Feeds

back to article Google flu-finding service diagnosed with 'big data hubris'

A paper in Science claims that Google Flu Trends, unveiled back in 2008 to become a poster-child of Big Data, has one teeny, tiny, fatal flaw: it's almost always wrong. The paper – abstract here – finds that not only did Flu Trends completely miss the 2009 swine flu, but for 100 of the 108 weeks since 2011, Google's predictions …

COMMENTS

This topic is closed for new posts.
Silver badge

Hubris or indifference?

I'd say both. Since they're working on false assumptions, one might think that they don't care about the voracity of their data input. At least not enough to bother verifying it. Perhaps they should have just called it "Google Fu Trends".

4
0
Bronze badge

Re: Hubris or indifference?

@Ole Juul: I suspect s/voracity/veracity/ - where their data input is concerned they are voracious all right, and that is the part they do care about... ;-)

2
0

There is a real danger that big data is based on a big assumption.

That assumption is that out of a mountain of crap you can locate a truth.

It may not be so and starting with good data may be a much better plan.

3
0
Silver badge

Snirk...

They blew it and yet they continue. Neither Hubris nor Indifference. Probably profit from the advertisements from the flu vaccine and flu symptom drug companies. Yes, I know, flu symptom drugs don't actually cure the flu. Neither do antibiotics but the drug companies make profit from it.

1
0
Silver badge

Its worked out quite well really

they've basically found acute hypochondria while looking for flu.

3
0
Bronze badge

They need a man-cold de-dupe program

If the urban myth is correct, then perhaps they should de-rate accounts that come from men. And those that are written on Mondays and Fridays.

1
0

Re: They need a man-cold de-dupe program

Almost 40% of sick days are on Monday or Friday. It is scandalous.

0
0
Silver badge
Holmes

In other words...

Garbage In, Garbage Out.

As most programers have known for decades...

1
0

I assumed that a TV documentary about flu would cause a rush of Google queries, without spreading any more flu.

1
0
This topic is closed for new posts.