Work continues apace down at the Paper Aircraft Released Into Space (PARIS) workshop, where we've been looking at just how to skin our Vulture 1-X vehicle. Before we get to that, though, we're delighted to announce that our audacious upper atmosphere project now officially exists, because Wikipedia says so. Lovely. Now, on with …
Won't it add too much weight to the air(paper)craft? My guess is that you already took this into consideration, so I'm curious to know how are you managing the design trade-offs (if any) to account for the paper and glue covering?
Model Aeroplane materials
In my distant youth I used to build balsa wood planes skinned with tissue. The tissue was somewhat stronger than the stuff you buy at the newsagent and there was a special solvent based dope for it.
You skinned the plane, sprinkled a little water on the tissue to shrink it and then doped the skin. The result (most times) was a tight, tough, wrinkle free skin. The dope added a lot of toughness.
I remember that stuff. Of course, you had to remember to use it in a well ventilated room... Or not...
I wonder if it's still readily available or if it's been banned by 'elf and safety?
"In my distant youth I used to build balsa wood planes skinned with tissue"
"You skinned the plane, sprinkled a little water on the tissue to shrink it and then doped the skin. The result (most times) was a..."
A very stoned Mahatma. Glue-sniffing modellers. Gah.
<-- Flame because you couldn't dope tissue and smoke at the same time.
I'm finding this coverage really rather exciting. I can't wait for the next article.
So when do you reckon it'll be airbourne?
What about the latter?
You speak of the former, - what of the latter?
84gsm Paper in the Bog? OUCH
Which is your standard: Glossy or Matte?
Beats the P180 grade wet and dry....
(badgers due to the legendary roughness of their posteriors)
Not even true
If badgers' arses are really so rough, why do they make shaving brushes out of them?
OK, joking aside this is showing excellent engineering practice - what would have happened if you hadn't tested the release mechanism properly? This would make a good introduction to engineering article.
Now all it needs is a copule of paintball cannons...
Drawing a blank...
I've no idea why I'm following this project....is it cause I is geek? Loving it!
Looks OK, but I'm somewhat puzzled by the use of PVA. A shrinking dope would surely be better since it will pull the skin nice and tight. If you're concerned about the amount of shrinkage putting the skin under too much tension then don't - you can vary the amount of shrinkage,
I've even come across people going so far as to use different amount of shrinkage on different panels in order that the tension will alter the shape of the structure. Going a bit far if you ask me.
This reminds me of Blue Peter! All the tissue paper and PVA I mean, not the Rizlas and dope!
Where is the ..,
Double sided sticky tape?
80GSM paper for tissue?
Tissue is not so feeble once it's been shrunk and doped - did you get as far as trying that? I'd be trying it, myself. I can't help feeling you're adding a lot of mass with the thicker paper skin. The idea is to support things on the frame and use the skin to provide rigidity.
You can still poke a hole through it, but it's pretty strong and you'll sort out the wrinkles at the same time.
When it comes the strength you can get tissue with directional "grain". To make a strong covering with this you can layer it with the grain running at right angles. You can also change the angle for different effects or increase the number of layers. The world is your lobster.
One thing to watch out for is that this stuff doesn't necessarilly shrink the same amount along and accross its grain when treated with a shrinking dope.
You are still using wrong paper
The best paper for this kind of stuff is the so called "rice paper" which used to be used by draftsmen for copying stuff around a drawing. Try that - it is lighter than normal 80, much stronger than 80 and you really need to break the stupidometer by driving it off the scale to wrinkle that.
The accuracy and integrity of the Wiki can not be doubted - indeed, it is most likely that the name "Vulture 1" has something, a vague something perhaps but a likelihood no less, to do with the vulture logo. I'm guessing. Maybe you need to join the talk page and add a little something.
Hard to find?
"with silver Rizlas and dope. Sadly, the former are a bit hard to come by round here,"
You guys are smoking some serious shit if only the Rizlas are hard to find, nice, pass the doobie now?
Is this a title?
Lester - you get to build paper planes and type things like "tighter than a nun's naughty bits" and call it work.
You lucky, lucky bastard!
Can I borrow your job sometime please? It looks like a hell of a lot of fun...
If you want a carton of silver Rizlas, I've got one going spare. As I said previously, I hate 'em ;)
I'm loving this :D
I hope you guy's are gonna publish the plans once you're done... we can all have PARIS then!
I love how El Reg has embraced the greatest of IT traditiions by sticking 2010 as part of the version and logo.
A date that is surely destined to slip (if IT tradtition is to be followed).
Unless 2010 doesn't relate to the year, and is some other relevant number ?
Grams weight of the vehicle?
Metres from launch point expected to crash (sorry, land) ?
Number of ants carried ?
I, and I think I speak for most Reg readers on this, would like to see a lot more high-res, detailed pictures of Paris's bare skin, shot from all angles and (preferably) in good light, although the light is a secondary consideration. If you could possibly get together a video covering the entire area of skin, that would be even better.
How cold is your freezer?
By the time you, well the plane, get to release altitude it's going to be at most -50C which is colder than most domestic appliances manage. If you're only testing in a home freezer you may still get problems at release as things get more brittle.
Just a thought.
I got a -80C in the lab at work if you fancy shipping a sample out to Seattle I'll pop it in over night to give it a test! Anything to cop a feel of PARIS ;-)
<- Well it's obvious ain't it.
A way of testing in colder temps
possibly lester can get his hands on a CO2 fire extinguisher - give it a good solid blast from that and it should get pretty darn cold right quick. alternatively, get your hands on some dry ice/liquid nitrogen and an esky? should be available, and -200 odd degrees should be colder than you will see in the atmosphere.
<-- good pub engineering this.
Thats a bit nippy.
Cheech & Chong
Like man, hey, like ... "Big Bambu" ... album .... rizzla papers ....... like, what were we doing here.
All well and good...
...but will we see Vulture 1 at the 2011 Farnborough Airshow?
PARIS at Farnborough?
In 2011? I doubt it'll be making any kind of formal representation; Farnborough's every two years and it was on last week. Next offical one: 2012. Mind you, if PARIS wants to come and lie on a table outside the entrance gates next year, I'm sure there'd still be a hommage.
Dope & silk
When I used to make model planes 20+ years ago I used silk and nitrate dope, I found a good site describing exactly how to do it:
Maybe you've missed the point, but this is a PAPER plane.
I too built balsa planes in my youth and recall doping tissue paper very well. At one point in the '80s, I tried a shrink-wrap plastic covering which was light, very colourful and easy to apply. While these coverings would almost certainly be lighter than normal paper and PVA, I think they might stress the straws too much. Balsa 'gives', straws buckle. If you can afford the weight, go with what you've got.
exactly what I was thinking
propietary name solar film i believe
yes i was right.!
it's the mutts nuts for what you are about - you can vary the tension my varying the heat you apply.
also as noted elsewhere - you need to dope the paper properly to relalt test this, i tjhink we used to use buturate dope? few coats of that and you'll have no problems with water.
From memory PVA is not water resistant.
What are the chances of condensation or clouds becoming an issue at lower altitudes? The plane will probably be quite cold too so might attract condensation.
Immerse PVA in water and it won't be happy, but it will take a while. I think it's best described as water resistant. Water does run off it. I've seen this often engough with stuff my son makes with "sticky white glue".
The P in PARIS...
...clearly is plastic not paper. Just because it contains some paper does not make it a paper aeroplane. You will be telling me next that a Jumbo is made of rubber just because hat rubber tyres (or is that tires?)
By the way PVA dope: that is "Heavy man, really heavy".
....which bits of the structure are plastic then?
To be fair..
it doesn't really have to fly... It is only a Paper Aircraft Released In Space (or close enough) That says nothing about acutally having to fly... infact if recovery is intended then a really poor glide slope would help a lot. just imaging how far you'd have to drive if it achieves a 1:35 glide slope.. (I know it can't achieve that initially, but hey, do the maths for fun!)
- Crawling from the Wreckage Want a more fuel efficient car? Then redesign it – here's how
- Review Xperia Z3: Crikey, Sony – ANOTHER flagship phondleslab?
- Human spaceships dodge ALIEN BODY skimming Mars
- Ex-US Navy fighter pilot MIT prof: Drones beat humans - I should know
- Downrange Are you a gun owner? Let us in OR ELSE, say Blighty's top cops