Feeds

back to article Indian ministers quit in parliament smut flick scandal

Three former ministers in the Indian state of Karnataka have until Monday to explain themselves to the Speaker of the local assembly after they were allegedly caught watching porn on a mobile phone during a debate in the House. The trio, accused of ogling the grumble flick in the state assembly building in tech town Bangalore …

COMMENTS

This topic is closed for new posts.
Silver badge
FAIL

Real or not

Idiots

5
0
Anonymous Coward

in a storm...

I'm sorry, but I did have a small lol at "the minister for ports"...

1
0

Minister for Ports, Science, and Technology

I am a little confused over the connection between ports, science and technology. The last two I see connected, even though I’d still rather have them separate, but ports? I am assuming this means the big things by the ocean where ships load and unload rather than difficult to reach holes in the back of a computer, or even funny numbered stuff I don’t understand fully in networking.

I know it’s off topic, just looks like a bizarre portfolio combination. Why not the Minister for Defence and The Arts? Or possibly Agriculture and Foreign Affairs?

What's the rationale behind that combination (genuine question, I am puzzled).

0
0
Gold badge
WTF?

Techy devices tend to have ports on them and some civil servant jumped to the wrong conclusion when carving up the jobs.....?

0
0
Silver badge

They outsourced writing the job descriptions.

2
0
Silver badge

An Investigation!

That's pretty much government code for, "The public will have forgotten all about this when the results are quietly published a few months from now."

0
0
Silver badge
Holmes

Er. Yes.

Hence the Malcolm Tucker allusion. You see?

1
0
Silver badge

Hang them. If they say sorry just by the neck, otherwise a staple gun and their tonkas would be a better route.

They need to remember they are civil servants.

Seriously, what is it about politics that seems to attract the most duplicitous, morally repugnant puppy ****ers on the planet? They can't all be bad, so why don't the good ones make sure there are plenty of staple guns about rather than constantly letting them off with letters home to their mummy about how naughty they were?

1
5

You're right. Even the mere suggestion of impropriety on the part of a government minister should be grounds for capital punishment, (or at the very least, torture through genital trauma).

I just can't understand why more citizens aren't pounding their spittle-flecked keybards in rabid fury in support of your proposal.

I really shouldn't need to use the sarcasm tag here but just in case... [/Sarcasm]

5
2
Silver badge

Yes because I was obviously serious. The point, which obviously eluded you, was that they act with impunity, things that your or I would be sacked for or that I would sack employees for seem to be no issue for them.

2
0

Actually - if weren't being sarcastic I might have voted you up... people in government _should_ be held to a higher standard than the rest of us; they should represent what is best about their country/people... rather than the self-serving, slimy, scum-sucking bottom feeders that seem to weasel their way into office.

Mind, anyone who actually wants to be a politician is probably mentally unsuited to be one.

1
1
Silver badge

I was only joking about the staples! Bodily harm isn't an appropriate response, the problem is the system that should be the response is useless.

0
0
Silver badge
FAIL

@Rampant Spaniel

"Yes because I was obviously serious."

Err, so that's why you followed what *could* have been read as a satirical Daily Fail Reader style rant with "Seriously, what is it about politics that seems to attract the most duplicitous, morally repugnant puppy ****ers on the planet?"

1
1
Joke

scum-sucking bottom feeders ?

Careful - the lawyers are proud of that label

As in

What's the difference between a catfish and a lawyer?

One's a scum-sucking bottom feeder

And the other is a fish

1
0
Silver badge

Daily fail, oh you are so witty Mr Marsden!

Of course I was not serious about harming them, I am however unimpressed with the lack of moral fortitude evident in the average politician and the failings in the system meant to deal with them. It is very rare that a politician in any 'developed' country is genuinely punished. Senator Stevens in the USA and MP's Morley and Devine in the UK are rare exceptions.

A more interesting example might be Baroness Uddin, she claimed 120k GBP in expenses, refused to cooperate with the police, rushed to fill the unoccupied property in question with furniture when the problem was raised by the press, and whilst claiming expenses she was using a housing association property with subsidised rent meant for people of limited means whilst having a mansion built in Bangladesh.

As shameful as this is by itself, my biggest issue is with what followed. She was asked to repay the amount in question (note asked) and suspended by her party. She was not dismissed, no criminal proceedings as she was saved by a senior party member covering her by saying her main residence might be one she only visits once a year and there is nothing to stop her retaking her seat in the lords. If I misspent even 1/1000th of that on my expense account (on which I have to provide recipts and justification for every last cent) I would be sacked. If I had attempted to hide the expense or lie I would face criminal proceedings.

The point is that not only should they be held to at least the same standard as the rest of us, but they should face the same penalties. Not all politicians are corrupt, there are probably many wonderful dedicated civil servants out there, I am left to wonder why they are not doing more to clean house and protect their image.

5
2
Silver badge

One thumbs down from the Baroness! I guess stealing and fraud in public office is ok with some people.

1
3
Silver badge

If you paid tax you might think otherwise. Those of us that pay over 50% of our income in tax, something we do not have a choice over, do not appreciate it being wasted or stolen.

No response huh, too busy watching QI so you can look down on daily mail readers.

1
1

@Spaniel : Totally agree.

0
0

But then, how could anyone even disagree with you. Upvoted you, hope others do too.

0
0
Silver badge
Flame

Business as usual

It's just another instance of conservative politicians doing what they forbid others to do, and to add insult to the injury they're doing it in their working time, paid with public money, and probably using public infrastructure, everything paid by their constituents-subjects.

Please understand me. If these guys were in a party that promoted an open approach to sex, I'd still think they should be sacked, as they aren't getting paid for watching smut in their work hours. But this kind of behaviour by conservative politicians is just incredible. I totally agree with Mr. Spaniel that a staple gun would come handy here. Oh, and also a flamethrower for their higher ups, who instead of cleaning their own house are just 'standing behind' the perps.

3
1
Silver badge

Mr Spaniel endorses your message!

Humor aside, the point is valid. If I were to be caught watching porn, let alone a video of someone being raped (which in many countries is illegal) whilst I was at work, on break or otherwise, I would be dismissed instantly. Politicians seem to get caught doing something stupid / illegal, they 'resign' but still keep their job as they just resigned one of their roles not their actual job, lie under the radar for a while then hop back up. It's called 'doing a mandy'. In the states they just seem to get told off and a letter gets sent home then it all gets forgotten about. They are elected (and remember we only get to vote for who they put forward) to serve.

They are richly rewarded for work that is insigificant (in terms of danger faced, training and skills required etc) to that of say a police officer, fireman, nurse, paramedic and yet they cannot behave. It's one thing that they seem to walk around with interns, secrataries, mistresses attached to their groin like its a towel rail, another entirely taking kickbacks, fiddling expenses, lieing ad nauseum.

I suggest Mako (I suspect a politician using an obviously fake name) watch some monty python clips to aquaint himself with British humor. I mean, seriously, I doubt a staple gun would even work but if any politician wishes to volunteer I could go to officemax.

3
1
Bronze badge
WTF?

Shocker!

Three adult men watched some porn.

Whoulda thunk it?

1
0
Silver badge

Bull*hit Excuses

"Savadi, the minister for co-operation, said the clip he was watching was not porn but footage of a real-life rape of a woman by four men as part of an investigation into the dangers of the rave scene."

Do people in senior office in India think they work? I recall after the Commonwealth Games in India, some guy was explaining why the accommodation wasn't ready until the games were almost due to start: it was because the accommodation was 'for servants'!

0
0
Trollface

'It wasn't porn, it was a real-life rape'

Oh well. Thats all right then. I mean if it was porn they had saved on their mobile phone and were watching it during a debate, that would have been serious, but since it was a real rape, that makes it fine.

Need I break out the sarcastic icon?

2
0

BJP

Does it stands for BlowJob Party?

2
0

"The BJP...has stood behind the men"

No doubt to get a better view of the video in question.

2
0
This topic is closed for new posts.