back to article Google axes YouTube attack vid after Brazilian fuzz uncuff chief

Google's chief in Brazil has been forced to take down the YouTube video that got him arrested on Wednesday. Fabio Jose Silva Coelho, who did not make the video, was briefly detained for questioning by police for "disobedience" after Google refused to remove the piece. The vid broke the country's strict election laws by taking a …

COMMENTS

This topic is closed for new posts.
Big Brother

Free speech

Silly Google, they didn't even know that free speech only applies to what governments like.

1
0
Anonymous Coward

Assuming that YouTube content isn't hosted in Brazil, it seems that the Brazillian govt has stooped as low as the United States, in subjecting its laws outside its borders.

1
3
Silver badge
Thumb Down

Just like Britain and Canada. NOT NEW ZEALAND though, they.ve got guts.

They also extend their laws outside their countries.

And Britain even helps the US by allowing rendition flights here and loading Brits on to planes for the US.

New Zealand, now there's an example of independence.

0
0
Thumb Down

From someone living in the country...

...the Brazilian government haven't stooped - that'd suggest this was out of the ordinary in the first place.

The entire machine is run by a bunch of proud profiteering cowboys.

0
0
Anonymous Coward

Geo lock

They do it all the time anyway.

Geolock the video from getting to Brazil, but keep it up elsewhere. The judges order is respected and anywhere outside of that jurisdiction can still access it.

Of course, that will not work with the good ol USA as their law applies everywhere, but hey... One battle at a time.

0
0

Re: Geo lock

It's possible that could be against the spirit of the order against them. I don't like it, but unless there is reform there, there's not much you can do.

0
0
Anonymous Coward

Re: Geo lock

"that will not work with the good ol USA as their law applies everywhere"

not really, it just apply to data stored on the servers hosted in their country. That is a very important detail that you might wish to keep in mind.

Note, if the a USofA court decide that something is illegal and should be removed, then there is a high chance that you already broke the hosting company terms of service, so your stuff is going down either way.

P.S. if a hosting company outside the USofA -with its servers hosted outside the USofA- decides to obey a DMCA take down request or court order, then please put the blame on the company. They should have blocked the content from being served to the USofA instead of taking it down.

0
0
Silver badge
Childcatcher

Jealous of China

Seems Brazil just wants their own great firewall. If they were jealous of us here in the US they'd be out of luck as our governmonkeys have an eternal patent on being complete and utter twats righteous duty to protect ourselves from making our own decisions.

0
1
M7S
Bronze badge
Big Brother

Brazil

Google. Is that the new Ministry of Information, or the Ministry of Information Retrieval?

Paging Mr Lowry. Sam Lowry.

2
0
Bronze badge
Big Brother

Poor Google

It must be tough having to comply with a nation's laws rather than being allowed to tell a nation what it must do.

3
3
This topic is closed for new posts.

Forums