Skype is slowly coming back to life after suffering a major outage over the past few days and, in an effort to say sorry, the firm is offering to compensate its paying customers. Users of the VoIP service were unable to log into Skype on Wednesday, and the trouble has continued for many over the past 48 hours. The company's …
Why would a peer-to-peer system be routing calls through supernodes, unless it is to make it easier for the security services to monitor people. See the NSA helping Microsoft secure Windows :)
Because it isn't peer to peer?
Most Skype users are behind firewalls or NAT routers. The software CANNOT connect directly to another node because there is nothing to connect with. How does it even know the IP of the other person or if they're on/offline unless its registered on a central place? Instead both endpoints connect to a server which will play matchmaker and route messages from one to the other, or if possible provide a direct P2P path.
I expect traffic is encrypted to and fro, but if you were worried about backdoors then double encrypt your traffic or don't use Skype at all. For example use Jabber. Jabber also requires you connect to a server (for much the same reasons as Skype) but you may if you wish set up your own private Jabber server and even encrypt the traffic if you like. Wikileaks uses Jabber for example although I expect they far more reason to be paranoid than you do.
As for NSA helping secure windows, why wouldn't they help with that. If you haven't noticed Chinese, Russian, North Korean, Iranian hackers have a very strong motive to attack US systems. It's in the US governments national interest to make its computing infrastructure as secure as possible.
It's also in their interest to ensure they can see what is going on in China, Russia, North Korea and Iran....
Well it ain't running here
We still can't log in at 1215 in north west London.
It looks like some expensive phone calls to the US later today.
Skype's OK in the land of the Killerdogz
FAO the previous poster:
I'm in Wallington, Surrey and the service on Skype is up and running for me
l'll think it was a firewall update.
Comodo had one go out about then. ha ha ha
Still not working here in Australia...
Tried calling my father several times for Christmas over the last hour.
He can hear me perfectly, however I only get a few words out of every ten from him.
He is (soon to be "was" I suspect) a paying customer. Their "support" people have been wasting his time and denying the problem exists. Wankers.
Obviously looking for alternatives now.
Their proposed "IPO" doesn't sound like such a good idea now either.
20 mil a day?
I know, though it might not compare to the volume of ordinary telcos, but in its right context, I think, that's impressive.
Given the usual reliability of Skype and it's reasonable cost ...
few people can criticise a failure particularly since it occurred on a major business break. Mind you, if you were travelling and needed to contact your travel agent you might be a little excised.
A tip of the hat for a great service, Skype.
Stll not working
Well it is still not letting me log in.
Supernodes are not evil
Supernodes are inherent part of a lot of p2p networks. The advantage is you get better performance bootstrapping from a supernode than making every node a supernode - which would be painful for most users. It's a compromise between practicality and decentralisation. It's common to have supernodes/relay nodes on P2P networks.
- HALF A BILLION TERRORISTS: WhatsApp encrypts ALL its worldwide jabber
- HUMAN DNA 'will be FOUND ON MOON' – rocking boffin Brian Cox
- Bang! You're dead. Who gets your email, iTunes and Facebook?
- YOU are the threat: True confessions of real-life sysadmins
- Blackpool hotel 'fines' couple £100 for crap TripAdvisor review