Micro-drum acts as quantum memory
Memory is one of the difficult bits of quantum computing. For example, while the polarisation of a photon encodes a quantum state, it's very difficult to get photons to stay where they're put. A group of researchers from JILA – a joint institute between the University of Colorado and the National Institute of Standards and …
COOL!
Cool! Drum memory is coming back.
Next, we'll get DEC and IBM platter drums to insert...
Back to the Bat Mobile spin-up. Or the washing machine, depending on vendor...
Quantum Geek Talk
"it's very difficult to get photons to stay where they're put"
This is deliberate understatement, no doubt, but one should replace the word "difficult" with "impossible". Photons are always observed to move at, and only at, the speed of light (C). You can use tricks to "slow" light but what happens there is that it's not the same photon from one moment to the next, in such systems the photons are continually absorbed and re-emitted by electrons in some material.
"The researchers note that the drum is actually a quasi-quantum memory: its beat is a classical system, but in a quantum-noisy environment. This author isn't physicist enough to completely understand the distinction"
Real quantum memory is extremely delicate, it depends on isolation from its environment. What we seem to have here is a classical mechanics system that "remembers" quantum mechanical events, very loosely speaking.
It is not only the author who isn't "physicist enough" to understand the distinction between quantum and classical mechanical systems. Real physicists do not understand the distinction either(!) There are conjectures but these are based on "interpretations" of what QM really is - and none of those is agreed upon, to put it mildly. Most physics shrug and go along with the "shut up and calculate" interpretation, which says, it's too weird to make any sense, but the mathematics gives us accurate physical predictions.
Re: Quantum Geek Talk
<long instructive post>
And this is why Eadon remains off my ignored commentards list.
For now.
Re: Quantum Geek Talk
"it's very difficult to get photons to stay where they're put"
Have they tried sticky tape?
Re: Quantum Geek Talk
> it it's not the same photon from one moment to the next
There is however clearly a big misunderstanding of what a photon "is". There is no continuity here, a photon wanders around as much as a bank transaction does. Photon is just the information extracted from the electromagnetic field.
> classical mechanics system that "remembers" quantum mechanical events
Well, that's not possible that's why there is this distinction.
Oh it's pretty easy to explain...
Either it works, gets more work on it, or we buy some thing else and either come back to it when it does work or we ignore it completely forever.
This is Fizzicks for you.
Elemental my dear Plank.
Re: Spinning platters - Yum
... made me think of pancakes.
choice of wavelength dictates size
The example of the platter include the resonant antenna and is about 150 microns square. It's visible to the naked eye!
Without going to plasmons (surface electrons that can transform from and to photons (with a loss of linked quantum uncertainty-entanglement) it is difficult to see this system getting smaller and therefor sets serious limits on the performance of a quantum computer using this form of storage.
Re: choice of wavelength dictates size
"The example of the platter include the resonant antenna and is about 150 microns square. It's visible to the naked eye!"
Would that not tend to depend on the frequency of the exciting radiation?
It's not mentioned in the article other than being "microwave," but that covers a pretty broad range. Then you could switch to light instead.
This is proof of concept tech. They probably designed it to use whatever hardware they already had. IIRC 2.4Ghz (microwave oven) and 10GHz seem to be popular frequencies for this but microwaves go up to the 100s of GHz before getting into the borderline THz and quasi optical methods.
This is starting to look a bit more like a digital quantum computer than some kind of analog device for solving a fixed class of problems.
