ITV fined millions for phone fraud
Anonymous Coward
re: Catherine Tate #
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 12:40 GMT

Anything that stops this completely unfunny person getting an award for comedy is fine by me.
Anonymous Coward
Lawyer speak.. #
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 12:51 GMT

"Finally, and for the avoidance of doubt, there is no suggestion that Robbie Williams, Anthony McPartlin or Declan Donnelly were aware of any of these issues."
Meaning: "..and there had better not be, either."
I'd be interested to know how the fine was calculated and whether or not the company and individuals involved are still better-off for running these scams. Somehow I suspect they are still giggling all the way to the bank.
My forumla would be..
Add all income from phone calls to the programs, along with all advertising revenue generated by them, add 20%.
Eponymous Cowherd
Ant, Dec, and Robbie knew nothing? #
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 12:53 GMT

A strange thing happened while I went out for lunch. A large pile of pig shit fell from the sky and landed right in front of me.
Paris, cos she'd believe it.
Hollerith
'People's Choice Awards' #
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 13:13 GMT
These 'awards' have zero validity, importance or interest. It's like the Top 100 Whatever that Channel 5 etc use as schedule fodder. The idea of having to choose between Ant & Dec and Catherine Tate is the choice between eating polyester or nylon. Neither tasty nore good for you.
Mike Tree
Fine? #
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 13:15 GMT
So what happens to the £5.67M fine?
Joe
ITV #
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 13:15 GMT

One could argue that people who watch this tat are too thick to understand any of this anyway. Perhaps Ant and Dec should present an "ITV Big Fine Saturday Special Extravaganza" where the couch potatoes vote for which charity the money goes to? There could be Tonight-style "investigative journalism" pieces with scary music so they know who the baddies are.
Mike Richards
What exactly are executive producers? #
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 13:15 GMT
Ant and Dec are listed as executive producers of their show and yet claim not to know the votes were rigged. Hmmm...
Anonymous Coward
erm... #
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 13:19 GMT
Aren't Ant and Dec directors of the production company that produces their saturday night programme?
richard
ant and decs new show...... #
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 13:35 GMT

"I'm an executive producer...get me out of here...."
...in a blacked-out limo, with lots of legal advice and a gormless, cheeky-chappie, 'wot happened there then?' grim on yer big, useless face.
better still - forget the fines - just ban ITV! anyone object?
Gordon Pryra
re: Catherine Tate #
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 13:35 GMT

I think the vote count was correct.
They deducted 99% of her votes due to her appaling performance in Dr Who
john oates
@ Mike #
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 13:35 GMT
hello,
Just rang Ofcom - the fine goes to the Treasury.
cheers
john
Anonymous Coward
Lawyer speak (2) #
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 13:56 GMT

It's a sad day when even lawyers are semi-illiterate... he/she misspelled "dependent"... a "dependant" (noun) is someone who is dependent on another.
Steve Crook
Money for old rope... #
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 14:29 GMT
This looks like a good wheeze to get more money for our chancellor. I predict many more Of*** investigations that result in record fines...
Ad Fundum
Donna Noble #
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 14:29 GMT

I emailed the Beeb at the weekend to ask when they would be broadcasting Doctor Who episodes without Donna Noble/Catherine Tate. I have loved that program my whole life, but I just can't watch it any more. As soon as the BBC can be bovvered to return my email, I'll post the dates here. And on every other website known to man, woman, dalek, sontaran, ood...
Stuart Moore
As much as I hate to say it... #
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 15:04 GMT

Catherine Tate isn't nearly as bad in Dr Who as she was in the special. The last few episodes have worked quite well really...
Ed Courtenay
@Ad Fundum #
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 16:09 GMT

Yes, RTD could have cast a better companion than Catherine Tate, but seriously - she's the first one to make you switch off? Were you watching when Bonnie Langford was squealing along with 6Doc/7Doc? Adric? Teegan? Come on...
Mines the coat with the extra long scarf ensemble...
Ade W
Next headlline I'd like to see ... #
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 16:09 GMT
... "BT fined millions for telecommunications fraud"
Anonymous Coward
Ant and Dec or Catherine Tate? #
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 16:09 GMT

Well, I know which I'd prefer to find in my bed...
Luther Blissett
Fraud and FRAUD #
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 18:11 GMT
If a little company like ITV can be fined so much for a little fraud in the overall scale of things, then how much should the big banks be fined for end-running around the regulations on their capital reserves by lending and then shoving the loans off balance sheet?
Like so much else, regulation is a simulation which requires occasional exercise in peripheral areas, as here, to occlude the fact that there is no regulation at the rotten core.
Anonymous Coward
Not enough... not even nearly enough #
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 18:11 GMT
The company should've been fined the amount of fraud + a discretionary fine (i.e. 12 million minimum), and the executive producers of the show should've been fined as well. They are executive producers for a reason, and they should be aware of the consequences of this kind of fraud.
Anonymous Coward
PJ+Duncan => Gallowgate Productions =>Saturday Night Ripoff #
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 19:46 GMT

www.gallowgatetv.com
"Gallowgate was founded in 2004 by two of British TV’s most successful stars, Ant McPartlin and Declan Donnelly."
"Gallowgate co-produces Saturday Night Takeaway and shares an interest in the format and ancillary rights with ITV"
Nice "work" if you can get it; better still if you can persuade loads of other suckers... viewers to pay you handsomely for it.
But if you get caught with your fingers in the till, as they and others have been, it should be more than a few quid at stake.
Anonymous Coward
Spineless OFCOM #
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 20:27 GMT

Typical OFCOM! They flatly refuse to do anything about the wastes of oxygen that are our TV, phone and bradband providers, and now they fine ITV what amounts to nothing more than pocket money to the multi multi multi multi million pound company! What a waste of space.
J-Wick
Teegan... #
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 20:36 GMT

I remember Teegan being an annoying American with a nice rack.
I *was* a teenager at the time though, so my standards were a lot lower.
Actually no, they're the same as they are now...
Anonymous Coward
Tegan #
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 23:25 GMT

Tegan was the annoying Australian.
J-Wick is probably thinking of Peri, who pretended to be American.
I can't stand Tate either but acknowledge this is merely personal prejudice and bear her no ill will.
Whatever our irrational feelings about the woman, if she received most votes she should have been given the award.
Adam T
Blah #
Posted Friday 9th May 2008 00:15 GMT

Nothing new about vote rigging in TV awards.
Catherine Tate losing out? What about Blue Planet losing out to Big Brother for best production a few years back?
Cough. Splutter. Come off it.
Paris, cause she appears to have a migraine.
Anonymous Coward
Hands off Tegan ! #
Posted Friday 9th May 2008 04:44 GMT

She's mine, all mine!
Anonymous Coward
What an F-Ing Liberty! #
Posted Friday 9th May 2008 07:47 GMT

What an F-Ing Liberty!
Slaine
@ John Oats #
Posted Friday 9th May 2008 14:00 GMT

after: "Just rang Ofcom - the fine goes to the Treasury"... nice one, so the general public gets ripped off by a bunch of media crooks in cahootz with a bunch of telecommunications crooks, then the general public pay for the investigation via the Government Coffers and finally the fine (gathered from profits made by abusing the general public with adverts) goes straight to the treasury.
And they refer to the Triads as "organised crime". If I want to get shafted, I'd prefer to use my own thumb.