Microsoft to act on IE8 'show stoppers'
GreyCells
IE 8 is Microsoft's first stab... #
Posted Thursday 29th January 2009 01:47 GMT

... at a standards-compliant version of its browser.
You've gotta admire a company that takes eight versions (and a little pressure from the EU) before it even considers trying to make a standards 'compliant' product. But where's SVG? Still stuck with the painfully slow VML for all those mapping applications.
Paris, 'cos she'll be pleased IE users will probably never get to see her between <video/> tags.
Anonymous Coward
8th time lucky? #
Posted Thursday 29th January 2009 01:47 GMT
Any chance of find-as-you-type? Or will I have to open that bloody Find... box whenever I'm forced to use IE?
How about being able to type an address into the address bar without the cursor jumping to the start of the line for some reason when the home page belatedly appears. Hands up who's had a ister.co.ukwwwthereg moment or similar.
Undo close tab?
If not, then bollox to it.
Steve Spiller
Alternate title #
Posted Thursday 29th January 2009 01:47 GMT

MS openly admit to releasing buggy crap on un^H^Hsuspecting world.
R Callan
Oh dear #
Posted Thursday 29th January 2009 03:43 GMT

It won't install, let alone run. Can any-one tell me where I can get the source so I can compile my own or a .deb?
Why doe's MS only supply app's for their own OS?
p.s.
I'm not going to try in wine (does that stand for WINdows Exposure? It does seem to allow MS malware a foothold in some cases).
Kanhef
Acid tests? #
Posted Thursday 29th January 2009 10:57 GMT
Any word on how the latest version does on acid2 and acid3?
Ash
@R Collins (And some of my own comments) #
Posted Thursday 29th January 2009 10:57 GMT
Source?! This has to be humour.
They make a Mac version of Office... I think that's it.
p.s.
Wine stands for WINE Is Not (an) Emulator
----
Showstopper for me? Stop button not responding instantly when loading the browser for the first time, forcing you to wait for the home page to partly appear, and taking focus away from the address bar when a page has fully loaded during typing a new URL.
Mark Aggleton
Oh dear #
Posted Thursday 29th January 2009 10:59 GMT

@ R Callan - Office for Mac.
@AC - Ctrl-F? and No never had that problem
However why doesn't it work with SharePoint explorer view - it's their own product FFS. Also why can you only raise queries if you're running in a non-domain environment?
TeeCee
@R Callan #
Posted Thursday 29th January 2009 10:59 GMT
"Why doe's MS only supply app's for their own OS?" (sic)
Actually they don't. Office for Mac is still popular and there are a few other things they put out knocking around on other platforms as well.
However, IE for Linux? I don't think we'll ever see this because it's not worth the effort to satisfy a demand of one installation (that'll be you, BTW).....
Trygve
Well this explains a lot.... #
Posted Thursday 29th January 2009 10:59 GMT
The bloke in charge of MS browser strategy is incapable of constructing a sentence, never mind a product.
"listening very critically for classically what's called" - oh dear.
"behaves the way you should expect the final product behaves" - oh dear again.
"The test suite and spec are a moment in time right now." - the test suite is brief period on a timeline? What?
Lionel Baden
@r callan #
Posted Thursday 29th January 2009 10:59 GMT
well why wouldnt they supply for their own OS ??
If they start making all those usefull little gadgets for other OS's and then support them for free ontop of it who's gunna buy Windows ?
i now have this image of a nun preaching the muslim faith lol
Rob Beard
ActiveX #
Posted Thursday 29th January 2009 10:59 GMT

Does it still come with the god awful ActiveX which Microsoft tried to put the friendly 'Addons' name to in IE7?
No Microsoft it's not an add-on, an Addon doesn't ask me for admin rights to install and generally isn't a gateway to malware hell.
Rob
Lozzyho
@R Callan #
Posted Thursday 29th January 2009 10:59 GMT
>> Why doe's MS only supply app's for their own OS?
Apart from Office for Mac, IE for Mac, Virtual PC for Mac et al, you mean?
frymaster
@AC - 8th time lucky #
Posted Thursday 29th January 2009 10:59 GMT
Any chance of find-as-you-type?
Undo close tab?
Yup
"Hands up who's had a ister.co.ukwwwthereg moment or similar."
never had that so can't comment
"We’re interested in reports of critical issues (e.g. security, backwards compatibility, completeness with respect to planned standards work, or robustness)" - from http://blogs.msdn.com/ie/archive/2009/01/26/internet-explorer-8-release-candidate-now-available.aspx - implies that if the proposed standard changes before ie8 is released, they _may_ well update ie 8.... if MS run true to form, they won't make page-display-behavior changes after release, though
Joe
At least they're trying! #
Posted Thursday 29th January 2009 11:13 GMT
I'm no MS fanboi, but at least they're giving it a shot. With a bit of luck within a year or two, IE7 and especially 6 will be gone or almost gone, and that will mean that my headache will have gone too.
Channel 9! Buono estente.
KenBW2
@R. Callan #
Posted Thursday 29th January 2009 12:47 GMT

Try getting Rhythmbox for Windows. what do you expect them to do? And more to the point, why do you want IE if it's not open source or Linuxy enough for you?
Oh, and learn to use apostrophes properly.
Idiot.
Disclaimer: I use Ubuntu
Goblin
@Acid tests? #
Posted Thursday 29th January 2009 12:47 GMT

IE8 fails the Acid3 test dismally on my XP machine at work with a woeful 20/100. I'd never install it at home, so I can't speak for how it runs on a decent PC.
Jon
no changes there then #
Posted Thursday 29th January 2009 12:47 GMT

so they're not going to fix any bugs that aren't absolutely critical? sounds like pretty much every other version of ie to me
Philip J.F. Quinlan
Tested on http://acid3.acidtests.org/`20% #
Posted Thursday 29th January 2009 12:47 GMT

Flies through the Acid2 test but fails worse then Firefox on Acid3
Chris Cheale
Must try harder... #
Posted Thursday 29th January 2009 12:47 GMT
------
Any word on how the latest version does on acid2 and acid3?
------
It does actually (seem to) pass Acid2 - which is a start - however, I ran the Acid 3 tests on all the browsers I have installed except Lynx (I'm a web developer - I have several for testing purposes).
None of them passed but Opera came out best at 85. The results were as follows:
Opera (9.63): 85 - consistently
Google Chrome (1.0.154.46): 77-79
Firefox (3.05): 71 (consistently)
IE8 (RC1): 12
Yay - go MS!
--- Fatal Exception ---
Sarcasm overload detected
Abort? Retry? Fail?
----------------------------
Goblin
@Must try harder... #
Posted Thursday 29th January 2009 13:49 GMT

Interestingly, the alpha release of Opera 10 scores 100/100. It's fast too. Maybe they've got it right this time?
Mark
@Chris Cheale #
Posted Thursday 29th January 2009 13:49 GMT

If you want a build of Opera that does 100/100 on Acid2 and Acid3, then you should grab the latest Opera 10 snapshot here:
http://my.opera.com/desktopteam/blog/
Giles Jones
The cancer of open source and GPL #
Posted Thursday 29th January 2009 14:09 GMT
Funny how long Microsoft spent slagging off open source and the GPL, yet these days it is where they get all their best product ideas from.
Probably wouldn't have been an IE8 or IE7 without Firefox. The gap between IE6 and IE7 was *five* (count them) FIVE years! Yet the gap between IE7 and IE8 could be a mere year or two.
Open source such as Firefox, Apache and Linux keeps Microsoft on its toes. You have to wonder why they hate competition so much (and why they try their best to eliminate it) when competition is shown to improve innovation, something that Microsoft seems to boast about having all the time.
Simon
@ Joe #
Posted Thursday 29th January 2009 14:20 GMT
IE6 won't be going anytime soon. Until large corps obtain millions for new computers I'm afraid that IE6 and maybe 7 are here to stay...
DutchOven
@TeeCee #
Posted Thursday 29th January 2009 18:50 GMT

>> Why doe's MS only supply app's for their own OS?
> Apart from Office for Mac, IE for Mac, Virtual PC for Mac et al, you mean?
Mwah hah hah. Funny one. Last I looked IE5 was the last version for the Mac and even that is no longer available.
Anonymous Coward
ie 8 rc1 inconsistent behaviour #
Posted Friday 30th January 2009 01:11 GMT
anyone else having an issue with ie8 rc1 not clearing cookies consistently? also, i've noticed different rendering of the same site / page using ie 8 rc1 on two different windows platforms, namely vista vs. xp.
Anonymous Coward
@ Mark Aggleton #
Posted Friday 30th January 2009 01:11 GMT

SharePoint is bloated and has far too much lag to be functional for its supposed purpose on anything approaching a large network. Try Compass, we had more luck with that.
Anthony Garrett
IE8 - worse than IE7 #
Posted Sunday 1st February 2009 00:20 GMT
IE8 up to the latest Beta hasn't supported XHTML properly - a major flaw. Until it does it shouldn't even be considered for release.