back to article Catalans to hunt wild boar with bows and arrows

The Catalan authorities have raised a few eyebrows with a plan to hunt wild boar with bows and arrows. The powers that insist that the boars in the Parque Natural de Collserola have become a serious headache, with a burgeoning population increasingly making forays into neighbouring Barcelona.* The problem is that the park is a …

COMMENTS

This topic is closed for new posts.
Pint

The title is required, and must contain letters and/or digits. NO!

Boaring... Cmon, tis friday after noon.... Be merry and break out the mead!

0
0
Silver badge
Pint

and with the drinks . . .

pork kebabs - they now come ready supplied with skewers

0
0

Sounds reasonable to me

Hardly a "medieval" practice. Animals have been hunted with bows for thousands of years, right up to the present day.

I'm an archer - not a bowhunter - but it is a common misconception that bowhunting is cruel and always leads to quarry suffering a slow and painful death. Bowhunting - if performed under licence and with careful regulation and education - is a perfectly responsible and reasonable method of putting food on the table and contributing to population control of wild animals.

There are many other benefits - other animals aren't disturbed by gunfire; the range of an arrow is significantly lower than a rifle bullet, so the risk to passersby is greatly reduced; it's much more difficult to get within range to make a kill, thus reducing the chances of overhunting; and so on.

As long as it's properly regulated, good luck to them.

25
0
Coat

@JK1440

I couldn't agree more.

(Mine's the one with the release aid in the pocket.)

1
0
Silver badge

Hunting with bow and arrow is a medieval practice

Another advantage is that a modern hunting arrow has a much better impact effect on the game. A wounded animal will be stopped in shock, presumably not even feeling the pain right away, unlike what happens with guns. Especially with boars, which are incredibly resistant beasts (with a hell of a hide, too). It is not uncommon to find several pre-existent slugs in wild boars killed in certain area, as wounded animals can escape and hide. Certain animal-lovers might want to do a bit of research before they pick the (medieval) torches and pitchforks.

3
0
Coat

Tossers

"surprising that Catalonia is allowing hunting with bow and arrow at the same time that it's establishing itself as a society at the forefront of animal rights"

Animal Rights activists....can't please them. If the regulation had be "hunters can go in with guns and shoot the boars," they would have complained that guns give an unfair advantage to the hunters and disturbs the natural habitat. Tossers the lot of them!

0
0
Flame

Obvious that this forum is in a country where real hunting is history

If you hunt a boar with a bow during the hunting season (autumn) you get a Darwin award.

Male boars towards the end of the summer grow up to 2+ inches of special fat to protect them when fighting with other males over a mate. That fat can stop some (lower energy) bullets. A bow does not stand a chance. It will only annoy the animal and annoying a testosterone blinded boar is a really bad idea. Terminally bad idea.

If someone is that keen to down a boar the hard way they should take a spear and do it as our great grandparents did it. Not a bow.

1
1
Anonymous Coward

Ignorance is bliss.

Well, there aren't that many wild boar in the UK - they were hunted to extinction long ago.They are very common in France however, and are successfully, (and legally), hunted with bow and arrow, although a gun is a lot easier..

0
0
Alert

@ Anton Ivanov - Do you really know what you are talking about?

My compound bow with a 56lb (~25 Kg for the metric ones) peak draw can penetrate a brand new compressed straw boss (thickness ~8cms or so) at a distance of 90m with about 20cm of the arrow poking out the back end. The kinteic energy in my arrows when I shoot is significantly greater than your standard bullet used by hungers. Replace my bulletpoints with broadheads and we are talking of something that is not going to be troubled with 5 cm of fat (which has much less stopping power than 5 cm of compressed straw).

1
0
Stop

@saggar: no, they are not.

France is overrun with explosive numbers of boar, so that hunting is not going well there. Everywhere on the continent there's a surprising boom in numbers, and severe culls needed.

e.g. 23/12/2012 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-11948612

0
0

Reasons...

"In 2009, there were 199 "incidents" involving wild boar penetrating the Barcelona suburbs. Between January and September 2010, this jumped to 540, meaning roughly a threefold increase in incursions for the year as a whole."

I don't know if this is a direct result of population size. If you look at most migrations of wildlife to urban areas (eg foxes, herring gulls), it seems to be more about the ease of finding food in urban environment than the difficulty of finding food elsewhere.

Reducing litter and securing bins is the first line of defense.

3
0
Anonymous Coward

@Reasons + 1

There was a news report on A3 this morning that showed people putting food out for them so they don't even need to go foraging.

0
0

This post has been deleted by a moderator

Anonymous Coward

Broadhead

I take it they have never seen the damage a well placed broadhead can do, but then why use facts when histiria gets so much more attention.

Man I hate these groups.

7
0
Badgers

drug eluting

bow hunters across the pond have been known to set up tree platforms with bait below and use arrows with coaxial rubber sleeve to contain drugs to immobilise/kill.

Badgers because...

0
0
Silver badge
Unhappy

Why doesn't that

surprise me.

It's a wonder the remote contolled crossbows from Ye Olde TV show 'The Golden Shot' havn't turned up on some 'Good Ol' Huntin' ' website.

Guns have.

Gives Dudes a bad name, again.

0
0
Bronze badge

Not only in Spain

We have wild boar in this part of France (just over the boarder from Spain), that are a real pest. Not only do they dig up the gardens but wander through the village at night annoying all the dogs. Fortunately the local hunters group make their monthly sweep which occasionally bags one but more importantly drives them off for a while.

0
0
Anonymous Coward

You have to be bloody good...

...to get a clean kill with a bow and arrow.

I think they should go back to spears. They can also legitimately call it "sporting" then too.

0
2
Anonymous Coward

No more so

Than with a rifle. Getting close enough to make the shot in the first place is a diffrent matter.

0
0
Happy

*shrugs*

I used to bullseye womp rats in my T16 back home.

2
0
Silver badge
Coat

My God!

"You shoot small animals for fun? That's the first indicator of a serial killer, you freak!"

(c) Family Guy - Blue Harvest ;-)

0
0
Anonymous Coward

Wild boar hunting

After seeing the title I thought maybe the Catalans had gone to the aid of their Mexican cousins and declared open season on Top Gear presenters.

0
0
Thumb Down

Wild?

They may be bores at times, but they're certainly not wild. Just watch their trip across Bolivia: they winge almost as much as Karl Pilkington.

0
0
Silver badge

Could be

> which involves a slow and painful death.

Especially if you miss - boars are nasty buggers up close

6
0
Silver badge
Boffin

Bows and Arrows?

What's wrong with a traditional Boar Spear?

0
0
Thumb Down

Are you kidding???

A wild boar in Spain stands a meter tall and weighs between 50 and 150 kilograms. If you don't hit it perfectly and are not in a tree stand then it's going to come over tear you into small bloody pieces.

A boar isn't some meek mild little herbivore. Google images for boar spear and note that every one has a cross-piece to keep the boar from pushing right up the spear so that it can eat your face.

0
0
Anonymous Coward

mmm... Jabali...

@AC-1420 - Yeah, saw that Antena 3 report too, fecking clowns leaving food out for the boars.

Now if only the city would declare war on those god-awful squawking Monk Parakeets...

0
0
Thumb Up

:D <) -->

Bow and arrow is definitely the way forward. PETA, eat your heart out.

0
0
Bronze badge

Try a Crossbow, hardly "medieval" anymore

Just a thought but a "state of the art" compound crossbow can deliver a hit with the same range, accuracy and force as a shotgun slug and in complete silence. You don't need to be a "Robin Hood" archer to use one either.

Death will not be slow though I can't speak for painful, that's GOTTA smart.

Down in the hills of Pennsylvania, and elswhere in the US there are folks that take on wild boar by hand with what is endearingly called a "Pig Sticker" a double edged dagger about 10" long.

I guess that's because they like to even the odd's for the pig.

0
0
Happy

bacon sarnies for all

that sounds good to me....start hunting.

0
0
Anonymous Coward

Where do I sign up?

I live in Catalunya. And I've got the correct arrow for it. It came from Papua New Guinea. I've got another arrow from there. It's designed for human targets...

It is true that there's not much enthusiasm for bull-fighting here. On the other hand, look up "correbous" and go figure.

0
0

Robots with grenades

Why don't they get the San Francisco robot with the grenades to take out the boars?

0
0

title

There are concerns about causing the animals a "slow and painful death"

Is anyone surprised? This is Spain we're talking about, a country that's turned torturing animals into a national pastime.

0
1
Silver badge

Oh the irony

Ironically, Spain also has a strong anti-toreada movement and seem to have better progress in banning bull-fighting than their former colonies.

Oh, and Catalans *hate* Spain, which they consider to be a rebaptized "Castilla". Calling a Catalan "Spaniard" would get you a response such as "I'm not a ****** Spaniard!"

0
0

This post has been deleted by its author

Bronze badge

Weaponry

I once saw a guy giving an atl-atl demonstration who said he'd hunted wild boar in Pennsylvania with it. I've only done it with a gun, myself. I hope these guys in Spain are hunting in groups, because the boars tend to travel in groups, and if you miss with a bow (or your gun jams), you could be pig food...

FYI, these boars have teeth the size of your pinky finger and weigh as much as 2 or 3 people.

0
0
Silver badge

Speaking as a rancher who no longer hunts ...

... shooting wild boar isn't hunting. It's varminting.

A good, well-placed, razor-sharp broad-head will drop a pig faster than a similar well-placed 12-gauge slug ... seems there is less trauma to the meat, so the pig bleeds out faster (hamburger makes for a good plug). And in my opinion, the sharp arrow head seems to cause less mental trauma to the pig, as well. I have never hit a pig with an arrow and had it flip about, biting at the wound. I can't say the same about slugs.

I use my old Browning bow where allowed ... and my Browning shotgun where not allowed. Other tools include the afore mentioned 7-foot boar spear, just in case you miss too badly and piss-off the pig (technique is "get a clean shot through the heart & lungs, but if you miss, place butt of spear on ground, set your back foot on it, and track charging pig's chest with the sharp end, all the while trying not to shit yourself"). I also carry my Kimber, in .45 ACP, for the coup de grâce if/when needed.

I always have "wild boar", smoked and/or salted & hanging, and in the freezer ...

Them boys is seriously tasty. They aren't really "wild boar", but a cross between domestic pigs and true European wild boar ... the wild ones were brought into California back in the late 1800s for so-called "sport hunting" purposes. They managed to cross with the more domestic variety. They look, and taste, like the real wild ones from Europe ... if a trifle smaller.

Anyone griping about killing off pests that don't just die and rot, but also provide proper bacon sarnies, ham, prosciutto, ribs, hocks, picnic butts and shoulders ... not to mention the sausages and blood pudding and head cheese, trotters, ears, cheeks, lard and crackling provided by all the misc. bits that are just too good to throw away ... Well, I just feel sorry for the gripers. They don't know a good thing when they smell/taste/see it. Poor bastards.

Family lore has it that I was introduced to bacon when I was two days old ... I doubt it's true, but I've had a love for all things pig since before I can remember ... We have a litter or two of domestic hogs here at the ranch every year. They are raised with tender, loving care. And then will kill them and eat them. It's called "food chain" and "apex predator" ... I'm just a trifle less mentally abusive than your average Puma/Mountain Lion ;-)

1
0

My mate from Madrid

Says that the jabalí are just trying to meet their relatives in Barcelona, but he's a Réal fan so he is his being naughty

A Boar Spear would be better for a good kill, but bloody dangerous for the hunter

Should get the extreme sports fans into it

0
0

Conservation hunting

The cities around here have deer population problems and they use bow hunters to thin the herds due to the lack of natural predators (although we have been having more lion sightings and them occasionally eating the family pet). Of course you have those that don't want Bambi hunts, but most agree that this is the safest way to hunt them in populated areas and avoid traffic accidents. In the large parks they will sometimes use guns to hunt but not in neighborhood areas.

0
0
Silver badge

Bacon sarnies?

I've eaten a lot of boar meet but never bacon from a boar. I have a hunch it wouldn't be like (english) bacon at all.

As an archer myself I think the only reason hunting with the bow is illegal in the UK is because bow manufacturers didn't have enough money to 'pay the expenses' of MP's when whatever bill that made it illegal went through.

0
0
This topic is closed for new posts.

Forums