Feeds

back to article Facebook sued by Chinese firm over Timeline

Chinese web firm Cubic Network is set to sue Facebook for nicking the idea and name behind its Timeline feature, after being prompted to do so by some friendly US lawyers. The Pinterest-like web start-up was founded four years ago by Harvard graduate Xiong Wanli, according to China Youth Daily (via MIC Gadget). <pXiong launched …

COMMENTS

This topic is closed for new posts.
Thumb Up

Good!

Maybe they'll have to get rid of that horrific pile of pish, then.

11
0
Anonymous Coward

Encouraged

Encouraged to sue them by an American firm..........

Wow and I didn't even register a flicker of surprise.

4
0
Silver badge
Devil

Re: Good!

Normally I dislike patent spats, but in this case I'll make an exception because maybe then FB will get rid of Timeline!

2
0
Silver badge

" ...allowing users to display videos and images in chronological order."

That is the most original and inspired idea I've ever heard of. (I don't get out much).

7
0
Silver badge

Re: " ...allowing users to display videos and images in chronological order."

I've heard that the Gregorian calendar is based on Facebook technology.

14
0
FAIL

This is getting silly

How can a company claim to own the concept of a timeline. Jesus.

This is NOT a chicken and egg scenario. Timeline would be, and indeed is, pointless and devoid of value outside of the context of the functionality of facebook.

5
1
Silver badge

Re: This is getting silly

It is never silly when US Ambulance chaseeerrmmmm... lawyers and piles of $$$$$$ are involved.

1
0

Re: This is getting silly

> Timeline would be, and indeed is, pointless and devoid of value outside of the context of the functionality of facebook.

and inside it too.

5
0
Bronze badge
WTF?

Re: This is getting silly

Eh, you saying that the other company have no right to this because their social network functionality is so lacking in functionality it it only makes sense when used in facebook?

1
0

Re: This is getting silly

"How can a company claim to own the concept of a timeline"

Well we have Apple patenting rectangles, how can copying a software concept and copying its name be any more ridiculous?

"Timeline would be, and indeed is, pointless and devoid of value outside of the context of the functionality of facebook."

Que??? I sort stuff by chronological order all the time outside facebook...

0
0
FAIL

Old Tech

I had a set of Encyclopedias bought for me when I was a kid. They were printed in 1973, and had several timelines covering several subjects "in print".

Can lawyers be sued for advising pointless legal action?

3
1

Re: Old Tech

"Can lawyers be sued for advising pointless legal action?"

We all wish!!

0
0
Silver badge

I'm just amused...

...that the country that has been shamelessly stealing from the rest of the world for decades, is now offended that one company is , ahem, "stealing" from them.

No irony here, nothing to see, just move on...

2
4
Anonymous Coward

Re: I'm just amused...

I know it's easy to be racist when posting on forums, however the country of China has not announced that it is offended or taking legal action.

It is one man/company and they are doing so on advice from American lawyers.

7
0
Anonymous Coward

Re: I'm just amused...

So what you're saying is that these lawyers just happen to be American and not under the direction of the American government??? Does that make your comment any more racist than the one you just directed the accusation?

0
1
Anonymous Coward

Re: I'm just amused...

Just like when the USofA during the 19th century, when their copyright law did not apply to non-American, and thus they were allowed to pirate European authors as they wished?

Look, it's all explained there in a convenient timeline (search for 1891 if you're in a hurry):

http://www.arl.org/pp/ppcopyright/copyresources/copytimeline.shtml

0
0
Bronze badge

When is the case booked?

Will they be using timelines in court to show the history of timeline use, I don't feel good about that.

1
0

Nice mildly NSFW link there Reg. Cheers for that.

1
0
g e
Silver badge
Joke

F8

I think cameras have had that a tad longer...

;o)

0
1

Re: F8

"F8...I think cameras have had that a tad longer.."

Keyboards too :-P

0
0

Chinese have a lot to learn still

After all, you can't own timeline, its something that’s been done since Mammoths first appeared on caves.

American legal companies however have a newfound injection of cash from naive Chinese who think they can get a quick win.

All that’s going to happen is the case will get thrown out of court and the layers will get paid

0
0
Silver badge

Isn't the Bayeux tapestry a timeline? It does, after all, display images in chronological order...

2
0
TRT
Silver badge

Pfff... errr...

I seem to recall it was a feature of Friend's Reunited as well, back in 1998 I think. And that social networking site from the same era, it makes me think of daisies... what the heck was that called? Green grass? Open fields? Come on, give a guy a hand here!

2
0
Anonymous Coward

I prefer the FriendFace "history all in a row, kinda" feature

I'm on it.

Why aren't you?

0
0
Silver badge
FAIL

Fuk Yu

Showing things in chronological order and calling it a timeline is probably centuries old.

0
0
Joke

Re: Fuk Yu

It may be a timeline, but is it a "Timeline" (tm)?

0
0
Coat

dumb greed

it's a great way of sorting the wheat from the chaff - dumb anal companies desperately try to make profit from suing for things they didn't invent

you didn't invent chronological order

you didn't invent a basic shape

you didn't invent stealing other peoples ideas

boycott companies who claim to have

1
0
Bronze badge
Trollface

What is facebook?

0
0

@ravenviz

It's a bit like facepalm, except you beat yourself around the head with a book at just how stupid things get.

Presumably timeline is the order in which this happens.

1
0

Patent Law Dicktionary

Its difficult being a sane person in this world, so to help others like me I think its time a dictionary was compiled, only one entry so far but its a start:

Non-Obvious: an idea that your pet hamster on a balance of probabilities would be unable to conceive of unaided*

(* unaided implies said hamster is kept in a cage away from any visual, audio or textual information which could otherwise lead to influence of thought)

0
0
Holmes

Re: Patent Law Dicktionary

"Its difficult being a sane person in this world..."

The way things are going, if this was true when you wrote it, it won't be long.

0
0
Dig
Facepalm

Jeeze

Picasa was doing this years ago, perhaps it has a novel and unique way of doing it, maybe based on star dates.

0
0
Linux

Where have these lawyers been? Have they never put their holiday snaps on a time-line? Perhaps they have never heard of 'chronological'. If they don't know what that word means they should ask any historian.

Are they going to sue every photosuit programmer who offers timeline facilities?

Stupid

0
0

But the difference is...

Timelines as in chronological type list details in a logical and ordered way which makes sense to 99.8% of the human population, even those not previously familiar with them.

Facebook Timeline which basically seems to be the "profile" page (as the frontpage and such hasn't really changed in concept), lists things in a totally random order mixed up around the page with no reference to any date system I've ever come across, and therefore isn't a chronological timeline.

Exactly what Facebook Timeline's purpose is however seems to be a total mystery, along with the equal mystery of why the heck anyone would want to lay prior claim to something resembling that mess...!?

0
0
This topic is closed for new posts.