See a bandwidth-friendly version of this video here Can't see the video? Download Flash Player from Adobe.com Our Most Popular CES Video Reports... Nokia N97 touchscreen webphone demo'd Samsung boffins demo transparent OLED screen Palm Pré demo of WebOS and UI Boffins offer plastic printing service Sony Vaio P netbook …
Hit or miss?
Not a bad concept, but perhaps not too functional. Imagine a family of four sat watching TV, imagine the squabble it would create! They might say in that case a backup conventional remote would be available but that would mean this gesture control is simply an expensive inefficient add-on, rather than the real deal. Watching TV aside, gesture control for computer input, gaming etc.. could really take off.
Only 1 problem..
.. now you can't stop the missus from watching whatever shite she wants by hiding the remote (unless you cut her hands off).
This isn't the channel you're looking for.
Why would anyone want to go to such a great effort to do something you can do with the nudge of a finger tip? Gimmick. Touch-less gesture technology is largely a technology that has no real use looking for a use.
I see this coming on at 2AM...
This isn't the channel I'm looking for.
They already tried this on the "Heart of Gold". It meant sitting infuriatingly still....
These are not the droids you're looking for
Gawd, teh h0tz0r! So I will be able to control my TV by wildly flailing my arms in front of it, as if I was performing some rad Jedi-mind-trick on it? That's just great. And stupid me hoped developers would spend their time on making TVs more energy-efficient while producing a better picture...
So no more watching porn then I guess
Unless you want the volume (or whatever) going up and down I guess.
What happens when i start trying to play wii games on this thing, it'll send it crazy.
Not to be used by any family who under normal circumstances fights for control of the remote.
is it wii-compatible?
..is the sort of stuff that will sell.
I'm just wondering what tech it uses to track, what the range will be and how susceptible it is to accidental activation. If they sort all that out hen it's goodbye remote.
Sod all that waving the hands around crap. It's easier just to use the remote.
How do you program that into, say, a Harmony One?
can't help but think that one wants a bunch of wank gesture as well.
Let me be the first to ask:
...what does it do if you're watching porn?
The kids will love this...
How many times have your parents said "I have the controls, so I choose the channel" and put on something crap. Now, anyone can control (or interfer with) the TV. Can you imagine the all-out family arguments now?
...until it detects unwanted gestures.
Good luck using it while playing Wii.
"For years radios had been operated by means of pressing buttons and turning dials; then as the technology became more sophisticated the controls were made touch-sensitive - you merely had to brush the panels with your fingers; now all you had to do was wave your hand in the general direction of the components and hope. It saved a lot of muscular expenditure of course, but meant that you had to sit infuriatingly still if you wanted to keep listening to the same programme."
I sometimes wonder what they think...
"What can we design today?"
"I know, what about a less intuitive, complicated control system that will be easy to activate by mistake (probably at the crucial moment)"
What happens when you...
Flip off the TV by being disgusted with the content? The only assumption is that the gestures are deemed obscene by some culture somewhere in the world.
Now if it would transmit the gestures back to the originating studio so I can get involved in the events of the day (or those of next Tuesday [USA only]).
Another thought: What happens when you stick your tongue at it, giving it your personal "raspberry"?
Another solution: Get a "Clapper!".
It was voice controlled
I did something like this
My honours project at uni was a gesture controlled television (okay, the television bit was a fake in vlc running starwars fanfilms, film trailers and red vs blue episodes but never mind that bit)
After a short while playing with it it became very intuitive to use. I was lazy and just after the marks so it used a menu with four directions as controls. Assuming you were wearing sleeves and sitting in the designated chair (lazy remember?) you could channel hop, control the volume and torture people with the bee gees with ease.
Bloody Great Idea
For most of the couch potatoes I know it would double the calories burned in a day waving their arms like that ! Which is why it wont take off until they develop the 'slight twitching of the finger' version :)
Re:Only 1 problem..
Well, slightly more than one problem really. I make all sorts of "gestures" in the direction of the TV when I'm losing at various console games, and I don't even want to think about what would happen if you tried to play a Wii game.
Ok, so they could allow you to turn the feature off when you didn't want accidental, or other peoples, or gaming gestures changing the channel for you. Then you'd have to reach for the remote to re-enable it, which kind of makes it completely pointless.
Factor in to that the TV changing channels when you're simply trying to explain the plot of a film to your other half for the hundredth time and this feature seems to be the most pointless inclusion since Britney's underwear drawer.
Techies can be great at inventing stuff but this is one of the cases where someone needed to go, 'err....hang on a sec'.....
Beaten to the Hitchhikers reference!
I am 'assuming' that this uses some kind of camera to detect the movements, and it makes me wonder what else it can 'detect' especially if you can wave to turn it on. (kinda means it wasnt off in the first place..........)
Do vans with blacked out windows.......................
Turn up if I flick the V's at Gordon Brown when he comes on telly or Boy George arrive when I moon at the Queens Speech
Imagine an Italian family sitting in front of the TV having a conversation. All that hand gesturing would confuse the poor thing!
- Hi-torque tank engines: EXTREME car hacking with The Register
- Review What's MISSING on Amazon Fire Phone... and why it WON'T set the world alight
- Product round-up Trousers down for six of the best affordable Androids
- Product round-up Ten excellent FREE PC apps to brighten your Windows
- Why did it take antivirus giants YEARS to drill into super-scary Regin? Symantec responds...