back to article China brands Tibet beating video fake

The Chinese government has branded a YouTube video, purportedly showing Chinese police viciously beating Tibetan protesters, as a fake. The film, apparently taken last March near Lhasa, was put on the video sharing site last Saturday and is believed to be what sparked China's renewed blocking of the site. The second part of the …

COMMENTS

This topic is closed for new posts.
Unhappy

China sucks

China sucks.

0
0
Flame

‘China brands Tibet beating video fake’

i clearly see unarmed(some of them with clear tibetan dress) protester been beating up hard by military police/gestapo-like drones.

are you telling me that all that footage is fake?

ODFO!

Tibet free! ( from china and from the dalai lama, theocracy is shit too)

0
0
Anonymous Coward

it is fake

the chinese are much more violent than that

0
0
IT Angle

IT angle:

Tibet don't make cheap electronic gadgets.

Just films of unconfirmed authenticity.

0
0
Silver badge

So, China says it's fake, and blocks YouTube...

...so I guess that mean's it's for real, fersure!

0
0
Anonymous Coward

Uh-huh

Might be more credible if they hadn't just censored YouTube.

0
0
Thumb Down

Duh....

Surprised the Chinese government is saying the video is a fake? That's like Dubya saying that the Americans won the "war" in Iraq.

0
0
Stop

@ Daniel Garcia

If you knew anything about the Dalai Lama you would not say that. The man is universally loved by his people and with good reason. When your religion is your way of life, theocracy is just a word smart-arsed westerners use when they think they know better.

0
0
Unhappy

A bad policy which must be changed...

There's a huge campaign being orchestrated by the Chinese regime to paint events in Tibet in a way that is faithful to the party policy line. Much of it is blatant false propaganda.

There are frequent and blatently untruthful attempts to discredit His Holiness the Dalai Llama by claiming that he is a terrorist or the the instigator of a violent clique of insurgents - utterly ridiculous as anyone with an awareness of the pacifist Buddhist ideology and principles which holds non-violence and compassion among its central tenets.

The Pachem Llama chosen to suceed the Dalai Llama was kidnapped by the Chinese and is still being held hostage as the worlds youngest political prisioner.

All independant journalists and media are banned from Tibet and during the Olympic year access by any foreign persons was blocked to the so call Tibetan Autonomous Region, a deliberatly misleading label which is completely unrepresentative of the reality in Tibet.

Tibetans within the TAR region are discriminated against in a system of aparthaid that favours Han Chinese for jobs, housing, land and welfare. Anyone who takes issue with the occupying power is subject to the harshest dissproportionate treatment - expressing the wish for a return of the Dalai Llama or displaying the banned Tibetan flag can result in 10 years imprisionment.

Many have been tortured, killed or dissapeared.

Quite honestly the Chinese regime is brutal and unjust in its policy to Tibet and undeserved of a place as a respected member of the international community.

0
0
Silver badge
IT Angle

But it begs the question...

Is there a means by which a video being taken can be quickly and reliably proven to be realtime footage taken at a specific universal time and date and not altered in any way, thereby removing any possibility that the video was faked?

0
0
Coat

Gangrene ...

...Is the fakest of wounds, necrosis is nonexistant glorious peoples republic

0
0

maotsetards, surely?

Oh, sorry, liking the idea of free information is retarded and China's government is OK.

0
0
Anonymous Coward

Chinese Harmony

This is the "Harmony" that China espouses and would like to bring to the rest of the world.

0
0
Unhappy

Boycott Chinese goods.

Don't buy anything that comes out of china. Buy buying Chinese goods your are not only potentially poisoning yourself it seems, but supporting a tyrannical and oppressive government that regularly commits crimes against humanity. They should have been stopped long ago. But now their military abilities make and conflict a bad idea. The only hope is to change their ways by educating the people and hurting the Chinese government economically.

0
0

@ Charles

No.

0
0
Silver badge
Stop

They must have got that idea from us

Claiming something posted on the internet is fake and then censoring it (and/or sending the police after the guy posting it) is an *Australian* idea, thank you very much... I think the Chinese should at least give credit where it's due. We thought of it first!

0
0
Stop

Fake stuff?

I think the Chinese are masters at "fake"

Such as fake:

- Goods

- Propaganda

- Freedoms

Free Tibet !!!

0
0
Unhappy

Everyone

who took part in the Olympics or watched it on TV or took any interest in it is complicit in the torturous regime controlling that country.

Tianemen Square.

Any government working or in talks with China is implicitly giving their ok with the torture and wrongful imprisonment of their citizens.

Invasion of Tibet.

Sad face for the path we appear to be travelling.

0
0
Anonymous Coward

@@ Daniel Garcia By blackworx

Maybe you should make a bit of a studie yourself on tibet before the Chineese invaded on the request of the population in Tibet.

0
0
Silver badge

Re: China as "a respected member of the international community"

You forgot just one thing : China is respected as a member of the international community based on two things only : first, it can field an army of more men than most countries have people, and second, it has limitless market potential for capitalist money-grubbing CEO's to drool over.

Being respectful of people's rights has never been a criteria and probably never will be.

0
0
Silver badge
Black Helicopters

Pupils

No doubt our 2nd Home Secretary & the Straw Man are watching this carefully - and seeking out ideas regarding how to implement it.

Ludicrous, you think?

In the 1970's & 1980's, the idea that a so-called Labour government would institute and implement the restrictions on our freedoms and privacy that the last twelve years have seen would have been laughed at, and anyone suggesting it would have been dismissed as a conspiracy-theorist paranoid nut.

We have been warned.

0
0
Silver badge

Pots, kettles

At least waterboarding keeps them nice and clean.

0
0
This topic is closed for new posts.

Forums