Feeds

back to article Mutated genetic supertrout developed in lab

After ten years of tinkering with DNA in a Rhode Island lab, a top fish boffin claims he has created a genetically enhanced mutant supertrout. "Our findings are quite stunning," says Professor Terry Bradley, an expert on trout, salmon, flounder and tuna. "The results have significant implications." Bradley says he has managed …

COMMENTS

This topic is closed for new posts.

Page:

Silver badge
Coat

Mutated Genetic SuperTrout

Sounds like the mother-in-law...........

3
0
FAIL

Wrong fish

Isn't it supposed to be sea-bass?

0
0
Silver badge

Loks like a cross between

a fish and one of those big black slugs I find in my garden.

more to the point, are they ill-tempered?

1
0

My God! What have we done?

Some supervillian will now apply this to the Great White, and man will finally be confined to land.

Oh, the humanity!

1
0
Welcome

Its only a matter of time ....

I for one welcome our new fishy overlords

2
1

great white...

Can they not experiment with something interesting like great white sharks. Or lions. Or gorillas.

Saving the trout farming industry a few quid is, i am almost certain, a very noble cause, but surely what the world really wants is to see some massive uber predator. Preferably a pair of king kongs that can duke it out for our entertainment.... possibly with ant n dec hosting.

3
0
Happy

@Andrew JAmes

Wouldn't it be better to have a King Kong duking it out *with* Ant and Dec?

2
0
Anonymous Coward

eXistenZ was on last night...

...and we're still in the game, right?

0
1

Tip for the subs

NB: There is a breed of cattle called 'Belgian Blue', nothing new in its genetics. The actual cow doesn't have to come from Belgium; similar to Charolais , Jersey or Friesian cows, its just the area when they originated.

Agri IT. Big business.

0
0

MONSTROUS

This monstrosity should be quarantined. If people farm this hideous perversion it will eventually interbreed with the wild populations. Do I need to explain why this would be disastrous? Some redneck that works in the lab mopping the floors will steal a few specimen and soon our rivers will be overrun by these mutants. This research should not have been funded!

3
3
Flame

I taek it you are a frankentard ?

OOOHHH genertic engineering....

0
0
Thumb Up

sure the opposite of Frankentard.

Frankentard - love it.

But what is somebody who is anti-frankenstein? Suggestions please (must end in ..tard)

0
0
Flame

v--- Here is the torch

I'll get the pitchforks. The rest of the lynching mob should be here any minute now. Get ready to be soaked in boiling tar

0
0
Silver badge
FAIL

A frankentard?

Or someone expressing a legitimate concern that if these fish were released into the wild, they may outcompete the natural species, in much the same way as introducing a foreign species is usually bad for an ecosystem?

So, in response to you calling someone a frankentard, can I take the opportunity to call you a 'tardtard'* for your willingness to stick the suffix 'tard' onto any word?

*Irony is intentional, just in case it doesn't go without saying.

0
0
Silver badge
Stop

I'm not geting involved.........

...........in this childish name calling contest.

2
0
Silver badge

Yes you need to explain

Bigger muscles cost more food to grow and maintain, but at some point provide no advantage to a trout. Evolution has already selected the ideal amount of muscle for a trout. If you double the amount of muscle on some trout, and release them into the wild they will stand a smaller chance of survival than normal trout.

It is like the insecticide gene placed in some plants. The gene requires lots of energy to produce insecticide. It is an advantage in a field dosed with loads of fertiliser. In the real world, other plants not wasting energy on insecticide grow faster and overshadow plants with the insecticide gene.

Moving a gene from one species to another is challenging enough. Selecting the required genes to give a significant advantage compared to the results of millions of years of natural selection is beyond our ability.

2
0
FAIL

@ Flocke Kroes

The trouble is that once the alien DNA is introduced to an ecosystem, it takes millions of years to breed it out again - if that ever happens. The wild Atlantic salmon DNA has been disturbed effectively for all time by allowing farmed salmon to escape. As has been pointed out elsewhere, introducing a different strain can upset a whole ecosystem, resulting in native species being endangered or driven to extinction. Look at the introduction of ruff to Loch Lomond by anglers using them as livebait: now the powan or "freshwater herring", which was perfectly adapted to the environment, needs human measures to preserve it - a species that has existed in and that has been perfectly adapted to that environment since the last Ice Age. The laissez-faire approach to introducing alien DNA is irresponsible and doesn't necessarily result in any improvement.

0
0
Silver badge

Bigger, more powerful...

Hope they've not invented the samlon (from 'The Legacy of Heorot'). Don't want any Grendels escaping the fish farm!

2
0
Gold badge
Joke

Old hat.

The British car industry is way ahead in this field. I remember reading in the Toadygraph at the millenium that the Queen had been presented with a new Bentley, equipped with an "800bhp twin-turbot engine".

400 horsepower Turbot beat out slightly stronger Trout any day in my book.

1
0
Silver badge
Paris Hilton

Teeth?

The fish in the vid has had its transgenic Piranha teeth removed for safe handling.

After DARPA read "Salmon Fishing in the Yemen" they planned to release them as Taliban killers!

Paris 'cos we don't have a fish icon. cough!

0
0

The cow is not dead...

Lovely cow, the genetically engineered Belgian Blue. Lovely plumage.

1
0
Thumb Down

dear god no

What...the....fuck?

And he wants us to eat them as well?

This has to stop, seriously this is not a good thing.

0
0
FAIL

Now I Know How...

...Mr. Burns was feeling when Marge fed him Blinky.

Just eating chickens full of estrogen made American girls start "blooming" at age 11 or 12. I think much of the overweight problem is also animal feed additive related. This is the same problem but from a gene splicing way.

This is basically a gene that makes steroids. Yeah that's gonna be healthy.

0
0

Trout milk?

Don't tell the New York chefs - they'll use it for cheese.

0
0
Silver badge

Revolutionary?

They think they can grow the double-size fish for the same amount of food? Have they also found a way around the laws of conservation? Or are the fish going to feed on dark matter in addition to fish food?

2
0
Silver badge

Easy to double size with constant food

Simply halve the quantity.

0
0
Anonymous Coward

Question is...

Are they ill-tempered?

0
0
Big Brother

Humans next?

Why go through the tiresome henchmen selection process when you can breed your own super-muscled goons, who can then wrestle the troublesome government operatives into the execution pool more easily?

0
0
Coat

Execution pool for government operatives

I insist that the pool's death-dealing properties be administered by having the troublesome operatives stand on a platform above it, said platform collapsing at the press of a button by an evil finger (or, possibly, collapsing when activated by a head-mounted device), relying on gravity to propel operative flesh towards hungry transgenic mouths. I sense a new Bond film coming on ...

I'll get me coat, the one with the secret pockets and the lever that makes it turn into a motorbike.

0
0
Bronze badge

doesn't count

It only counts if they breed fricking LASERs into them.

2
0
Coat

Ah ....

But you have to admit this is a good first step.

First create something that can carry the dead weight of the energy weapon THEN add the energy weapon. They have probably had the gene splices for the Laser for the last ten years, but the fish wasn't strong enough to do more than sit on the bottom of the pool. Expect another anouncment soon.

Now if you'll excuse me I must see about getting my pre-order in for the next version to stock my moat.

Mines the one with the keys to the secret lair in a volcano and the copy of "How to be an Evil super villain"

1
0

Not Sharks...

...electric eels would be a good start!

0
0
Bronze badge

Is it just me?

Or have none of these scientists read Oryx and Crake????

0
0
Linux

Surely

in 10 years they could have selectively bred bigger trout?

or is that 'old skool' tech passe now?

super penguins, now you're talking!

0
0
Silver badge
Welcome

The day of the trout is upon us!

I for one welcome our burly, salmonoid overlords...especially with a side of tartar sauce.

1
0

Whats the problem?

Every natural fish is a mutant compared to every other natural fish out there so why is it ok to eat natural mutants rather than ones mutated by ourselves?

You know when you cook and eat something what its dna was before does not really matter after it has been though a cooking process and our digestive process.

Anyway we have been genetically modifying creatures for are plates for thousands of years now though elective breeding, you think the pig that provided the pork your eat is a natural creature? what about the beef from cows or chickens? none of them are as they where in the wild yet a lot of you have no problem eating them.

Btw after watching the video i can not find where the guy said that these fish get bigger with the same food but if he did say that all it could mean is that they grow quicker which means they process food better, you do not fully consume every thing you eat you know a lot of it gets flushed though your system.

Hmmm i wonder why no bioscientist has not gone nuts yet and filled an island with really mutated creatures Dr Moreau style.

1
0
Troll

An island with hideously mutated creatures?

Manhattan.

1
0
Stop

Kill them now while we still can

Here in the Great Lakes region of the USA we are staging a last-ditch effort to keep 2 species of Asian carp from getting through the Chicago Ship Canal and into the Great Lakes ecosystem. These giant (up to 100 lbs.) and aggressive carp have already overrun the Mississippi River after an accidental release . They have a nasty habit of jumping at small-boat operators when they heat the sound of outboard or inboard engines and have caused many fishermen to require trips to the ER after an encounter.

We don't need these GM Frankenfish in the ecosystem!

0
0

Salmon

It wont be long before the farmed salmon industry uses this.

0
0
Go

Fish crossed with cattle?

The time saving on preparing surf & turf will undoutedly free us all from our daily labours and we can explore the galaxy as one.

1
0
Paris Hilton

Blue belgium bovine bulge benefits

"Are you happy to see me or is that a blue belgium bovine bulge benefit in your pocket?"

0
0
Silver badge
Pint

cage^H^H^H^H tank match

Are we ready to rumble?? The fight of the century where the truculent trout goes mano^H^H^H^H fin to fin with the sinister snake head in a winner take all... (What? An almond butter sauce)... move along people, nothing to see here.

0
0
Troll

The outdoor programs on cable TV might improve

Watching paint dry or grass grow is usually preferable to watching the fishing shows on cable tv here in the US. When I read the article, I imagined how much video of Bill Dance being yanked off the front of his bass boat by a 9-foot trout could improve such a show.

Then I read the comment about the asian carp in the Chicago river.

Hey Bill, we have job for you, up in Illinois, nothing too difficult....

0
0
Alien

You re doing it wrong...

That's deeply disturbing. Six pack abs fish, if they released into the wild who knows what will happen to normal trout...

0
0
Gold badge
Pint

Six pack abs fish?

If we anthropomorphise a bit, the regular trout will look at the ripped version, say something like "poncey git" and order more lager.

1
0
Anonymous Coward

Blue Blue Cow

Everybody knows cows can't do that... Mooo..

Couldn't they have bred in a useful genetic trait? Like perhaps modifiying the light emitting cells from some of the deep sea fish for higher intensity to develop trout with frickin lasers?

0
0
Pint

Calling Sam 'n' Max...

One must admire the skill with which the wily übertrout stalks its prey...

0
0
Badgers

Trout are very valuable, and immensely powerful.

Keep away from the trout.

0
0

an amazing number of professional biologists in these comments...

Wow, we have so many people who can confidently claim that a genetically modified trout is an ecological calamity just because it exists, and will be poisonous to eat anyway - and deduce all of this from nothing more than a pop science article, too! I didn't know there were so many top geneticists on the Reg comment section!

0
0
Thumb Down

I shudder to think

what could happen once this escapes into the wild. If not this particular mutant, some other mad scientific creation

0
0

Page:

This topic is closed for new posts.