Feeds

back to article US appeals court smacks down FCC obscenity rule

Fans of open-mic celebrity blunders rejoice! The 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals has just ruled that the Federal Communication Commission's recent shift in its standards for obscenities uttered during a broadcast violated administrative rulemaking requirements. After declaring the new standards null and void, the court vacated an …

COMMENTS

This topic is closed for new posts.

A Glimpse Of Stocking

Tracing the history of manners is a funny joke. Perhaps the best guide is 'The Civilizing Process' by Norbert Elias. In Canada the two volume work addressed the history of manners and power and civility. Manners are a convention. They amount to a handshake.

The nobility in ignorance tied opulence to grace and the servant and working classes practised monkey see, monkey do. Grace stemmed from the gods in the form of power and wealth. 'Dieu et mon Droit' set the standards of the day and in an way still do today. The waltz was once a counter culture dance to be seen only in out of the way, unlit places, now is the signature form of politesse. Lords and Ladies were house broken and stopped taking a dump on the living room carpet, and, instead, politely squatted deep over the cold ashes of the hearth. Power brokers have used social convention in the form of civility as a means to shame the uninitiated. The gig is up. It's time to stop those who don't get the joke that they'll never dance la minuet in the hall of the Sun King. At Waterloo Napoleon (perhaps apocryphal) said of his opposition, "they have finally stopped dancing la mineut", by which he meant the opposing forces no longer marched obligingly forward in lock step to be slaughtered by his grape shot. Civility in society serves as well in today's world as would the polite rules of engagement from a post renaissance field of battle in Iraq. (Oddly this has some truth to it as we fight terrorists as if they were signatories to the Hague Conventions, we engage the enemy but wage war as if with ourselves).

Society, such as it is, sets standards, but such standards, barring hate crimes, needn't be set by fiat. The various social tribes can set and enforce their own standards and do. A warning in the preamble of a public broadcast is enough. Major streets in most, if not all, western cities have stores selling sex toys and pornography. Children pass such stores every day, but don't gawk because it's all but meaningless to them. Puberty hits and they seek such places out.

0
0

FCC regulation of cable and satillite

Meanwhile, the FCC, in a power grab, is seeking to regulate "standard" cable and satellite. I guess a recent airing of "Hustle" on AMC where Stacy says "this is bullshit" would have prompted a fine.

The FCC needs to come into the 21st century. I've heard 13 year olds using "shit" and "fuck" (and much worse), so we're not really protecting innocent ears. Any parent who let their children watch "NYPD Blue" has only them self to blame for the kid picking up "naughty language".

0
0

Re: A Glimpse of Stocking

Hi Greg. Still talking gibberish I see.

0
0

Title

Someone should send these guys a dvd of south park..

0
0

Single person complained?

Lemme get this straight: ONE person complained about the NYPD Blue episode? ONE FUCKING PERSON?!?!?! AND THEY CONSIDERED LEVYING A FINE?!?!?

I weep for my America. No matter what, there will always be one twat who bitches, moans, and complains something is indecent. Please, you folks across the pond, don't get the idea that we're all like this. I grew up in a household where if there was profanity on the TV, one of two things happened: My mother turned it off (What a novel idea! I should write a parenting book!) or I was warned that using such language would result in swift and painful buttock punishment. My son is still in the pants-shitting stage, but I plan on using similar discipline.

Oh, but we must 'think of the children'...here's a novel concept: think of your own goddamn children, not mine: be a parent, don't whine for the government to do your God-and-nature-given job for you. You lazy, whiny fucks.

I'll make you a deal, Euroboffins: Don't assume we're all fundie crazies and gang-bangers, and I'll assume you're not all chavs.

0
0
Tom
Bronze badge

George Carlin should be proud...

...of his "seven words". Now he can hear them on the Radio/TV

0
0
This topic is closed for new posts.