The Register® — Biting the hand that feeds IT

UFO wind turbine prang site sealed

Page:

mark

funny 

Thumb Up

but a (MOD) spokesman said: "That's so secret it's beyond above top secret, I'm afraid."

what a comedian!

cant blame hin in light of the nature of the allegation / enquiry

Benny

Damn, I was wrong 

Alien

And there I was thinking it was a lump of blue ice from an air-o-plane..

Anonymous Coward

er... 

If it was my wind farm, I wouldn't want a bunch of gullible/deranged/clinically insane/paranoid idiots running around on my private property trying to make off with "souvenirs" either.

oxo

Well.. 

Alien

I for one welcome our new windmill-smashing overlords.

Ian Ferguson

What? 

Stop

“If a stealth aircraft struck the turbine, it may be made of some material which is itself classified above top secret.”

Eh? Or, it might be made out of steel. Or carbon fibre. Or cheese. It may be shaped like a raspberry. Or it may have come from Mars. Or you might be speaking out of your arse. Idiot.

Occam's razor means nothing to these people. Is there an equivalent expression that assumes the most complicated, unlikely explanation for the simplest of mysteries? How about Occam's Gillette Mach3 Turbo Champion?

Perpetual Cyclist

Don't ya just love it? 

Alien

The great advantage of conspiracy theorists is that it is impossible to prove them wrong. Just imagine the lawer's fees if a UFOlogist was injured or killed by a falling , broken turbine blade, as he sought to retrieve incontrovertible proof of our alien overlords. Of course site security has been beefed up. We must keep that evidence (of inadequate maintenance? ) from the public at all costs.

The sad thing is that it all distracts from serious conspiracies like the stitch up of alternative energy suppliers by the nuclear lobby....

Lyndon Hills

Playmobil 

After reading the first paragraph I expected a playmobil depiction of the site. We know you have most of the necessary elements.

JonB

"an ultrasecret robot stealth aircraft project"... 

...would actually be a "UFO" wouldn't it.

fLaMePr0oF

3rd Rock Stupidity? 

Alien

Technologically super advanced aliens traveled light years across the reaches of space to visit earth and... crash their ship into a wind turbine? Even the mention of ET's in this instance is absurd in the extreme.

MattW

UFO's my ar*e 

So one blade failing at the hub couldn't take out another as the windmill continued to rotate?

Anonymous Coward

Experts=Shepherds? 

Go

"Security operatives backed by snarling dogs"

"German experts have indeed now moved in"

Anonymous Coward

As predicted then 

Start a UFO flap and see what happens.

As soon as there's a flap UFO "enthusiasts" will be all over it with their cameras and geiger counters. The people who own the alleged location of the UFO incident don't want a load of people running all over it so they increase security. The UFO crowd will then claim the increased security proves there is something to cover up.

Enquiries conclude that a perfectly normal incident is responsible (equipment failure, fireworks, civil air traffic, whatever). The UFO crowd state that this is proof that there is a cover up.

The MOD deny that anything unidentified showed up on radar at the time. The UFOlofists say that this means something IDENTIFIED showed up on radar and therefore the incident was caused by a top secret stealth vehicle.

MOD deny that any such vehicle exists. To a UFOlogist an outright denial is concrete proof.

Rinse and repeat for as long as it takes you to get bored with the convoluted (ahem!) logic of the UFOlogist.

Ad Fundum

Challenge Churchill! 

Black Helicopters

Dale Vince of Ecotricity, which operates the site, said last week: "We don't have an explanation at the moment as to what the cause was. We have been crawling all over it and have sent bits off for analysis to see if we can work out what caused it. Until we have some idea, some plausible explanation that it was not a UFO, I don't think we should rule it out."

Good luck trying to claim that one back on your insurance.

ben

hmm 

Alien

"That's so secret it's beyond above top secret, I'm afraid."

Surely that’s an admission that they in fact do have some secret alloy!!!

Lee Stacey

Of course 

Alert

It was a UFO.

It is unidentified

It was flying

It has to be an object.

Duh.

Anonymous Coward

Bloody loonies. 

Pirate

It's incredible that these loonies can't see that the investigators simply want to avoid the evidence (ie shards of windmill) being stolen by loonies who then sell it on eBay as "alien composite material".

As the bleat about wanting to know "the truth", their little paranoid expeditions make it impossible for anyone else (like, maybe, someone with the appropriate qualifications and experience) to actually find out the actual truth.

Can't we medicate these people?

Pirate: cos they're thick as two short planks -- and they probably believe the "walk the plank" myth, too!

James Pickett

Occam's razor 

A simpler, but boring, explanation may be that one the blades sheared and hit the other one on the way down. I can't imagine that a race clever enough to have mastered interstellar travel would then have an accidental prang with a wind turbine...

richard

don't be... 

Black Helicopters

so fucking stupid!

...a machine went faulty...

next story....

Anonymous Coward

ETs should go home! 

Black Helicopters

Are you trying to tell me that it really wasn't a blade snapping off, hitting and thus bending a second blade and that they've restricted access to the site because there is a chance that the same could happen to a second turbine?

Dammit....

Eddy Ito

Wasting time 

Alien

They shouldn't waste time getting that thing fixed. Skip the investigation and get it back up and running. Ye gods and little fishes, we need them things running to keep our skies clear. So get 'er back up sweeping the heavens of those nasty little green men and their tall purple three twatted wormen or fembotys or whatever they call them.

Geeks and Lies

Seriously considering investing in Tin Foil Hat business..... 

Alien

they're comming, they're comming!

Whilst it would be great to finally answer the question of life on other planets, but sadly i feel any race advanced enough to get here in the first place would be sufficiently equiped to deal with avoiding a windturbine!

Bad Beaver

170ft 

Paris Hilton

That big, that low, merely scraping a single rotor in a whole field of windmills?

ChrisInBelgium

We all know what exactly 

Black Helicopters

The tower was of course struck by a weather balloon! It's obvious, isn't it?

Mongers

The Old Foe 

Flame

Personally I blame the Soviets.

Richard

U.F.O. 

Thumb Down

"We don't have an explanation at the moment as to what the cause was. We have been crawling all over it and have sent bits off for analysis to see if we can work out what caused it."

So assuming it was indeed a flying object, then as they say it is yet to be identified. It is therefore a UFO, until such time as it is positively identified.

"Until we have some idea, some plausible explanation that it was not a UFO, I don't think we should rule it out."

In other words; "Until we don't not know what it is, we can't be sure that we won't not know what it is."

David Webb

Above Top Secret 

Black Helicopters

Isn't that obvious? Its "do not allow civil servants to handle these documents, they are secret and we really mean it this time, no leaving it on trains or on computers at MP's home where the local plod can come and have a gander whenever they feel like it, its REALLY secret, although we will share the information with the yanks at some time so they can say 'hey, thats really cool, we'll steal that tech from you now' but other than that, no one is to know about it, not even me, or the PM but then he is a bit of a dick, so yeah, its super top secret and if I find any information about this project on youtube I'm going to cancel the xmas party this year"

Naturally its way too big to put on everything (Top Secret fits just right) so they just write down on it "Really Top Secret!!!!!" with lots of !!!!!!'s

Helicopter cause now they know that I know what they know about what I know about their secret secrets!

TeeCee

If a real UFO *were* to crash.... 

Coat

......would we have to put up with interminable conspiracy theories that the crash was actually caused by plain old pilot error and not the destabilisation of the monomolecular matrix in the thrunging washers of the starboard photonic interrupt array at all?

Peyton

...classified above top secret 

Happy

Would he be referring to super-duper top secret??

Anonymous Coward

of corse 

Alien

"That's so secret it's beyond above top secret, I'm afraid."

of corse they would say that it is so secret that you needed to be rated top secret for them to tell you it exists

Anonymous Coward

Ironman test flight? 

Gates Halo

R-tards, its obviously Bill Gates in an Iron Man suit...

jeremy

UFO != aliens 

Black Helicopters

If an object is unidentified then it is a a UFO, if it turns out to be something that is identified then its not a UFO anymore.

Besides what would make any alien life want to come to this sh*t hole?

Anonymous John

an ultrasecret robot stealth aircraft project? 

Coat

Lights in the sky?

if that's the MOD's idea of a stealth plane, I think they need to go back to the drawing board.

Mine's the one with the sleeve mysteriously ripped off.

Ron Luther

None. None More Secret! 

Boffin

How much more secret could it be?

Anonymous Coward

What's the religious fundamentalist position? 

after all, if they're letting every Tom, Dick and Harry with half a brain cell to run around spouting bollocks, what's to say it wasn't the work of one of any number of gods, or even my main man Cthulu?

Anonymous Coward

Protective Markings 

Britain doesn't have any protective markings above secret - to the best of my knowledge.

There are caveats which afford higher level of protection, but I'm not aware of any 'main' marking higher than TS.

I believe in America it's different.

Anonymous Coward

lizard alliance? 

Alien

I, for one, velcome our wind-turbine destroying overlords.

JonB

Aliens != UFO 

If we know it's an alien spacecraft then we have identified it, so that wouldn't be a UFO either.

Owen Carter

Solved? 

Black Helicopters

http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/organgrinder/2009/jan/08/windpower-thesun

Naah.. not really, but an illuminating read nonetheless..

Anonymous Coward

UFOlogy, @AC 

"MOD deny that any such vehicle exists. To a UFOlogist an outright denial is concrete proof."

Unlikely.

It's people like you making rediculous remarks like that, that give UFO investigators a bad name.

I would suggest you read Stanton T. Friedman's book PhD. who is a nuclear physicist who started off his career developing protective shielding for nuclear reactors to power space craft.

His methodical approach to proving/disproving, chasing every witness statement down, looking for corrobative evidence from a number of disparate sources, checking many archives across the USA is how an investigation should be done in order to determine the authenticity of documents.

Do I believe in UFOs? No. Well, not yet anyway. Do I believe the American airforce and other organisations are covering something up, witholding evidence? Yes. If you read Friedman's book about his personal dealings with various government agencies, that can be the only logical explanation.

Do I believe a UFO hit the wind turbine? No. My guess it's nothing other than a mechanical failure.

Duckorange

For the love of God 

Paris Hilton

Marsh gas.

Planet Venus.

Q E D

Phil the Geek

UFD = Unidentified Flying Deity 

The site is sealed because of the amount of pasta remnants strewn around. The offending turbine was smote by the Flying Spaghetti Monster, for reasons that only He may know.

vale

Its obvious isn't it? 

Alien

Swamp Gas! Has to be.

Robert E A Harvey

@MattW 

Alien

The problem with one blade rotating and hitting the failing one is that in the weather we have had since the new year the wretched things were not turning at all...

Anonymous Coward

@ Protective Markings 

Coat

"Britain doesn't have any protective markings above secret - to the best of my knowledge."

Yes it does.

Mine''s the one with the Torchwood logo.

Anonymous Coward

@ AC spouting on about Friedman's book 

Black Helicopters

"If you read Friedman's book about his personal dealings with various government agencies, that can be the only logical explanation."

If you read Harry Potter books then you may very well believe their is a secret school for for young wizzards teaching them the fine art of magic, doesnt mean its true though.

Any tin foil left over so I can make a hat too?

ShaggyDoggy

Centre of the New Universe 

Well I live in Lincolnshire, and I am so happy that our new but somewhat dodgy flyer UFO overlords have chosen our county to set up their death star base super central control hub city complex.

It will make such a change from potatoes and brocolli.

Wait ...

Liam Johnson

@fLaMePr0oF 

Alien

>> Technologically super advanced aliens traveled light years across the reaches of space to visit earth and... crash

Duh! Unless they were on auto-pilot back to the point they visited 2 billion years ago and were not expecting their bacteria to have evolved so far.

REMF

FSM 

brings new meaning to the phrase; "touched by his noodly appendage".

richard

link to genius story: 

Stop

http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/news/ufos/article2120065.ece

bollocks to the economy, get a 'vicious' dog and guard a 'secret' field.....

Ex-IT

Yah Bollocks... 

Alien

It was Aliens on a shopping trip, out to pick-up a bargain at Woolies closing down sale.

Page: