back to article Bing accused of out-censoring the Great Firewall

Microsoft is facing another PR battle after a rights group accused Bing of more heavy-handed censorship in China than even homegrown search engine Baidu shackles its users with. Despite claiming to remove results as “narrowly as possible” in order to comply with Chinese censorship laws, Microsoft is actually blocking a “vast …

COMMENTS

This topic is closed for new posts.
Silver badge

Perhaps not just in China?

Is this why Bing is not the search engine of choice, because it doesn't give any?

16
2
Anonymous Coward

Agreed

I'll agree with that. As much as I would like to use Bing their results simply stink. I now use DuckDuckGo but their categorization of results is not much better - for example, DuckDuckGo "Dell XPS" and you get:

- (top of page) a link to the Wiki article on Dell XPS

- (next paragraph down) a sponsored link to Dell's laptop XPS line

- (main search results) a SINGLE Dell XPS result, as search result #2, and again to their laptop line

Google "Dell XPS" and you get:

- (top of page) a sponsored link to Dell's XPS laptops (on sale)

- (second paragraph) a sponsored link to Best Buy's Dell XPS [laptop] page

- (main search results) links to Dell's XPS desktop AND laptop pages, taking up search results numbers 1, 2, AND 3

Big difference. And I'm only using that search term as an example, it happens all too often for me on many of my DDG searches and I find that inexcusable - DDG should show their search results based upon the inherent rankings of the search engines behind the anonymizer.

0
0
Silver badge

Who cares?

It's Bing.

17
2
Silver badge
Happy

Never confuse malice-

With a crappy search engine.

19
1
Bronze badge

Re: Never confuse malice-

That was the comment that sprung to mind before I read the article, I assume (yeah I know) they check the results against Bing from elsewhere to see what was filtered.

Is it possible that the other native search engines get a way with a little more or maybe are not filtering things they should? I can't remember the last time I stuck up for MIcrosoft but maybe they are erring on the side of caution, the Chinese government are a bit picky after all.

2
0
Silver badge

Re: Never confuse malice-

What is it with Microsoft and search? They have a long history of failure to make it work as expected.

They always seem to have imagined that the primary role of a search engine is to find reasons for not showing things. Early versions of Windows file search were limited to "known file types" by default. Even today, I can enter "foo.bar" in the Windows 7 Explorer search box and get no results, when "dir /s foo.bar" returns a result.

All Microsoft search facilities should have a checkbox labelled "Don't try to be clever, just show me the effing files".

5
1
Silver badge

So Now We Know

So now we know why China stopped work on Red Flag Linux - it's because Microsoft are so willing to go that extra mile to please the CPC.

5
1
Silver badge
Thumb Down

I just hope...

...nobody seriously expected Microsoft to suddenly grow a spine, considering its history.

4
1
Silver badge

Re: I just hope...

Nothing specific to Microsoft. Many if not most businesses when faced with the choice of conforming to local laws or not doing business don't chose the "not doing business" option.

Nothing personal, it's just business, they say.

Sad, perhaps, but true.

2
1
This topic is closed for new posts.

Forums