back to article Analysts slam iPhone security and battery life

Industry analysts have decreed that the new iPhone's lack of security and poor battery life make it unsuitable for all but the lightest enterprise use. The conclusions come in a nine-page research note from Gartner, as reported by Computerword. Entitled iPhone 2.0 Is Ready for the Enterprise, but Caveats Apply, it is based on …

COMMENTS

This topic is closed for new posts.

Page:

  1. NHS IT guy
    Heart

    So, like everything else then...

    So it shares the same flaws as most smartphones then?

    Data not encrypted? Same as 99% of other smartphones as PDAs

    Battery life not great? Same again, especially if you stay connected to exchange all day long.

    I'm using my iPhone 3G as my NHS smartphone via exchange and it's working a dream. I'm not a mac user, but I do love the form factor - and the fact I can take my personal and work life around in one handsome unit.

    The web-browsing on the iPhone is a leap ahead compared to the majority of smart phones I've used, this also applies to the multimedia capabilities which are obviously the iPhone's forte.

  2. Gulfie

    Power Update

    Yes I find my iPhone hard to put down so... last night I did a full charge and cycled the power to reset the usage figures.

    Right now the phone has been in standby for 16 hours, used actively for 70 minutes, and everything (3g, wifi, bluetooth) is turned on, email is checked every 30 minutes (not Exchange). Battery is about 30% discharged. The only thing I'm not doing is using the mp3 player on it, I'm back on my iPod.

    So, for a normal user I think battery life will be acceptable, and my experience is that if I listen to MP3s through the working day then a daily charge is recommended.

    It's a multi-functional device, folks, with multiple radio transmitters and receivers. Show me another PDA phone of a similar size/weight that can do all this and not need charging... like somebody else said - you just can't stop using it...

  3. Matt Bryant Silver badge
    Stop

    FFS, who rattled the fanbois cages?

    Please, can all the paranoid fanbois get off defcon1 and realise that Gartner are not calling their holyphone a piece of junk, they are just pointing out that it is not quite ready for enterprise big time. Blackberry was designed as an enterprise solution and has evolved over time into a very secure system, those are just basic facts. Win Mobile devices like the HTCs or iPAQs have long targeted the Blackberry and have also evolved over time from joke to reasonable enterprise solution. The iBone is still largely at the stage of bling toy, I'm sure given time and attention Apple will close the gap, but does it matter? If you are not using it in an enterprise setting then it will probably do what you want very well, just don't expect any professional setting to be overjoyed if you ask to use it at work.

    For a start, the main hostility in many workplaces to iBones comes from the iPlod, where many moronic users would try and install iTunes on their work desktops and trying to download all day, using up company bandwidth and company resources for purposes definately not intended by the owners. I have seen workers genuinely confused as to why they were being fired after having been warned three times that doing so was against their contract terms. They just don't seem to understand that the company is not interested in underwriting their non-work activities which takes them away from the tasks the company is paying them to do.

    We have decided not to add the iBone to our list of company-approved phones, and are looking at ways of detecting the Apple MAC address range and rejecting them for our comapny WiFi access points. If Apple make a more secure version which meets out criteria we'd allow it, though we'll probably keep on blocking iTunes. This is not because we hate Apple, it's a business decision. No need for fanboi rage, thanks.

  4. Anonymous Coward
    Flame

    an alternative

    give me my nokia 6310 any day, 2 weeks on standby , and I can talk to people on it.

    also since it doesn't attempt to browse the web (ok it attempts wap) , my 40 year old eyes are less strained

    and since it's display is monochrome you can even see it in direct sunlight.

    I might retrofit my nokia 6310 into one of those motorola brick cases from the eighties , fill it up with lithium polymer batteries and have a phone with a battery that lasts for months.

    not that I want to talk to anyone , I am thinking of becoming a trapist monk, then I will not need a phone to talk to anyone either !

  5. This post has been deleted by its author

  6. blackworx

    @Camera phones

    "I can see why camera phones might be a big hit with teenagers, but I fail to understand why grown adults feel the need for one."

    1. Home made porn

    2. Ridiculous misspelt schoolboy graffiti

    3. The occasional cool stencil

    4. Home made porn

    (2 and 3 only apply to people who don't spend their lives outside of work and sleep driving around in a car)

  7. vdb

    power is no issue

    I've owned the whole scale of qtek's htc's and other smart-phones;

    they all had smaller screens, they had slower processors, most applications run at a fraction of the speed compared to iphone. Their battery life sucked big time.

    iPhone, 3G, wifi, bluetooth (use it all the time in car), check mail contacts calendar every 30 minutes, daily use varies between 1 - 2 hours, 2 days on a full charge ... none of the current phones beat this, period (did I mention I owned the bloody competition and used it;-). And as already mentioned the screens are pity-full, the applications on the iphone already trump the competition after a few weeks ...

  8. Trix
    Boffin

    Regarding the battery life issue

    I love all this "if I set to poll once an hour, I get a whole DAY of use". I get 5-7 days' use out of my Blackberry, with push functionality.

    It's not enterprise-ready until it has built-in device encryption (although we don't encrypt our laptops, so it's wildly amusing that my email infrastructure is more secure than our pcs), it does a self-wipe if the password is entered incorrectly (we have ours set to wipe after 5 attempts), and it has software management/lockdown functionality (you might want to support devices where anyone can install any PoS software they find on teh Intarwebs, but I don't). I'm not even going to mention cut-and-paste.

    Blackberrys are not sexay phones, but they send and receive email and meetings securely and well. And you can type on them. Windows Mobile is crap (just as bad as the iPhone with the battery life), but at least there is enterprise policy management, there are third-party (can't they build it in?) encryption tools, and you can cut and paste. Of course, when the iPhone catches up (and it will), Windows Mobile will be going down the gurgler at a rate of knots.

  9. Andy Dent
    Alert

    @Camera Phones

    Why? White boards.

    I would estimate about 80% of the meetings I've been where anything useful has been worked out on the whiteboard have resulted in someone taking a photo with a camera, even when printing is available.

    It's a lot easier to email a photo around or put it up on a wiki than to do something with crap thermal-printed paper which is probably only black and white.

  10. vdb

    Re trix

    Sure, using 3G ;-) my 8800 has a poor 4 hour talk time and hardly gets through the day on a single charge ...

    oh no the 8800 has no 3g oops, 4 hours on edge you must be kidding ...

    (my iphone has 9.5 hours talk time on edge and does push for 4-5 days on single charge ...)

    and before you tell me that my battery is bad on the 8800 forget it, already tried 3 different ones, and I've read several test reports that 4.5 is the max you can get out of it, know I understand the crackberry users want a replaceable battery

  11. Mat Smith

    @Camera Phones

    To add to the chap who posted previously, I can also testify that camera phones are extremely useful in work scenarios. I'm a serious photo-head and I shoot with a full-frame DSLR, but nobody is comparing this to using a cameraphone. A cameraphone is a piece of useful *functional* kit nothing to do with real photography, which alows me to take quick snaps for site surveys, work inspection photos, switch rooms and fuseboards, and even sometimes for personal use and to capture memories. Means I don't have to bring a mini digital camera around wherever I go.

    As for the use of the word fanboi, I concur with Rich who recommends castration. A large proportion of the readership of this website is over 20, let alone over 40, people who use or run IT at work, how old are we?!

  12. Jonas Nagel
    Boffin

    RE: nobody has mentioned it yet ...

    "Not to mention that OSX is just Linux under the hood and Linux evolved from BSD :-D"

    Of course this is a flame-bait, but you could at least get the facts straight:

    OS X underneath is not Linux, but Darwin. Darwin is derived from NetBSD while NetBSD is derived from System V/AT&T UNIX (simply put). Linux has not much in common with UNIX except a few commands and left-overs, hence the GNU "standard" which acronym implies "GNU is Not UNIX".

    While NetBSD and OSS Darwin (mostly) do not exhibit the same security issues like Mac OS X, what do we learn? All the GUI bollocks and apps which are screwed on top, hastily, are what lack security review.

Page:

This topic is closed for new posts.

Other stories you might like