NASA is pondering how to remove a rogue knob which has firmly wedged itself between a window and the dashboard of space shuttle Atlantis - an apparently minor affair which could actually result in a six-month delay in the venerable vehicle's STS-129 mission to the International Space Station, or even see the shuttle grounded for …
A Stuck knob?
Everyone knows all you have to do with a stuck knob is apply lubricant, and it'll slip right out. just make sure its water-based, or it might explode.
Paris, 'cos she knows about lube
"The options relating to the application of dry ice to shrink the knob have already been attempted, and failed."
Paris because...oh, work it out for yourselves.
Quick squirt, wait a few minutes and it'll pop right out with a bit of a tug.
Just tell the astronauts it's bling for the window and launch the shuttle.
A stuck part? Call a dentist...
... a local dentist would have that out in a jiffy. I'd do it myself but it would be a rather exteme house call.
i hate it when my knob goes rogue and gets wedged too
What knob did that? Bloody cleaners, can't get the staff these days
Maybe a Gigli saw would be less of a risk than a power drill?
Still, we don't know what the knob is made of. They do.
Read the article that's linked from el reg - looks rather serious. Can't drill for fear of damaging the window further - as it stands, looks like the window has been compromised already!
Blame the messy astronauts who didn't clear all the coke cans/mcdonalds bags from the footwells before landing her!
can't they just pop the windscreen and get those dudes off the telly to fit a new one? Surely its covered by their insurance policy...
My Ex Girlfriend
When faced with the choice of driving her car full tilt through a woodland, or driving along the road but wiping out a "sweet innocent fluffy little rabbit" embedded a treetrunk in her VW polo's engine bay. The deceleration force parted the dash from the windscreen for just long enough for a biro to become sandwiched between the two, I believe it stayed there until the car was scrapped.
Christ alone can imagine the carnage that would ensue if they let her drive the shuttle.
So the actual problem is the damage to the pane of glass, not the fact that they are probably going to have to destroy a 50p item?
Surely a dremmel and an extension tool with a disc cutter could cut the knob into pieces.
I used to know a plumber like that
6 months to remove a small metal implement from where it shouldn't be. Sounds like someone's on an hourly rate.
p.s. Who else read the headline "Rogue knob could ground space shuttle ..." and assumed it would be about a NASA manager?
The Terry's approach...
Don't tap it, fcuking whack it. Typical boffs, overthinking a problem.
#The First Dave
50p Item ? , it probably cost 1.2million USD and is made out of GOLD ALLOY.
Bolt cutters ?, probably NASA will commision a expensive one-off Bolt Cutting tool to remove errant knobs give it a long 42 alpha numeric code reference and order 15 of em just in case.
“Knob removal attempts should be performed by exhausting least risk options first. More evaluation is required.
I bet theres every scientist and tech there with there own pet "that'l do it try that" idea, just itching to sneak in and give it a go.
"Use pry bar to deflect dash down: Viewed as the riskiest removal method for all hardware involved." - my idea already thought of, they would have had to restrain me from already having a go, i probably would be trussed up in corner with a armed guard for suggesting it.
To put part of a window behind a console seems an interesting design choice. Still, they are the rocket scientists so must have their reasons.
Easy to put in place, small, make quick work of it. Dry Ice & airbags?, these guys need to get out in the field more often...
@All the inevitable cut it, saw it, cable disk cutter tools
They are NASA, some of the finest engineering minds in the world, they've already used dry ice, do you think that they haven't thought of cutting/sawing/drilling it out before that? I can think of two problems off the top of my head:
Friction causing heat and weakening the glass
Slipping next to the window glass and fucking it up.
Or maybe they are all stupid, which as they can get people into space and back (generally) safely seems unlikely.
PS: Knob. Hur, hur, hur.
Think of all the loverly metal shavings getting into the navcomp
Can't they use dry ice to keep it cool but then zap the middle with a stonking laser or something??
@My Ex Girlfriend
> Christ alone can imagine the carnage that would ensue if they let her drive the shuttle.
it would probably be perfectly fine. There aren't many rabbits in space and even fewer trees to drive into.
(BTW. I wonder how much _more_ damage she did to the ecosystem - destroyed tabbycats, sorry: habitats, run-over beetles and small furry creatures, just to save one of a million bunnies.)
I know of a C-130 (a fairly special one) where a socket wrench socket fell into a maintenance opening between the inner and outer skins of the plane, making sounds like a pachinko game till it came to rest somewhere in the belly of the plane.
Nothing short of un-riveting the front belly of the plane would retrieve it, and even that might not work. They marked the plane as "not flyable" for a week while they thought hard on the problem. Eventually, when it was becoming an issue up the chain of command, they said WTF and just flew it anyway.
I'm guessing that won't happen here for lots of reasons.
Sorry Ms Bee..
“Knob removal must be performed carefully; exhausting all risk free options first, then attempting more intrusive (higher risk) options, if others fail.”
sounds like a bad Friday night out.
'Inspections of knob have been carried out via borescope'
and that's the result of careless knob removal, a trip to the STD clinic and a thorough inspection with a borescope.
Use acid or something to dissolve the stem of the knob
Assuming the knob is metal, dissolve the stem/screw part, perhaps use an electric current to encourage a kind of reverse electroplating effect.
just turn the shuttle upside down and shake it - works for me
Sounds like the problems before Challenger's last flight
If anyone is wondering why they're being so cautious; it's because the Orbiter is incredbly fragile.
The day before Challenger made its final launch in January 1986, NASA had a problem with the orbiter's hatch. When the door closed, a couple of tiny pins should drop into place completing an electrical circuit which confirms the hatch is in place. That day, the pins didn't fall into place. Pressure tests and Mark One eyeball said the hatch was sealed and pressurised, but NASA didn't want to launch without absolute confirmation - they didn't want another Soyuz 11.
So a team was called to the Pad to replace the microswitches, they used a special aluminium tool to hold the hatch in place because they couldn't risk touching the orbiter's protective heatshield. After replacing the microswitches, they tried to remove the tool and found one of the bolts had become jammed. They couldn't use force without damaging the ship, so the only option was to cut the tool away. After a long discussion about potential damage to the orbiter, the risk from stray hydrogen boiling off the ET, they get a drill sent to the pad - the battery is flat from being left in the cold. A replacement was sent and the fix is finally made - but by then winds around the Cape exceeded the threshold for a safe return in the event of a launch failure.
The launch was scrubbed until the next day. The media had a field day that the Shuttle was a dog and made jokes about the staff who'd tried to get it to fly. Meanwhile, that night in Florida was the coldest on record.
So, the failure of one bolt probably lead directly to the explosion that destroyed Challenger.
Which explains why NASA are taking no risks with this one.
<<Several attempts have already been made to remove the knob by applying dry ice in the hope the knob would shrink...>>
Christ almighty, mine would, given the same treatment...However, G/F giving me a B/J with an ice cube in her mouth, somehow has the opposite effect...
The exact opposite observation is also valid.
Namely, the destruction of the Challenger was an indirect result of the scuttle's dependence on complex systems built from unreliable components. This was exacerbated by NASA's inability to perform a relatively simple fix in an efficient and timely manner. Leading to a delay and an unforeseen set of circumstances, where an engineering veto was over-ridden.
So far as the inability to fix a relatively simple problem (caused by a design fault), the situation appears very similar to what you've described, and has not changed at all in the past 20-plus years. Hopefully this time, the engineers will hold sway and their opinions respected.
Are windows now "compromised"...
..in the same sense that software has "issues", and wars result in "collateral damage"?
"I'm terribly sorry Mrs Jones, but I fear that my son has inadvertently compromised your greenhouse with his football. I will of course pay for its decompromisation ...."
only NASA - 4000 GB document!
Did anybody see down at the bottom of the linked document? And I quote:
"L2 members: Documentation - from which the above article has quoted snippets - is available in full in the related L2 sections, now over 4000 gbs in size."
Methinks somebody has a little too much time on their hand with a 25 Mpx camera...how in the *world* does one assemble a 4 TB document?!?
What's the knob made of?
Saw it in half using a diamond-coated wire saw? (Hand-operated, and doesn't suffer from being pinched or nipped like a dremmel saw might. Apart from a spherical diamond I doubt that there's anything one can't cut through this way!
If thermoplastic: melt it? If any polymeric material: attack it with a laser tuned to wreak havoc with molecular bonds in that particular polymer and thereby selectively decompose it?
Drill lots of holes in it until it can be crushed or crumbled? Combine this with freezing with liquid Nitrogen to make it glassy, and high-powered ultrasound if necessary to shatter it?
Vibrate it out (pull hard while it or the panels around it are vibrated)?
I refuse to believe that there is any known material or composite that could not be gotten out of there using at least one of these techniques!
Seriously, a Dremmel Tool and a vacuum hose
They're NASA. Rejigger a Dremmel, attach a vacuum hose to suck up metal shaving, and cut the damned knob in half. The vac will suck up the metal bits, and you'll know it''s done when the vac sucks up half the knob when you're done.
Well, at least with three orbiters in the mix, if they need to take one out of the mix because of this fuck up (don't they have a spare window pane on the shelf somewhere?), I'm sure the other two can complete the damned job, so we can get around to twiddling our thumbs until the Dragon comes on-line, followed a few years later by Apollo on Steroids.
Yes kids, Steroids are bad, unless you have some localized swelling, or a Space Capsule...
Someone give NASA Lorena Bobitt's number
she's got previous in the whole knob-removal sphere
@ Seriously, a Dremmel Tool and a vacuum hose
Thy can manage with two Shuttles, but the time it takes to prepare a Shuttle for its next launch means that finishing the ISS will extend well into 2011.
http://www.spaceflightnow.com/shuttle/sts127/090624update/ sounds less pessimistic though. My money's om Atlantis launching in November though.
@@My Ex Girlfriend
"BTW. I wonder how much _more_ damage she did to the ecosystem - destroyed tabbycats, sorry: habitats, run-over beetles and small furry creatures, just to save one of a million bunnies.".
More to the point, although both she and her passenger walked away from that one, it was by sheer dumb luck... Fancy knowing that your driver will risk your life to save a rabbit that's stupid enough to be sat in the middle of the road.
I wonder how many furry critters get barbecued or broiled each time the the shuttle launches...
"Rogue knob could ground space shuttle Atlantis"
What a great headline!
That is all.
That may work (assuming that the sawing didn't put undue stress on the window) but the consequensces of even a tiny bit of swaf in the cabin, while weightless, could be serious in the extreme.
The two main reasons that pencils aren't used in space is because they chip off little bits of electrically conductive carbon when you write with them. And they are an excellent source of fuel, what with being made of wood. To make this worse, the cabin is a very high oxegen environment.
There are two obvious options. Slap a piece of duct-tape onto the windshield and call it fixed, or use a larger hammer to beat the windshield off, rip the knob out and install new windshield.
6 months is simply outrageous, at worst I could see it taking 1/3rd that to fab a new windshield (if they really don't have another lying about which would be surprising) , then another day to install and a week to test.
Loop a UHMWPE string around the area touching the glass and pull it. The filaments will act as a wedge to pry the two surfaces apart and UHMWPE is as slippery as Teflon. It's a fairly common string. Even some dental floss is made of it.
Coincidence? I think not.
AFAIK, this problem never happened until Windows Vista came along.
The trick to object removal from the dashboard
They can simply locally distort the dashboard in the vicinity of the knob in order to remove it. That's what I had to do to remove the GF's foot from the glove compartment.
Hmmm... if the pressure difference of being in space allowed the knob to get where it could be wedged, I wonder why they couldn't just pressurize the whole interior of the shuttle to 29.4 psia (or 14.7 plus whatever the exact ambient air pressure is that day). 29.4 psia would be 14.7 psig, if my physics knowledge is holding.
This would be similar to what Mythbusters did to a retired jet aircraft body in one episode.
That should result in a pressure differential between the interior and exterior of the orbiter that is the same as that which occurred when the knob became lodged in place. I suppose they could be concerned that the window (if damaged) could dislodge violently, causing more damage to the orbiter. That scenario should be familiar to anyone who has ever worked on old cars.... well, if it breaks when I take it off, I really don't care because I can't use it like this anyway!
PH, because that's the closest thing to an anti-boffin icon on the list ( IANARS = I am not a rocket scientist!).
No not what you're thinking...
Am I the only one worried about the fact that it takes NASA up to *six months* to replace a windscreen?
I start to sympathise with those folks who say that NASA needs to work on the ol' efficiency thing...
@Robert Forsyth re. Use acid or something to dissolve the stem of the knob
"..dissolve the stem/screw part, perhaps use an electric current to encourage a kind of reverse electroplating effect."
Do you work for DARPA?
Couldn't they just
Take off and nuke it from orbit....
Obviously using another shuttle! I'm not that drunk !!
These damn knobs are wreaking havoc on mother earth
they are in the UK government, US house of reprehensibles
I say nuke 'em
They can't overpressure the shuttle to 29.4 psia. There are things in there that won't take that much pressure, even though it's only 14.7psid relative to the atmosphere outside the shuttle. Little things, like cabin pressure sensors, pressurization control valves, and so forth. If you take the shuttle up to 14.7psid where it's sitting, you're gonna be replacing a bunch of other stuff. As it stands, they're only allowed to go to 3psid.
im with you man !!!!
but really is a window worth more than 6 months off line equipment and the staff to mantain it !
sounds more like a bofh excuse to get a new shuttle
... make a tool to remove it. Looking at the diagrams in the linked article, it should be possible to make a custom tool that would bend the petals of the knob without exerting any more stress on the window and retrieve it. It looks like it's made of brass, so it's soft as shit anyway.
If they send me the exact dimensions, I can knock something up for them by Friday, during which time, they could be building a test rig/mock up to make sure the tool works perfectly.
6 months my arse.
- Just TWO climate committee MPs contradict IPCC: The two with SCIENCE degrees
- Apple winks at parents: C'mon, get your kid a tweaked Macbook Pro
- SOULLESS machine-intelligence ROBOT cars to hit Blighty in 2015
- China in MONOPOLY PROBE into Microsoft: Do not pass GO, do not collect 200 yuan
- BuzzGasm! Thirteen Astonishing True Facts You Never Knew About SCREWS