Feeds

back to article 'Thundering mechanical behemoth' walker mech to attack Leicester today

Our hearts went pitter-pat here on the Register exoskeletons, walkers and mighty roaring machinery desk just now, when we got a press release telling us that all our dreams had come true - or some of them anyway. It says: Hydraulic walking machine to thunder through botanic garden A hydraulic-powered mechanical beast will …

COMMENTS

This topic is closed for new posts.
Bronze badge

Sigh...

Generally speaking, I love modern art but - oh, dear...

1
0
Silver badge
Thumb Down

Re: Sigh...

If something is "art" people don't need to be told that its art - they can see it immediately. "Modern art" is the label slapped on talent free rubbish that normal people might mistake for something the binmen will be coming to collect if they weren't informed otherwise. Unfortunatelty people in the art world seem to think that you can call any old rubbish "art" and voila - art it is! Umm , no , it isn't. A turd is still a turd no matter how many pretty bows you tie around it.

Though I do feel rather sorry for this guy - if he'd been around in the 1970s he could probably have secured a top job at British Leylands tractor design studio.

2
1
Anonymous Coward

Looks like the Gardener will be mightily cheesed off with the ruts being left in the grass.

If he intends to use it on the road the Highways department may want to have a word .

And they call this modern Art? Phaaa

2
0
Silver badge
FAIL

So basically

He wrecked a perfectly nice park to faff about on something that looks like a very ugly rocking horse?

6
0
Silver badge
Thumb Down

Art? ART?

No it's not art - classical art, modern art or any other sort of art. It's a mildly curious experiment in creating some sort of inefficient alternative agricultural machine - it's good at destroying turf, and that's about it.

If you want to see art meet engineering have a look at Theo Jansen's wind powered walking machines - serious engineering and quite beautiful art - video on TED http://www.ted.com/talks/theo_jansen_creates_new_creatures.html

24
0
Silver badge

Re: Art? ART?

Just what I was going to reference, so have an upvote instead. His machines have a very natural aesthetic grace, whilst this thing looks like an oversized baby crib made by Tonka.

I wonder if it was designed by committee, in the camel sense?

0
0

Re: Art? ART?

Or these, maybe (not as good as Jansen, but they have a certain something)

http://www.lesmachines-nantes.fr/

0
0
WTF?

Re: Art? ART?

This is craft, not art.

Or all crafts are art.

0
0
Bronze badge
FAIL

"It's very interesting to hear what people think of it."

Well, not so much.

0
0
Silver badge

If a horse was that lame...

You'd just shoot it...

1
0
Silver badge

Re: If a horse was that lame...

It's more camel than horse, at least in design ethic.

0
0
Silver badge

"... very graceful choreography ..."

He must know some totally useless dancers.

Note: Yorkshire Sculpture Park is in the grounds of Bretton Park, a mile up the A637 from J38 of the M1. It's a nice place for a relaxing day out for the entire family. As well as the 'modern' sculpture exhibitions, there are the original buildings of the country house and also one of the finest yew hedges I've ever seen (10 years ago).

0
0

do't bother, go here instead....

Seriusly, LAME is an understatement. Don't bother with it. If you want something vaguely approximating what I was thinking it might be, try this: http://www.mantisrobot.com/

1
0

Missing the point

It's a zombie tractor

0
0

Robert Llewellyn

Seen way better on 'Scrapheap Challenge'

10
0

Oh man, that sucks...

That thing was even more disappointing than the writeup led me to believe.

Now, the 'walking' contraptions made in Scrapheap Challenge, THAT was art!

2
0
Silver badge

I like stomp-bots ... and have built a few.

But that's pretty much useless, IMO.

As for art? No. Just no.

1
0
MJI
Silver badge

Re: I could do better with Meccano

Not man carrying though

0
0
Anonymous Coward

Artists eh?

Can't live with 'em, can't get yer Predator drone to give 'em the Hellfire treatment (legally anyway).

0
0
Silver badge
Pint

The should look at Robot Wars (UK) sometimes...

Because I remember seeing robots that used such constructions to move around. Of course a bit smaller, but that's besides the point.

The best part is that when looking at robot wars you'll also quickly learn the flaws with such a design.

0
0
MJI
Silver badge

Re: The should look at Robot Wars (UK) sometimes...

I remember - the weaponised giant Scuttle.

The small Scuttle was a very fast walker

0
0
Gimp

Re: The should look at Robot Wars (UK) sometimes...

Walkers were permitted a higher limit on the overall mass of the machine which was intended to compensate for some of the flaws you mention.

I was a bit disappointed that the walkers never got a look-in in that series.

It was great to see the evolution of Panic Attack (2), at one time the undisputed champion for more than a couple of years running IIRC.

0
0
Thumb Up

+1 for Diggerland name drop

If you haven't been to one yet then go.

Operating large mechanical beasts is fun.

1
0
Silver badge
Terminator

I used to go to Diggerland when I lived in the north east - who doesn't love machinery that can rip a humans head off, and that's just a skid steer.

As for robot art, check out the Earth Bound Misfits (juggling troup) stilt robot, robotstiltskin - sure it's human powered but it's means as the proverbial!

0
0

"it will not stop"

Imagine being pursued by this mechanical terror, you could forward roll (kiddy style) your way out of trouble having a five minute breather between every 20 rolls.

0
0
Silver badge

I can clearly see why

He has become a "modern artist" and not an engineer...

3
0

Catapult

You, for a second had me fooled in believing someone made a catapult like mechwarrior machine... Oh how I wish for that to come true one day(not even as a war machine really).

0
0

Capper???

From the state of it surely there's an R missing is there not?

2
0
Anonymous Coward

Who are you to judge whether this art is crap or not.....no, wait....it's crap.......

Was just about to get on my high horse and have a moan at you for knocking art, just because you didn't understand it, but no, you're right, it's crap.

1
0

Who are you to judge whether this art is crap or not.....no, wait....it's crap.......

Was just about to get on my high horse and have a moan at you for knocking art, just because you didn't understand it, but no, you're right, it's crap.

0
0
Bronze badge

attack Leicester

Oh damn you el Reg, I got all excited, then you let me down with this 'art'

0
0

Art, my rse, it's not even good engineering

This is good art/engineering by Matt Denton.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d4_xcCYTgTE

1
0
Anonymous Coward

But Wait

I think this is the Bot you are looking for...

http://kuratasrobot.com/

0
0

Quite pointlessly primitive

It is a ugly jolting clown thing, which wastes loads of energy Even his inspiration's machine looked more practical. He would do better to look at mammals, insects, spiders, and molluscs for locomotive inspiration.

0
0
FAIL

I think he should go back to the day job..

..."Would you like fries with that?"

0
0

I lasted less than 20 seconds. Embarrassing nonsense. What is worse is that he probably got funded to do it. I can imagine it now - him surrounded by yaysayers telling him what a great thing it is he's doing. It's shit AND a waste of time and money.

0
0
This topic is closed for new posts.