the discount you can't top it up anonymously, you must submit your bank details. The discount is because "cashless payments are more efficient - odd you don't get a discount on credit card or debit card payments. Also to get the discount you must swipe at both ends of your journey, not just on boarding.
So, it's sod all about efficiency - it's about tracking where you gen on and off the transport system.
And cashless payments are a wet dream for a fascist government such as in power in Britain. I'm not surprised to find out they are already in use in Singapore for the same reasons - a government obsessed with control over its citizens.