Feeds

back to article Amazon randomly censoring incest books

Confusion over the censorship policy at Amazon continues to mount, with news this week that the company now appears to be removing incest-themed material from its Kindle. Evidence that not all was well in the world of Amazon first surfaced in a discussion thread on Amazon’s own Kindle Community forum. Author Jess C Scott asked …

COMMENTS

This topic is closed for new posts.

Page:

Stop

Cowards

I stopped using amazon when they bowed to US pressure.

Amazon should pick a stance on permitted erotica and go with it. Flip flopping around with your policies based on tabloid backed opinions is retarded.

13
1

not so simple

As with Apple, the "no porn" issue is not exactly one of parental motivation, its a matter of dealing with a myriad of laws covering controlled sale of porn material, including requirements to validate age, proper display of the material, or outright bans on certain content, which are made worse when trying to compare state to state.

As for online-only or mail order sales, most of these laws don't apply, but because Apple has retail outlets in (is it every state now?) most states, its more complicated. Amazon has distribution facilities in a dozen or more states as well.

This is all the fault of Republican Christian Zombie Vampires, oh and Tipper Gore too.

2
1

Amazon?

Oh, I see, you mean US Amazon. Why didn't you say that in the first place.

3
0
Joke

I don't know...

Maybe they wanted to keep it in the family...

3
0

Silly people.

>and open to charges that its policy is mostly to give in whenever the moral majority

>comes calling in sufficient numbers

Hold on I'll get that one for you.

'and open to charges that its policy is mostly to give in whenever the vocal minority comes calling in sufficient numbers'

Moral majority? who are those exactly? would that be 'everybody else'? in which case Amazon can argue that since the rest of the world HASN'T complained then the complainers are far out numbered.

'Sufficient numbers' must surely be something like at least 10% of the global population I would have thought

Anyway - does this mean that as a UK person if I buy a kindle will my choice of reading material be artificially constrained? or is it just the USAians (tm) that are affected?

ttfn

5
0

indirectly

See, its not the complainers who do lobby against amazon, it;s the ones who successfully already lobbied to their state legislatures, creating an array of complex and differing by state laws covering how porno material is legally allowed to be displayed, advertised, and sold. In most states, especially in the south, its harder to buy porn than it is to buy liqueur. Since amazon has a physical footprint in that state (distro warehouses and/or offices), and is bound to collect taxes and obey local laws in those states, they have to follow local laws. Taxes are one thing, as they apply mostly equally to all items sold in that state, but porno rules are complex, and don't easily apply to Amazon, or Apple's, electronic sales processes. So, they simply ban it (and gain favor in elderly and church communities, and with some parents).

0
1
Troll

Moral Majority

The Moral Majority was in fact a minority - It was a US-based political action / pressure group which pretended that they' were defending the majority of the citizenry in the US from Things We Don't Like. IOW, trolls.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_Majority

They're gone, now, but their spirtual heirs linger on, kinda like a bad stink after taking a particualrly foul crap.

5
0
Silver badge

Hammer and anvil

Honestly, I wouldn't want to be the guy in charge of making these decisions at Amazon. No matter what they do, people will complain on both sides...

One might regret that they are not willing to make a stand and go "we will publish anything without censorship" but they are a business trying to make money, not a civil rights organization. Accordingly, they try to make everybody happy, even though this is clearly not possible.

3
5
Troll

Re: Hammer and anvil

you don't actually need to keep "everyone happy," that is why you have policies and _laws_.

did those book break any law? did they break any _clear_ policy? if not, then the book can NOT, nay _should_ NOT, be removed no matter who is complaining and no matter what *your* personal opinion is.

7
1
Silver badge
FAIL

they're obliged to sell?

I don't think so. It's Amazon's business and they can sell what they like. There's no obligation on their part to keep selling, whatever the moral issues are. Or, to turn it back to you, what _law_ are they breaking by stopping selling this book? Isn't their policy perfectly clear, it's at their _discretion_?

4
6
Silver badge
FAIL

Clear as mud

There is a difference between an outfit that claims to sell books and Neurotic Annie's Preselected Backyard Sale, ya know.

4
0
Silver badge

One problem

"did those book break any law? did they break any _clear_ policy? if not, then the book can NOT, nay _should_ NOT, be removed no matter who is complaining and no matter what *your* personal opinion is."

While I actually completely agree, the one problem with this is that if the Towering Intellects* can't get their pound of flesh with Amazon, they'll start screaming in the newspapers about how There Should Be A Law. And then there is one. And then we're all screwed.

But then, we're probably all screwed anyway.

*Rhymes with Shining Wits.

1
1
Stop

I'll ammend the article...

"moral majority comes calling in sufficient numbers"

"mouthy minority comes calling in sufficient numbers"

there.

6
0
Silver badge
Headmaster

And I'll amend your title.

There. ;o)

1
0
Anonymous Coward

first they came

First they came for your Rapelay

Now they come for your incest stories

Next who knows?

6
0
Coat

Next...

They simply couldn't come any more, being somewhat drained and exhausted...

17
0
Coffee/keyboard

*cof* *cof* <spill drink>

You, sir, owe me a new keyboard!

0
0
FAIL

typical

Typical conservative America, terrified by anything slightly different. Morons.

5
2
Silver badge

It's not just that they aren't selling them

They are removing copies which have already been purchased from the customer's personal archive on their servers. And according to some reports they are insulting customers who try to get a refund.

See for instance http://theselfpublishingrevolution.blogspot.com/2010/12/amazon-in-book-banning-business.html

7
0
Silver badge
WTF?

Now that DOES surprise me

I'm disappointed, but not be any means shocked that Amazon is removing some of their more controversial content, but I'm really quite surprised to hear they would repeat their "1984" blunder after having apologized profusely and paying $150,000 in damages. Further more this claims the customer didn't even receive a refund, making it an outright theft. Frankly I'm a little skeptical that really happened.

0
0
Silver badge
Coat

Oops

I obviously didn't read that close enough. For the benefit of anyone who made the same mistake, no one is saying Amazon is actually "disappearing" the books off customer's devices this time. What they are apparently doing is removing them from the online archive, thus making it impossible to re-download as you are normally allowed to do. That's substantially less creepy, but still pretty bad if the book was purchased with the understanding that this online backup would remain available.

0
0

quick bit of research

shows that the book title given in the article doesn't exist on amazon.co.uk

0
0
Anonymous Coward

I may surprise you to know

1. Amazon can choose what it puts on sale, sort of like Waterstones.

2. Amazon doesn't give a toss what anyone else thinks about that.

2
5

That's as may be..

But when you pay for a book you don't expect it to disappear with no reason and no refund. Even if you haven't paid anything for a book, having it suddenly disappear fro your collection is not reasonable.

Also when you look through an 'erotica' section what might you expect to find? you've no reason to be surprised when the books turn out to be a little adult in nature.

ttfn

7
0
Silver badge

OK, but

Except Waterstones' shop assistant won't break into your house to take back a previously sold book from your shelf because his manager decided that it is no longer appropriate, licensed, politically correct etc.

Kindle = BD player = Internet-connected TV = iPhone = Steam = any other DRMed crap and those who use it are either ignorant or not very bright or just like to be abused.

12
1
Big Brother

AC@ 15

Yup, Amazon CAN choose what they put on sale.

BUT in this instance they received a book from the author, printed it, offered it for sale in both electronic and printed format, sold it in both formats and THEN unilaterally removed it from their customers' devices.

I perceive a major difference.

9
0
FAIL

Of course they give a toss !!!

Of course they give a toss what people think. If they believe that something they are or are not doing will impact sales then they will change their behavior.

Companies spend billions trying to work out what people think.

2
0
Silver badge
Thumb Down

Re: I may surprise you to know

Actually, it would be great if that were true, but it's not and that's exactly the problem. If Amazon didn't care what anyone thought about what they sell, they would obviously choose to sell as much as possible since, unlike Waterstones, they have near unlimited shelf space (especially for virtual goods like Kindle books).

But apparently they do care what people think, because they bow to public pressure by removing whatever certain people find offensive.

0
0
Bronze badge

There's a law for that

There are clear laws in most countries about what is acceptable and what isn't. All Amazon has to do is apply them. Yes, it calls for judgement, but that is what lawyers are for. Once the books remaining pass the test of law, Amazon should defend its right to sell.

This is why self-published books are such a pain: books accepted by publishers have already been tested by someone's judgement.

0
2
Silver badge
FAIL

clear laws in most countries

Clear?

"Yes, it calls for judgement"

So much for clear. Who gets to be the judge? Oh I see it's someone... very clear, glad that's all straightened up.

0
0
Thumb Down

Private company

First, Amazon are a private company and they can do anything they like in terms of not selling books. They should be making their decisions on whether or not the decision makes them more money. However they don't seem to be taking this account in their censorship decisions.

Bowing down to a vocal but minority* sector of your customers doesn't make much difference to your profit line. If you are large enough, like Amazon, then even negative publicity campaigns won't make any difference either (see Vodophone and UKUncut). All it does is mean that you can't sell to another minority who would have bought the products.

* The moral majority are actually a minority group, just very vocal and they label themselves as the majority.

0
0

@AC

Too right.

You have the right to write anything you like. However you don't have the right to force anyone to sell or distribute it. Tough titty, basically (although that's a whole new category...)

1
3
Grenade

Start with this book...

I expect to hear that Amazon have applied their censorship in an even handed way and removed other titles which throw incest about as though it were a normal state of affairs, that would surely please the "Moral Pejority" (TM Me 2010)... starting with the Old Testament!

3
0
Heart

"If underage sex is illegal, why is Vladimir Nabokov's Lolita still available for purchase?"

I'm not sure that's quite what she meant...

2
0
FAIL

Laws?

"There are clear laws in most countries about what is acceptable and what isn't."

Are there actually laws in the US that specifically tell you what you are not allowed to write down in a fictional form?

1
0

no

but there are laws about how, where, and to who that content can be sold. I don't think this is amazon getting involved personally in this decision, I'm thinking this was an unfriendly phone call from a few state AGs letting them know they might want to repeal some of what they were selling in violation of that state's law, but it was kept under the table if Amazon quietly complied.

Apple doesn't sell porn not because Steve is a prude, but because dealing with local pornography sale legislation is more complex than dealing with tax collection, has ridiculously severe penalties, and pretty much most of it can;t be applied to simple online transactions. They have physical outlets in those states, so what mail order firms can do to get around state laws, they can not.

1
1
Silver badge
Megaphone

Yesh, there is a law about that

“Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.”

Alas, enforcement is spotty at best.

0
0

think on it

If every book that someone disapproved of was removed from sale, it's unlikely that any book anywhere would ever have been published

2
0

Waiting to see

if they dare apply this to George R R Martin's work in the Song of Ice and Fire saga. There's rape of children, consensual sex with children, rampant incest, and depravity galore in those books. I can;t wait to see how they're handling this on HBO (I know many of the characters have already been "aged" to handle some of it).

2
0
Gold badge
Coat

Oopsie!

"....they would judge each case on its merit, and they would act as their own judge and jury..."

Cue lawsuit from Apple claiming that they own the IP to that process.....

5
0
Paris Hilton

@"Hammer and anvil"

Is this comment title also a reference to the Harry Turtledove novel of that name (0-345-38048-7) in which the main character has intimate relations with his cousin? Or is that a coincidence?

Paris, because I'd sure like to see her try to put on those red boots...

And thanks to my father for giving me this book in the first place. I suppose he had to thin the library and (oblig.) he at least kept the book in the family.

2
0
FAIL

Why this is now more scary...

... is because the EBook market is starting to mature. EBook readers are becoming more popular, and people are starting to consider this as a serious medium (not sure I subscribe to that, but hey...).

Actual book shops are now shutting down, due to pressure of online sales.

Unless your book is Disney-sweet, it's likely to get removed by all the vendors who are the first port of call for EBook customers.

It's commercial censorship.

Better hope Waterstones and Barnes & Noble stay afloat...

4
0
WTF?

"whenever the moral majority comes calling in sufficient numbers" ???

This should read...

"whenever the self righteous minority comes screaming at the top of their voices in any numbers"

4
0
Unhappy

MY beliefs count - screw you

As a fervent believer in an omnipotent God I am pleased that Amazon has removed this book, as I demanded.

Now please remove ALL books that mention the theory of evolution, 'Buddism for Beginners', and Harry Potter.

2
0
FAIL

Perfectly valid reasoning...

...on why one must be puddled to buy a Kindle.

At least all my paper books are mine and can't be taken back by the retailer I bought them from.

2
0
FAIL

No Kindle for Christmas

I had been thinking about which e-Reader to get for Christmas, but Amazon's behaviour has suddenly made that decision a bit easier.

When I buy books I do so in the belief that I'll probably keep them for years and will almost certainly read them repeatedly over the years. I am certainly not going to pay for books that can be stolen from my collection whenever Amazon decides a book is no longer suitable.

3
0
Silver badge

Just a suggtion, but...

TELL Amazon. They have clearly shown that they ARE swayed by public pressure, perhaps there just aren't enough people vociferously pressing on this side.

0
0
Unhappy

@Pablo (and telling Amazon)

I agree, tell Amazon you won't buy a Kindle whilst they continue to excerise unacceptable control over that which you purchase from them. I certainly will (and am sick of explaining why I want an e-book, but don't recommend a Kidle, to people). However, last time I emailed them, when they launched their UK MP3 store, telling them I won't buy albums (or more than the odd track, at least), until they provide them in FLAC, you can probably guess how much of a toss they gave, due to the speed of the response.....(I'm still waiting ;) )

The iRiver cover looks the most interesting/likely e-book reader to me, at the moment....

0
0
Anonymous Coward

Why I wouldnt ever buy a kindle or similar

I have little doubt that they charge full price for the books available unlike real books and at least with a real book I dont have it disappear at the whim of Amazon.

0
0
Silver badge
WTF?

I will now read from the book of Genesis Chapter 19 Verses 30-38

30 Lot and his two daughters left Zoar and settled in the mountains, for he was afraid to stay in Zoar. He and his two daughters lived in a cave.

31 One day the older daughter said to the younger, “Our father is old, and there is no man around here to give us children—as is the custom all over the earth.

32 Let us get our father to drink wine and then sleep with him and preserve our family line through our father.”

33 That night they got their father to drink wine, and the older daughter went in and slept with him. He was not aware of it when she lay down or when she got up.

34 The next day the older daughter said to the younger, “Last night I slept with my father. Let us get him to drink wine again tonight, and you go in and sleep with him so we can preserve our family line through our father.”

35 So they got their father to drink wine that night also, and the younger daughter went in and slept with him. Again he was not aware of it when she lay down or when she got up.

36 So both of Lot’s daughters became pregnant by their father.

37 The older daughter had a son, and she named him Moab; he is the father of the Moabites of today.

38 The younger daughter also had a son, and she named him Ben-Ammi; he is the father of the Ammonites of today.

Erm, excuse me, Amazon...!!!

4
0

Page:

This topic is closed for new posts.